Israel will not give refuge to Sudanese refugees?

Question

"More than five hundred Sudanese refugees have fled to Israel in the last two months to escape genocide in Darfur.
Now Israel is threatening to deport them."
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/A516C172-220E-42AF-A3F4-41935E58EEAC.htm

Jewish ethics would call for giving shelter to the needy. Israel will not give aid to the needy. Is Israel a jewish state or just another secular state? and if so, how can it continue to claim to be an exception? What makes Israel exceptional if it does not follow the Jewish religion exceptionally? Why does Israel deny safety to the Sudanese refugees? Why does it deny safety to the Palestinians?
Israel allow jews to immigrate there but no one else. A NAZI policy?

It is illegal to annex land by war. Welcome to the 20th century. Why do Americans support colonialism and racism with such fervor? And why are you so eager to overlook blatant violations of the UN charter? Are you wholly committed to destroy any possibility of justice and equality to all the people of the world? It seems to me, you are as much a racist as the Zionists are. The Nazis never did lose, they just changed their name in America and Israel.

So, now i am Muslim because i empathize with the suffering of Muslims? Not that i mind.., I mean, these people made civilization what it is today. You people wouldn't even have guitars or algebra if it weren't for the Muslim world!!! But I have to dispel such a misconception, I place my loyaly to justice not to tribalism. What about you? How tribal are you? conceling US/Zionist crimes but decrying the Arab nationalists and insurgents defense... Americans are waay backwards.

Sanchez, most leaders are treacherous rats. We both know that. But the people in the US and Israel support Apartheid. Israelis, not jews, are shaming themselves through their bigotry. Just as South Africans, Americans and Europeans shamed themselves for the crimes they committed in the name of the white race.
This is not about the Jews, this is about Israelis claiming to uphold Jewishness. If they did uphold Hebrew law, they would have abandoned violence a long time ago.

Israeli says Muslims have a lot of land. You should know, you took a huge chunk yourselves.

Answer 1

If Israel were run according to Jewish law, then yes, they should let them in to stay. But it isn't. It is run according to the zionist political movement which contradicts Judaic law. That is the problem.

Answer 2

It does not deny refuge to the Sudanese. The fact that they are there (instead of Egypt where they originally crossed into) proves this. Israel however doesn't have the resources to foster these refugees indefinately. Also, Israel can't harbor people opposed to its existence, which applies to the Palestinians who you say need safety.
Israel has a history of providing aid where they could. They sent rescue crews to Thailand following the tsunami and sent neccessary supplies, as well as other places since Israeli search and rescue units are considered elite. They are also currently training Kenyan search and rescue teams.
Allowing only Jews to immigrate to Israel (which isn't the case) is NOT a nazi policy. A nazi policy would be KILLING EVERYONE NOT A SPECIFIC RACE, as opposed to courting a specific race for immigration. It's ignorant and offensive to call it such.

Answer 3

Speaking as an Israeli citizen, 1/4 of Israelis live under the poverty line. We have thousands who apply for food aid during holidays. Our national budget is so stressed that our schools do not have the funding to run properly.

Much as we would like to, we cannot start taking in the Sudanese (we took in hundreds of Vietnamese boat people in the 70's, but most have left for America). We are helping them at the moment, but they must be transferred to aid agencies. It would start a tidal wave of refugees when word got out and it could start problems with Sudan who is an enemy of Israel.

There is so much land in the Muslim world and parts of it are so so rich, why don't these these rulers do something to help the Darfur Muslims? They don't care. Who helped the Bosnians? I suspect the fact that they are black has something to do with it, and the despotic rulers of the oil sheikdoms would rather spend their money on buying up real estate and corporations, as they are prone to doing.

Answer 4

The final I examine of the refugees became interior the Jerusalem submit; people who made it have been scuffling with to be waiting to stay in Israel. some stay to tell the story a kibbutz and others are being held in prisons looking forward to a variety. i've got no longer heard something approximately them being given abode or different information different than some kibbutzim have taken quite a few of them in. luckily, they have human beings like Elie Wiesel scuffling with on their ingredient, so with any luck all of it works out nicely. in spite of the undeniable fact that, the Sudan and Israel are enemy states, and the refugees are no longer Jewish, for that reason there has been a lot of resistance in permitting them to stay. we could all desire the region interior the Sudan incorporates a ingredient the place there are not any greater refugees, yet interior the intervening time this is mandatory to furnish any help a threat! desire I spoke back your question!

Answer 5

Learn your facts. Meantime they are here in Israel unlike any Muslim country in the World. Israel is the only country trying to find a solution for them. They are Muslims themselves but they try to get to Israel through Egypt which will not allow them to stay. In Israel They are now recieving education for their children, free medical services and work. Come see for yourself instead of putting all your trust in the arab press. Have a great day.

Answer 6

The whole reason Jews need their own land is because of morons like you.

As for Israel only allowing Jewish people to immigrate - that's incorrect. I personally know plenty non Jewish people who have made Israel their home. In addition, Israel does more for the Palestinians than their fellow Muslims do!

You are a total twit, and have made this abundantly clear with this idiotic question.

Answer 7

A good reason could be that they have too many people to begin with. More muslims would make it even worse. Do not be hasty with the N-word. Israel hasn't started massive killings of any race yet. Denying saftey to palistinians? What have you been reading? National interests come first everywhere but itseems in Israel where they have gone out of there way to make a palestinian state and give back lands they won. Have you ever seen a victorious nation give back land it won fair and square without losing a war? I haven't.

Answer 8

Many states give preferential treatment of citizenship to common ethnic groups.

It is called Jus sanguinis, and is common throughout the world. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_sanguinis

As for the Sudanese refugees Israel is giving them refuge, if you notice they all crossed though Egypt. How many are seeking refuge there?

Hopefully when their county will stabilize they can return to their homes.

Answer 9

Are you slightly mad?

Israel is a tiny country, smaller than Wales. She's barely coping right now, being attacked by Hamas and Hezbollah continually, her citizens being slaughtered and the country on PERMANENT critical alert. Now you demand that this tiny bit of land takes in yet more Muslim immigrants - when it's Muslims that deny Israel's right to exist?

Also, in the past, be aware that I have found several stories on Aljazeera to be false, or at best inaccurate.

EDIT: why are you demanding that Israel, and not any of the 22 Muslim countries, helps out? And as for your other insulting and frankly irrational comments: clearly you are in need of psychiatric help. I hope you find it.

Answer 10

Why don't your Muslims brothers take them?? There are other immigrates that live in Israel so you statement is false Mr Muslim man.