pound for pound the best college football atmoshere?!!?

Question

emphisis on pound for pound! im talking about the actual school, town and gametime atmosphere. once again pound for pound, its easy to say michigan, penn state or tennessee with 100k+ fans in the stands, 50k+ students and national tv coverage but does that compare with 60k screaming at hawaii with no or minimal tv coverage, thousands of miles from the nearest school, little local recruit base and a school with 20k students? no! i have been to over 50 different stadiums and games across divisions and i have to say pound for pound, fan for fan, student for student, citizen for citizen i believe that best college football atmoshere is........ the univesity of montana!( im an east coast guy that didnt go to montana or was born in montana) when you consider the school has 12k students the town has 60k and the state has right at a million people, you will be blown away by the way that program is embraced by the people of western montana!

j-dub while i respect ou and see where your coming from, 30k students, national tv coverage, national fan base, consistant heisman canidates and winners sort of stacks the odd in their favor and pound for pound weakens them in this context. in this context only!

Answer 1

This is per Kirk Herbstriet

Best stadium atmospheres
1. Texas A&M
2. Tennessee
3. LSU (at night)
4. Florida
5. Oregon
6. Washington
7. Virginia Tech (at night)

http://espn.go.com/ncf/preview02/columns/herbstreit_kirk/1415804.html

Answer 2

Well, I'm a Gator fan and I think that they have the best college atmosphere of any Division 1A team. They get virtually no respect outside of the southeast, and the fans are always with the team (maybe not the coach) through thick and thin.

However, I also have family in Montana and I couldn't believe that I actually heard someone else say that. I've probably had more fun at Griz games than anywhere else. They may not be D-1A, but man, you couldn't tell when you are in that stadium. The only reason why the school isn't D-1A is because of the lack of people in the state, so of course everyone there loves them, because they are the highest level of football in big sky country.

Oh, and Kirk Herbstreit's an idiot so what does it matter what he says. But coolhand i think it's funny how there are so many USC fans now, but in that article you have only FIVE years ago, Kirk is talking about how Oregon has the only good fans in the Pac 10, USC bandwagon maybe?

Answer 3

I agree with LSU Balls in that Tiger Stadium is a special place to play on Saturday night. Practically the entire campus is one big tail-gate party for both home and visiting fans. The stadium is an engineering marvel in that the noise from the fans hits the field of play with more force than most stadiums. First time visiting coaches are amazed at how loud the crowd is.
I remember the LSU/Auburn game where Pat Dye brought in his #1 defense and I believe they were ranked second in the nation. That was called the 'earthquake game' because when Tommy Hodson threw what was the game deciding touchdown with less than two minutes to play the crowd rose all at once and came down to register on the school's seismograph. Tigers won the game 7-6. Haven't heard of that happening anywhere else.
As a side note I believe the stadium capacity at that time was about 74,000. It was packed to the rafters.

Answer 4

I gotta go with Neyland Stadium and the Tennessee Volunteers. The entire city shuts itself off for a Vols game. The stadium itself holds a city's worth of people (109,000!!!!). The band is second to none. The place is insanely loud. The Vol Navy, tailgating....damn, I could go on and on.

I also got to liking the environment at Gampel at UConn. Very small, not a bad seat in the house, rowdy fans, and high caliber Big East basketball (well, excluding last season...).

Answer 5

Accept no substitutes, Tiger Stadium (aka Death Valley) on a Saturday night with 94,000 screaming, highly intoxicated, insane, LSU fans, is the best atmosphere in college football. I have been to the Swamp and Rocky Top, awesome, but Tiger Stadium gets my vote. Ask the Hokie faithful in a little over a month what they think of an 8:30 pm game in Death Valley.

Answer 6

Ga Tech, Bobby Dodd stadium when we play UGA. Yes its a small stadium (seats around 55,000) but its in the heart of downtown atlanta and the rivalry is so good. Everyone, from drunk college kids to old men who graduated 60 years ago to little kids barely walking, is into the game. Then you add the bands to the mix at halftime and it is a crazy fun atmoshpere. Nothin like that while still being in the heart of downtown

Answer 7

I am a U.S.C. Trojan fan , but I believe Alabama Crimson Tide has to be one of the best. But I think Boise St. with the Blue field has a atmosphere that is is loud and growing. Also The Oregon St. Beavers have a loud crowd and the fans are right on top of the field. It is always fun when the Trojans and Beavers get together. Ha Ha Bad joke . Fun question

Answer 8

Not in any order, but basically Florida and LSU...

Jacksonville when Florida plays Georgia ("World's Largest Outdoor Cocktail Party")

Army-Navy (I know it's a game, but you gotta put it on there because the situation changes everything)

Washington Huskies (saw a college football special on stadiums, and it's kind of cool how they basically park their boats near the stadium and the tailgates extend to the boats)

Wisconsin Badgers

Boise State.

But still have to go with Florida :-)

Answer 9

Memorial Sadium, Lincoln Nebraska!!!! The SEA of RED! On gameday Memorial Stadium, Tom Osborne Field becomes the 3rd most populated city in the state! The Huskers are all the people of Nebraska live and die for... And they are good fans to the opposing teams!! Very good sportsmanship! The pre-game atmosphere is amazing all week long!!

USC will no longer be overrated after they travel to Memorial Stadium!!!

Answer 10

Virginia Tech in Lane Stadium.