Want help? Or just an answer? Who deserves the latter?

Question

Recently a math or science question stated baldly: "I don't want an explanation. I just want an answer." I did not answer that question.

There are times when all of us would like an answer -- without an explanation. That's fine, and I have no complaint in general. But all too often, someone has a homework assignment, and all they want is to get it finished. Some have the chutzpah to list six problems, all identical in concept, and expect to get the six answers [which they often do : < ]. There seems to be little wish to learn to do the work on their own. There is even the notion that only a nerd would do the work if a friend can supply the answer.

When someone posts a question with "I got the following. Is that correct?" or "I'm having problems with this assignment. Can someone give me a clue?" I respond as often as I am able. I know that textbooks are not always clear, and that an alternate explanation can clarify things.

Am I wrong to 'help,' but not to 'answer?'

Answer 1

You aren't wrong because it is opinion and opinion cannot be wrong.

However, here's how I think of it.

I answer all questions, even if I suspect it is just for homework answers. I explain all of them, though. I do this because I like doing math.

For me, if the person is just getting answers, there will be a time when the call comes (usually during a test) and they will be screwed. It's not up to me to decide if they are just getting answers or if they are truly needing help. Because in all honesty, none of us know the intention of the asker. Even the ones who say "can you just help me with this one, I don't understand" could be looking for just an answer. How do you truly know?

I give explanations to all of my answers. I never have and never will give just the answer. At any rate, if the asker just wanted the answer and not the explanation, maybe it will help out someone else who sees my answer.

But, you are not wrong to do what you are doing. It's truly up to you. I just wanted to give my view to it, because I have had people attack me (verbally, by email) for giving explanations for all problems posted by a person, even when it is almost blatantly obvious they are only looking to write answers down on their homework. All I say is this: I love math. That's why I do it. The intention of the asker is not for me to question.

Answer 2

You are without doubt correct. I do the same as you.

The thing I don't understand is how they can get by with just the answers. Don't today's teachers demand to see how they got the answer? How else can the teacher assess whether or not a student is truly understanding a concept? If they can't make that assessment, they are as much at fault as the lazy student.

Answer 3

You are not wrong because if you just gave the answer, that would not be helping. What I do is I give the answer and then explain in full how I arrived at that answer. If the asker doesn't want to look at the explanation, that's their loss and I don't really care.

Answer 4

I wish I had posted your comment-it's EXACTLY how I feel. So much of my time is a waste.
I keep a list of those who are polite, whose personal stats are indicative of giving as well as taking, and who,as you state, want help as opposed to an answer.
If ever you figure out a way to sort out the leeches, post a comment again. I'll join your group in a heartbeat
Good to see your comment.

Answer 5

you are totally right (but you won't get a "best answer" if that matters to you)
keep helping where you can, and don't let the obvious cheaters cheat :-)