Should i trade Tomlinson for Addai, Fitzgerald, and Mcnabb or trade him for.....?

Question

T.Jones, P. Rivers, S. Smith panthers steve smith not giants, Westbrook.....at QB ive got campbell,pennington (yeah this draft was on autopilot this team is the worst one i have so i put tomlinson on the block to get some value) HB tomlinson,m.barber,a.peterson,d.foster and at wideout edwards,cotchery,williamson,jarrett,m.jones should i do either of those or hold on to tomlinson i figure now would be the time to trade tomlinson if i do cause his stock couldnt get any higher than it is now

Answer 1

first one dude, if LT is the number 1 running back then Addai is at least top 5 so you even out pretty close there and you get top 3 receiver Fitzgerald and top 3 QB Mcnabb if he stays healthy so you get 3 players in the top 5 at their positions, good job buddy

Answer 2

On first read I was tempted to say go for the Addai/Fitzgerald/McNabb combo, but after a moment of consideration the 4-player package is the way to go. I love Addai this year, but your second HB is two weak - gotta leave the transaction with two starters, and Jones/Westbrook fits the bill. They won't be spectacular, but will be better than Addai/Barber/Peterson. Hang onto Peterson - might be good trade bait in a few weeks.

Answer 3

Do the second deal.

Tomlinson will have a top 5 season, but not like he did last year. Last year, Chargers' offensive coord Cameron went with LT early and often, because he did not have confidence in Rivers yet. Defenses will also be keying on LT, leaving receivers open down field. The Chargers also want to get Michael Turner involved more, both to take the load off of LT and to showcase Turner in his last season on his contract.

Look for Rivers to have a break-out season, throwing to Gates over the middle, Vincent Jackson (6'-5") at the goal line, rookie Craig Davis, and LT too (but not enough to warrant not making a trade).

Smith will have his usual monster season after last year's let-down. And, you have to love an RB like Westbrook who gets a lot of passes thrown his way.

Answer 4

Was that second deal Rivers, Jones, Smith, and Westbrook? I would take either of these deals, but particularly the second one. Both of them address your glaring weaknesses at QB and 3rd WR. The second deal also takes care of your problem at 2nd RB. Neither Barber nor Peterson is likely to be a back you want to start week in and week out; both of them are stuck on the short end of platoons, and barring injuries to Jones and Taylor they won't get enough carries to make them weekly starters. The combo of Westbrook and Jones is likely to produce numbers at least equal to LT and Barber/Peterson, and quite possibly somewhat better. McNabb was the #1 QB in fantasy by a wide margin last year before he got hurt. Steve Smith is just a beast, and he'll be fully healthy all year and catching passes from his favorite QB, Jake Delhomme, from the get-go. You're not likely to get more total value than that for Tomlinson; the odds of him coming even close to repeating last season's numbers are fairly low, and getting 4 top-end starters for him is definitely maximizing his potential.

Answer 5

good Morning, This commerce will actual benefit you. every time you will get the huge form a million participant in fantasy activities it particularly is a great commerce. you have already got the main suitable QB so dropping youthful isn't that good sized a deal and Losman is a workable backup(third QB on your team) Fitzgerald is likewise plenty better than Burress so because it particularly is yet another plus to the commerce. seem at this beginning lineup: Mannning & McNabb Tomlinsson & Henry or MJD Fitzgerald, Wayne & Moss you have the main suitable participant and maximum suitable QB in the NFL. To me this would properly be a no-brainer. good success! thank you.

Answer 6

Do the rivers smith jones and westbrook deal. I assume that Brian Westbrook?

Answer 7

Don't make a trade. It would take 2 of those players to equal L.T.s points.

Answer 8

I like the second deal you mentioned and I would make that deal ASAP. You are getting four solid starters which will make your team better week to week.

Answer 9

Hang onto LaDanian Tomlinson. Good Luck. Thanks.