Who's The better player:Lebron, Wade, or "Melo?

Question

LeBron James:Led The Cavs to 1st Ever NBA finals
Dwayne Wade:NBA Finals MVP ,Gave the Heat There 1st Championship in franchise history
Carmelo Anthony:2nd in NBA in scoring last year

Answer 1

This is the most asked question in this section, of those only one player has a ring, so lets go with him.

Answer 2

Out of the three, 'Melo has just made a name for himself and has finally emerged this past season as an elite NBA All-Star. So he is out of the question. That leaves D-Wade and King James. This is a tough one, but not all dat tough. Wade and James both have a killer instinct, what you can't find in a lot of players. Wade has a much better team than James, which played a large role in the Heat capturing the NBA title in '06. Wade has about 3 future hall of famers in O'Neal, Payton, and Mourning. While, without maybe the exceptions of Illguaskus is doing it all by himself. Then if you want to compare them on an individual basis LeBron can do everything Wade can plus he can shoot the 3 way better.

Answer 3

I'd say right now, Wade. Melo is too one dimensional and doesn't have the defense and hunger to be as good as wade and lebron.

I think in the long term, Lebron has the potential to be the best. But right now whether it's the coach stifling him or Lebron just being inexperienced, but the guy doesn't know how to read a game and know when to take over and when to let the game come to him. His mistakes towards the end of the Piston games almost cost them the series if it weren't for a Pistons meltdown. And against the Spurs, Lebron just seemed lost.

Wade has the hunger, the skill, the drive. But his aggressiveness to the basket is going to make him continue to be more and more injury prone and he's gonna be too banged up in a few years to be as good as he is now.

Answer 4

Everybody will say Wade becuse of his championship.

Labron & Melo are not on teams as well rounded as the Heat are.

But as far as individual talent goes, LEBOMB, my bad LEBRON JAMES is athletically superior to Dwayne and Carmello.

Dwayne probably has the higher basketball IQ of the 3 players. He knows when and when not to on the court.

Carmello is the guy in the gym nobody thinks is that good but he can outshine the best of them on any night, look at his head to heads with LeBron.

They are all good, but if there was a 3man 1 on 1 tourney, I would put my money on LeBron James.

LeBron is a manchild, and once his head catches up with his body he will be good to go!

Answer 5

Lebron has the physical gifts but he just lacks the mental toughness to finish off games. He has this tendency to settle for jumpers in the endgame. he's just not "clutch" enough.

Melo on the other hand has the heart during end game, but he's the least gifted athletically of the three. His greatest drawback is his immaturity & conduct off the court.

Wade is the total package. he has already shown that he has the heart to will his team to victory in the mold of a Jordan. He is athletic. He's clutch & most of all he's a model citizen outside the basketball court.

Answer 6

The Man They Called Flash: Dwyane Wade

Answer 7

LeBron. End of discussion. who ever thinks wade is better, tell me how many VETERAN players are on his team... umm... yea. Lebron has 1, yes only 1, teamate who has expierence from the finals. o and that expereince was about 2 minutes of it. the next 'veteran' LeBron has is larry hughes... the passed 2 offseasons, he's deal with injuries... ok
wade has SHAQ.o yea, is he the guy who won championships with KOBE? uuhhh yea. then Alonzo, passed #1 draft pick, then shooters : Gary Payton, Antonio Walker.

IF wade is better, wud he have gone to the finals all by himself like LeBron, (who i should say has 1 decent shooter,rookie daniel gibson) gone to the finals. i think NOT.

Answer 8

Melo can be counted out of the question. It might be LeBron coz hes just so charismatic. Wade is also young but i guess LeBron could take it from him

Answer 9

Dwayne Wade

Answer 10

lebron james by far. he leads his team, he means so much to the cavaliers. he can carry his team on his shoulders when they need it , hes a great player. dwayne wade is a really good player but just not as talented as lebron james. carmelo anthony can score.....thats about it, he doesnt pass or play much defense. hes good , but needs to pass once in a while and learn how to defend.

Answer 11

I would say Lebron. even though Wade won a ring he has another superstar along side him and Melo has better teamates than Lebron and Lebron still won more games than him. Lebron is like Magic Johnson comparison who can score and is physically better.