Are these good trades?

Question

#1 I give:
Laurence Maroney
Hines Ward
Carnell Williams

I get:
Stephen Jackson
Joey Galloway

#2 I give:
Alge Crumpler
Travis Henry
Hines Ward
DeAngelo Williams

I get:
Reggie Bush
Jeremy Shockey
Terry Glenn

Answer 1

i don't like the first one. Your givimg up Hines Ward for Joey? Galloway is getting old and Ward has a great QB with him.

I like the second one. U get Reggie Bush. enough said.

Answer 2

I like trade #1, as long as you have a decent WR corp behind Galloway. Maroney should have a pretty good season, but Ward and Williams are nothing to get excited over. Jax is the #2 fantasy player this year. Giving up 1 potentially good player, and 2 average ones for a great player is always advised. Like I said earlier, as long as you aren't relying on Galloway to score a bunch of WR points you should take it.

I don't have a feeling either way for trade #2. Both TE's are solid. Ward and Williams aren't that exciting, and Henry is a health hazard. Glenn is a solid WR3, and Bush is overrated. I would probably do it if I were you. TE is a wash, as is WR. Henry could have a good year, but I worry about how long he can hold up. So for me it comes down to your feelings on Bush and Henry. If Henry can stay health and keep the starting job in Denever, then he is he superior pick. If Henry gets hurt or demoted, and Bush can gain a bunch of receiving yards and take TD's away from Deuce then he could be the way to go.

Good luck!

Answer 3

I would make either of these trades, Lawrence Maroney could have a monster year and with Big Ben healthy Hines could return to form. The #2 trade is a disaster, Travis Henry in the Denver running game and you are thinking of trading 1600+ years and 19TD's for Reggie.

Answer 4

1. good trade
2. also a good trade

Answer 5

1. good trade
2. also a good trade

Answer 6

both good but i like the 2nd one better

Answer 7

I wouldn't do the #2 one, maybe the first. But............

Answer 8

no

Answer 9

heck no!