Whose the best at grading World coins-ANACS, NGC, or PCGS?

Question

I personally think that anacs undergrades and pcgs and ngc are close but ngc grades higher then pcgs. So does this mean that pcgs grades the most accurate? I have always thought that ANACS was right up there with the rest and since I have started to collect world coins have noticed the difference in the top three graders. Does this reflect how they grade with us coins also and is that what brings the premiums higher for NGC and PCGS because they arent known to undergrade coins as much? ICG is the best new grading company and should be in the number 4 spot.

Answer 1

ANACS is by far the best for authentication, especially colonial issues. they also have the best track record for World Coins. None of the grading services are really good at grading world coins. There are too many standards out there. The grading services have made it almost impossible to collect American coins by the average collector who has a small budget. I hate to see them do the same with world coins and ancients. Americans are to lazy to learn to grade coins on their on. So I don't feel bad when they get taken buy a mistake from a grading service. I may sound harsh here but I divide coin collecting up to the average collector who tries to fill an album or folder with dates and mint marks, the come the investors which can be divided up into groups also. The last group is some what small and that is true numismatists who not only collect coins but also study them. They collect for the history aspect also. I very rarely buy slabbed coins unless I see one misgraded or the coin sticks out as a great strike. All NGC and PCGS do is make their owners richer as well as coin dealers. Grading is someones opinion and standards change from time to time. Look back a few years to all the people that paid $200 to $300 for PCGS & NGC MS-64 Morgan dollars only to find out that is a very common grade and the coins now sell for $64. The dealers don't like that fact showing up.

Answer 2

PCGS on old gold is your best option. NGC is not as tough and many NGC graded coins trade a bit lower than PCGS graded coins. I am watching a $20 1852 o coin that was bought in a AU 53 PCGS holder, cracked out and then graded by NGC as a au55. PCGS is more stringent old gold (can t say about silver ) and they trade at a premium to NGC coins of the same grade. There are exceptions, especially if the coin is CAC.

Answer 3

None of them. The best is to use your own judgement and come to your own decision about the grade. All the top TPGs have been inconsistent with their grading and some seem to favor large dealers and biased toward pedigree coins. You can even resubmit a coin multiple times to get the proper grade that you want. But if you have to pick one, then I'd say that any of the top four mentioned would be fine for grading world coins. NGC and PCGS are considered in the first-tier, they grade stricter so any coin in their slabs generally sells better than other labels. ANACS is regarded as second-tier, grades more lenient than the other two but doesn't bodybag coins and anyone can submit coins without going through dealers. So it's the best for the average collector. ICG is an up and coming TPG and the best for ancients. So it's all up to a collector's preference and how a service can suit his or her needs, but all things being equal, I would rather have a tier-one graded coin over any other especially at the time of sale.

Answer 4

Ngc World Coin

Answer 5

Best Coin Grading Service

Answer 6

You are. The important thing about the grade of a coin is what you think it is. If you are good enough to be able to tell the differences in the grading style of the different major players, your opinion is the one that you should trust. If you are trying to get the most money by selling slabbed coins, go with the highest grading service and sell to dealers who just read the slabs and don't grade coins themselves. Personally, I think a slab detracts from the value of a coin and I pay more for unslabbed equivalent coins. I would never slab my GSA CC dollars.

Answer 7

lots extra probable it became an old one from yet another year. I have been given a field of chocolate coated cherries like that a pair months in the past. many of the moisture became even lacking from them. yet this variety I had became the comparable I had have been given for years.