How Do You Think The "Surge" Is Working In Iraq?

Question

HH: I’m joined now by satellite phone from Baghdad by intrepid reporter Michael Yon. He’s actually in Baquba. Michael, welcome back to the Hugh Hewitt Show, always a pleasure to speak with you. How goes the fighting on the ground?

MY: Well, it’s really slowed down here in Baquba, Hugh. I was just in the TOC or the headquarters about fifteen minutes ago before I came on the show, and they were like the Maytag repairmen here. I mean, Baquba has just…you know, it was a very serious fight when it started, Operation Arrowhead Ripper on the 19th of June, I came in with them, but it quickly abated. The people have just turned against al Qaeda here. And so Baquba is really, the big fight now is to get the food distribution working again, which it already is. You know, they’ve got that going. And now, they’re working on fuel, because the fuel relates to electricity and water pumping. So really, they’re working on more civic things now.

There’s still some combat to do, but not a lot, actually, because like I said, you know, the people just turned against al Qaeda.

HH: Now Michael Yon, a lot of people don’t know the significance of Baquba. And so can you explain what peace in Baquba means for the larger war effort?

MY: Well, it’s huge, because al Qaeda had claimed Baquba as their capitol, their worldwide capitol. And you might recall one of the things that kind of upsets people about my reporting is I said Iraq was in a civil war, and I said that way back in February of 2005, and I continue to do so. But when I first wrote that, I was in Baquba, in 2005, and I spent two or three months here. And it was just total…you could see it, and you could see al Qaeda was trying to foment that civil war, because that’s their underlying strategy, is to do that. And so getting, fracturing al Qaeda here, and al Qaeda alienating so many Iraqis, it’s helping us to put a damper on the civil war.

HH: Now yesterday, Harry Reid said on the floor of the Senate that the surge has failed. Do you think there’s any factual basis for making that assertion, Michael Yon, from what you’ve seen in Iraq over the last many months?

MY: He’s wrong, he’s wrong. It has absolutely not failed, and in fact, I’m finally willing to say it in public. I feel like it’s starting to succeed. And you know, I’m kind of stretching a little bit, because we haven’t gone too far into it, but I can see it from my travels around, for instance, in Anbar and out here in Diyala Province as well. Baghdad’s still very problematic. But there’s other areas where you can clearly see that there is a positive effect. And the first and foremost thing we have to do is knock down al Qaeda. And with them alienating so many Iraqis, I mean, they’re almost doing it for us. I mean, yeah, it takes military might to finally like wipe them out of Baquba, but it’s working. I mean, I sense that the surge is working. Reid is just wro

http://hughhewitt.townhall.com/Transcript_Page.aspx?ContentGuid=ad2ccbe4-c31a-422f-b099-65ba45ec5887

Catcu: there is a logical fallacy in your arguement when 1) Exxon doesn't own Iraqi oil, and 2) Free flowing oil from Iraq would decrease gas prices as the supply of oil went up.

Answer 1

It's NOT!

Answer 2

Funny. It doesn't matter whether the surge is working! The Iraqi government is not working, nor will it be any time soon! So we just keep troops there so Exxon can pull 4 Million barrels of oil a month out of Iraq! When Bush took office gas was $1.46 a gallon! I don't think Iraqi oil works either?

1/20/09: End of an Error

Answer 3

The surge is working. Al Queda in Iraq is getting racked up in Al Anbar province. What Americans are being fed is constantly looped footage of attacks on civilians in Baghdad.
The desperation of Al Queda and its Salafist Jihadist allies is evident in their "surge" of internet pleadings and video taped bleatings trying to exhort Islam into something they don't care to do. By adhering to the heresy of "Takfir", allowing Muslim to kill Muslim in the carrying out of Jihad they have shown themselves to merely be the Ku Klux Klan of Islam.

Answer 4

Kudos. I am sure the liberals feel reid knows more than the soldier on the ground actually in Iraq. pelosi & hillary are surely experts too. Liberals are like vampires, the explode when the truth hits them like the sun. Kudos to the men on the ground in Iraq

USN vet Iraq 2001-2003

Answer 5

You should place a warning on that. Some people's eyes might start burning after reading the truth.

Answer 6

Great...this war should be over shortly then. Who knew...