Were Jews responsible for the Communist Revolution in Russia?

Question

According the Winston Churchill they were. Churchill documented this fact in the following article:http://www.fpp.co.uk/bookchapters/WSC/WSCwrote1920.html

Answer 1

They were blamed, they weren't responsible. Jews were the money managers and managed the money of the land owners. They collected rents and taxes and were the bad guy when there was Resistance.

Answer 2

It is true that many of those involved in the Communist movement in Russia were Jews. In fact many of the leaders of Communist movements in Europe and the America’s were Jews. But this has a lot to do with the Jewish experience as aliens and second-class citizens in nations even when they could trace their lineage to those nations for hundreds of years. The details are too voluminous to even summarize here but I suggest you take a look at Hanna Arendt’s “The Origins of Totalitarianism.” It’s a bit long but it is also the most well researched treatise on this subject I have every come across.

Of note regarding Russian Communism, most of the Jews in the movement were Mensheviks who were among the first victims of the Bolsheviks. Leon Trotsky was chief among them. Ironically, many of the proponents of German Socialism were also Jews yet they were among the first victims of the National Socialists Labour Party (NAZI Party).

Answer 3

karl marx son of a Jewish Rabbi wrote the communist manifesto in the 1800.s after he died a group of rich Jew;s Kowen, Loeb, Trotsky, Nichols all Jew's pooled their money together and hired mercenaries from the U,S, Canada,Germany England and any where else they could get them, keeping mind the Russians lived almost the same as the Indians did in America is scattered groups with a czar as their head or Chief, when the Mercenaries went into Russia and they conquered one Czar who had been at war with the others , they recruited their men into their army and went on to conquer other czars until they had conquered all of Russia except the Ukraine, after the communist party was installed there has always been a Jew who was at the head also you had to be Jewish to belong to the communist party, or married to a Jew, this was the law until Gorbachev and I am not sure about him, the Jew's goal has been to rule the world for at least 500 years, they started in England but were kicked out before they got so strong, then they took Russia, then were after Germany but, Hitler was succssful in getting rid of them, their communist plans died in Russia, but they were stronger in America so now they are hot after America, and unless our people wake up in a hurry we will be as the Russians were for over 60 years, also Russia is still some what commie, I have this feeling that they are playing possum until they gain controll of America, they already have control or our monetary system ( the Federal Reserve, our new's media and T,V, etc, and almost control of our food supply, when will they bring us to our knees? we need another Hitler or???

Answer 4

perhaps Winston did, I really don't know but I would be surprised because he was half Jewish (on his mother's side). There weren't enough Jews remaining in Russia to create the revolution but if they did create it, great for them because the Czar was a monstrous anti-Semite. Marx was Jewish but his original doctrine of Communism was never carried out by the Russians. They modified it substantially and eventually became a Totalitarian state.

Answer 5

You should have really done more research before asking a question with a link to the world's biggest Holocaust denier.

A disproportionate number of Jews served in the Russian revolutionary leadership before the revolution and for years after. Most of them were hostile to traditional Jewish culture and Jewish political parties, and were eager to prove their loyalty to the Communist Party's atheism and proletarian internationalism, and committed to stamp out any sign of "Jewish cultural particularism".

In his 1938 book The Protocols of the Elders of Zion: A Proved Forgery, based on his testimony at the Berne Trial, Vladimir Burtsev wrote:

"Antisemites... refused to acknowledge the important and undisputable fact that the Jews who participated in the Socialist and Anarchist movements around the world, including the Russian Jews in particular, were renegades of the Jewish nation who had no connection with Jewish history nor with Jewish religion nor with Jewish masses, but were rather exclusively internationalists, promoting the ideas shared by Socialists of other ethnicities, and were hostile to the Jewish nation in general."

Answer 6

Churchill was a rabid Jew hater and seriously demented in a lot of his views. Are you another Jew hater as well, or are you just trolling for answers to satisfy some demented whim? What difference does any of this make anyway? Are you writng a research paper, because if you are this sin't the right forum for aquiring information.

Answer 7

The Czar's unwillingness to implement any democratic reform in Russia, the repressive government which was basically a feudal form of government, and extreme poverty had more to do with causing the Russian revolution than any religion. Russian involvement in WWI didn't help matters much either.

Answer 8

Interesting. The web filters pop up on your link, calling it a racism and hate site. Tell me you're not linking to a bad thing like that.

Addition: Oh, I see. Look up David Irving to see why that site gets to be in the racism and hate category. Nothing like some nice Nazi rhetoric to make you all warm and fuzzy.

Answer 9

The Communists were responsible.

Answer 10

You're posting all anti-Jewish questions and have posted no answers to questions on your account. Isn't this rather odd?