Is this a good price for this horse, or are they asking too much?

Question

I like this horse's looks, and I'm wondering if he's worth the asking price? What are your opinions (knowledgeable horse people) and would you pay this much for this horse? I'm looking for a gentle horse my daughter can learn to ride on. My horses are all too green for a youngster. What would be a good offer, if you think this horse is overpriced? Thanks for your help!

http://www.liverystable.net/index.php?a=2&b=560

The horse is 4 years old, and the horse's discipline level is "experienced", and the horse's rider level is marked "beginner". Many of you just aren't reading the ad right. I personally think he sounds gentle enough for a beginner, but of course I would ride him a lot to make sure he was dependable before I put my daughter on him. Thanks for all of your input!

Answer 1

He looks to have good conformation, nice color, sounds well trained and quiet, but where I live he would be very over priced. With the market down, it is hard to sell a walker over 3,000 where I am from (it might be different in other states though). Since he is only 4, and it says he is broke for anyone to ride, I would deffinitly get a through vet check, he could just have a very quiet and trainable nature, or he could have been started too young...

For 5,500 I would expect him to have some good placings at shows, be very well trained (not just quiet so anyone can sit on and walk around, but actual training...) and to be completly sound and healthy. If he is all these things, he may be well worth it for your daughter. But, keep in mind if your budget is around 5500, you can easily get a very quiet, well trained horse that has some show accomplishments, you don't need to settle on something that may not be worth the price.

Answer 2

I personally think he seems overpriced - and if I am reading the ad right...how come it says 4-6 years old? Do they know how old he is?
They call him experienced as a trail horse, but how experienced can he be at only 4-6 years? He doesn't sound like he's had a terrible amount of training and they are still asking $5500 for him.
Saying that he has been used in open shows isn't real specific - he could have done lead line in those shows, and again saying he's been used for lessons for a 4 year old - he could have been on a lead rope .
I would question how well trained this horse actually is, and at that young of an age, there's more that needs to be decided upon besides his pretty color.
If you are looking for a gentle horse for your daughter to learn on, and you say your other ones are all to green for a child, then why are you looking at another young horse that doesn't really seem to have training?
Look at a 14-16 year old horse instead of a 4-6 year old.

Answer 3

He looks great, and if he's really gentle enough for four year olds (although at his age he could still be pretty unpredictable) Then I think he would be a great mount for your daughter. Is he a long ways away from your house? If he was fairly close, seeing and possibly riding him might help you decide if he's worth the money or not. If you really like him, and don't want to take the chance of someone else getting to him first, then maybe you should just pay the asking price. ( I don't really think he's overpriced) Good luck!

Answer 4

Tell your parents, and tell your sister that if she doesn't take care of that horse, then we will sell him, etc. Something threatening :p. I would tell her all the bad things that could happen to her horse. Then maybe she'll smarten up. See, some people just go through a phase where they love horses to death. That wears out in a couple months. Its also the parents fault. If every parent said yes to a little girl wanting a horse, there would be many unwanted horses. If she's not caring for him, you might as well just sell him. Every little girl has had a phase where they are horse crazy. Fortunately, I never grew out of it :)

Answer 5

he does seem a little overpriced. also, he is pretty young too. beginners can ride him i am sure, but an older horse will have already had "life experiences". older horses have been there done that. i would go on a horse classifieds website and look for a kid-safe horse that is at least 10 years old. they usually sell for about $3000 at the most. here are some sites to get you started. go to advanced search and click what you want.

Here is what i would put
gelding
any breed
at least 10 years old
no taller than 16hh
kid safe
not more than $3000

dreamhorse.com
acmehorses.com
equinehits.com
horseville.com
bridleandbit.com

just go to google and search horse classifieds.
Good Luck.

Answer 6

No! I think he should be around 4500-5500. He is the right price unless he is a little rusty. If he is not show ready or has been out to pasture for a while, I'd say 4500 or 3500 depending on how bad it is. If you really really like the horse then 5500 is a good price even if he isn't a show horse. Anything below 3000 generally is out to pasture or WAS beginner safe.

Answer 7

i think maybe they are asking a little much...his lines are OK...but i don't particularly think hes WORTH 5,500...maybe 5,000. But if that doesn't work out and they won't use this plan then unless you REALLY, REALLY like this horse and have seen it being rode well... Then i'd try to find a different horse...I mean some horses like champion show horses i'd understand but this isn't a very good price...try dreamhorse.com ...then you can kind of specialize stuff like if you want a Tennessee Walking Horse then look for that only and there can be a price limit...discipline, age, weight, miles away you'd go to get it, calmness....ect....Hope i helped!!

Answer 8

It's not real cheap, but his age and "bombproof" nature may make that extra money worth it.

I would suggest a smaller pony for a young girl to ride on. They are normally cheaper, and easier to ride. Horses have broader backs which present some problems with small kids. How old is your daughter though? ~7 or older and he should be a great begginner horse!

Answer 9

Number 1..... they say he is 4-6 years old? Don't they know? Sounds like they don't know him very well if that is the case. Also look around. If other horses are selling in the local paper and see the prices they are advertising. If that is comparable then go look at him make up your own mind. I personally think you can find one cheaper. But if you are showing or something for points he may be the one.

Answer 10

I would recommend taking your daughter out and letting her ride him. Many people will lets potential buyers come and ride the horse. Also saddle the horse and do normal things you would be doing with the horse. Also if they will let you. Take the horse home and see how it gets use to your stables. Some horses are compatable with some people, and then hate others.