fantsy trade?

Question

i get Donvan McNabb, Edgerin James, Santana Moss and i give Marc Bulger and Donald Driver

Answer 1

I'm with D B on this one
-not just because of his Dolphin Fanness


Santana Moss doesn't put up even average numbers in 2/3 the games he plays
Edge hasn't shown he's a good starting RB since he stopped running behind the Colts line
and McNabb (for all we know) could pull a Culpepper and not be physically (or mentally) ready to play this season
and that's not even factoring in the likelyhood that he'll end up injured at some point in the year.

On the other hand, Bulger was an absolute stud last year before they upgraded at TE and WR
and Driver is a very solid option at WR


I'd stick with your guys

Answer 2

Looks good on paper, but I wouldn't pull that trigger. Bulger is a top 5 QB while Driver is Farve's number 1 option and a top 8 receiver.

Looking to get 29 year old running back with a shady o-line. Arizona will be playing from behind so running the ball isn't an option. The Edge had 6 total td's last year. Santana Moss is on the wrong team; even though the Redskins are my favorite team, they don't have a QB or decent OC. Santana Moss is going to be on your bench anyway.

This trade comes down to Mcnabb and james vs Bulger and Driver. Would anyone make that trade? I wouldn't!

McNabb isn't going to be as mobile as last year. Mcnabb only played 16 games just once in the last five years. Look at that division too, its one of the bests. Besides Reggie Brown who is young, they are going to struggle at WR.

Its up to you on how you think Mcnabb will hold up during the season.

Answer 3

Yes that is a good trade.

Donovan McNabb i think will have another breakout year , Edge is on a mainly passing oriented team but is a great aggressive runner and solid 2 back. Santana Moss is a speed wide out who will score you some points every week (will most likely return kicks) if your league scores that way that is a plus.

Granted Bulger is a great fantasy QB with his high touchdown numbers and passing yards, but Isaac Bruce is wearing down and they need another guy to step up and take his place. Donald Driver is a good reciever but will not get average as many points as Moss will.

Answer 4

I'd say NO. Bulger in that Rams offense puts up big numbers every year, McNabb hurt again? very possible. Driver is the only good WR that Favre has so he should have good numbers. Having Bulger and Driver would cancel out not having James but with the O at Arizona they will not be a dominate running team anyway.

Answer 5

I guess I am in the minority on this one, as I would decline that trade. McNabb hasnt finished either of the past two seasons, Santana Moss doesnt do anything for me (less than 800 yds receiving last year) and Edge is well past his prime.

Bulger has one of the best supporting casts in the league - Holt, Bruce, Bennett, McMichael, Steven Jackson, gets to play half his games in a dome, plus he gets to play the Niners, Cards and Seahawks twice a season, and none of them were very good against the pass last year.

Driver is Favre's favorite receiver, and should produce close to what he did last year - 1200 yds/6-8 TD's.

Answer 6

I would do it. Moss and Driver should essentially cancel out. McNabb will be a stud, and edge is icing on the cake. The only thing holding you back is worrying about McNabb's injury, but I think he'll be fine.

Answer 7

you should do it for sure, Moss is probably better than Driver, Mcnabb and Bulger are a push plus you get James in the deal

Answer 8

Let me join that league. 3 possible starters for the price of 2. Done.

Answer 9

Yes, do it.......now.

Based on the NFL knowledge of your league mate(s), you should be able to dominate your league. lol!

Why would they even offer that trade?

Answer 10

Dude do it quick before the other guy changes his mind!