harry's scar and all?

Question

i pick this article (part of it) from Keith Olbermann's prediction

But what about that scar on Harry’s face? What is it really, the one seared into him in childhood when Voldemort tried to kill him and did kill his parents, the one that could register Voldemort’s emotions, even sense when Voldemort is physically near. It’s got be a horcrux, no? It’s got to be a part of Voldemort carried on Harry Potter’s very flesh?

and the idea just hit me. what if it's true?
harry's parents life's is the killing, so Voldie did made another horcrux. What if harry "is" that something from griffindor? a decendant?

Answer 1

It seems like a really good idea to me. You have to kill to make a horcrux so what he accidently made the scar one?

I wonder if the dementors will, again,,play a role. Will they somehow destroy this horcrux.

Harry would be something of Griffindor's.

If Harry’s scar does contain some piece of Voldemort, then I believe that Harry and Voldemort are still – as Dumbledore’s silver instrument told him – “in essence divided.” This essential division is what will make Harry’s survival possible, if he is housing a piece of Voldemort. The scar itself may be the cause of this “essential division” and may therefore be the reason that Harry turned out as he did, and not like Voldemort. Remember what Dumbledore said to McGonagall the night he left Harry at Privet Drive? Even if he could remove Harry’s scar he would not do it because scars can come in handy. Perhaps Harry’s lightening bolt came in handy by preserving Harry’s pure soul – essentially divided from Voldemort’s.
Whenever Harry is near Voldemort he has excruciating pain in his scar. Is this due to the magnetic pull of Voldemort’s soul struggling to reunite with itself? If so, can something pull this fragment out of Harry’s head without killing him? I don’t think it’s an accident that dementors have been so crucial to Harry’s journey since POA. I think the dementors will be back (remember, they are breeding) and that their thirst for soul-sucking will play a major role in the ending of DH. The presence of Harry’s stag Patronus on the U.K. cover supports this theory (though I once wondered if Harry’s Patronus would change to a phoenix, this now looks unlikely). However, if there are dementors to be fought, I expect a phoenix to be present.
Might Harry need to subject himself to the dementors in order to rid himself of the Voldemort within? Horrifying thought, but possible. Sometimes it is necessary to go straight into our worst fears, and sometimes those fears can be the thing that delivers us from despair or ruin. Would it not be ironic if a dementor were ultimately the thing that freed Harry from Voldemort? I also note that the Patronus lesson Harry gives to the DA in OOTP took a lot of page space, and yet thus far we haven’t seen any DA member cast the spell. I think we need that payoff, and we will see a Patronus army at some point.
If the scar is not a Horcrux, then it is something very like a Horcrux, as it seems to be the seat of Harry’s connection to Voldemort. Even Dumbledore tells Harry that Voldemort put something of himself in Harry, though not intentionally. The scar is an essential plot point, Horcrux or not, and will most certainly come into play as the connection that must be somehow broken or overcome in order to destroy Voldemort.
Perhaps the famous “gleam of triumph” that Harry saw in Dumbledore’s eye when Voldemort used Harry’s blood to regenerate a new body has something to do with how Harry will survive the connection. What has Harry’s blood been doing to Voldemort for the past two years? Harry’s blood is also Lily’s blood, and so Voldemort does now carry love within him. Will that have an effect on him? I have no idea how, but my gut says that the “gleam of triumph” is connected to “in essence divided.”

Does this help?

Answer 2

In HPCoS go read page 332's last paragraph and page 333, it makes you think. But to diprove this theory in OotP it talks about when voldemort tried to take over harry he couldn't stay in him because the love in Harry caused to much pain so if a part of his soul was in Harry then it would probably be dead, I'm working on my theory right now that has to do with why voldemort got hurt when he attacked Harry as a baby, I know Harry was protected by love but what made his spell backfire and hurt him. My theory needs a little more to make sense, that's what I'm trying to find.

Answer 3

I don't think that he is a Horcrux, if he is then why does Voldemort keep trying to kill him, because if he did he would kill part of himself too. But we will get the answer in just a few more days.

Answer 4

It's a popular theory, but I have never believed it. Too random. Voldemort doesn't do things randomly. An incantation must me recited after the murder to create a horcrux and we all know Voldemort did not have the opportunity.

Answer 5

to the people who are saying "why is Voldemort trying to kill him if he is a Horcrux" what if he has to kill him to release his soul and use it?

i dont think harry is a decendent of Griffyndor but i dont think harry is a Horcrux either.

Answer 6

if harry is a horcrux then why is voldemort trying to kill him? wouldn't that just be weakening himself?

Answer 7

Doesn't Dumbledore say something to the degree of 'one can't live with out the other.' If Harry dies (after all the other Horcruxes are destroyed) then he-must-not-be-named dies, and if Vol-you know who dies so whould Harry. Ooooo! Guess we'll find out on Friday.

Answer 8

I've been theorizing that same thing for months, and no one has taken me seriously.

Harry IS the 7th horcrux. It makes the prophecy make a lot more sense...

Answer 9

That's an interesting theory! I never thought about that! It deffinatley seems like it could happen!=)

Answer 10

*nods* That's what people have been thinking for a while now. Well stated, we'll find out soon I guess.