who is a better quarterback jay cutler or vince young?

Question

i think its jay cutler because he is on my favorite football team

Answer 1

Vince Young is a double threat, and can even pass better than Cutler.

So you think Cutler is suddenly better skillswise because he is on the Broncos? What kind of logic is that? If Vince and Jay were traded, would Vince be better all-of-a-sudden?

Vince Young hands down.

Answer 2

reraise 4, when is 9-7 identical to 8-8.
Let's see what Jay can do with a full year as starter. I know VY. didn't start the entire year. But Jay has the potential to be a great QB. I just see a lot of ifs with Vince. If he had more talent around him, if he can stay healthy. C'mon that goes for any athlete in any sport. Vince needs to stay in the pocket. don't try to be Vick. Vince is a better QB than Vick. Oh and to the KC fan I have nothing bad to say about your team, except they suck. But hey at least their not the Raiders.

Go Broncos

Answer 3

Alright, this answer is coming from a Chiefs fan so I'm obviouly biased against the Broncos - in fact I hate them with a passion. Cutler has better recievers, but Cutler is also the better QB. He's a pure QB that is accurate, has a strong arm and showed some flashes of great leadership last year. He's not as fast as Young, but he can run pretty well (better than average) in the open field and isn't a sitting duck in the pocket. Don't expect him to be the next John Elway, though. You Denver fans have a tendancy to do that and it's not fair, or realistic to think he'll be that good.

All that being said, if Young can develop his passing game (something Micael Vick has yet to do) and get some good recievers around him like Cutler has, he'll have the advantage over Cutler because of his superior abilityto make plays with his legs. IF that happens, it won't be for a couple years.

Answer 4

Vince Young

Answer 5

Jay Cutler is the better passer, but Vince Young is the better quarterback because of his athleticism, leadership, and decision making. It is also clear that Cutler has way more help around him, but their teams had identical records and Vince Young had a better individual winning record. Also, Vince Young has a better ability to bring his team back in tough situations.

Answer 6

athlete- Vince Young
Quarterback - Jay Cutler

Answer 7

Vince young is, jay cutler will still do very well but not as good as young will.

Answer 8

Vince Young, not a big fan of his. At least he has won games in the past. Cutler was a failure in college and that will just continue in the pros. He may put up stats but its all about the W's baby. National championship in college compared to 5 wins in career or whatever cutler had, sorry did not want to waste my time to look it up. I just know cutler is not the winner vince is.

Answer 9

Hmm... i'm no longer a Vince youthful fan, he has been overvalued in my books ever for the reason that he gained that Rookie of the 365 days award!, yet i will stand right here and attractiveness how good of a participant he would be sooner or later. He has 0 receivers and that's barely his 2d 365 days. whilst jay Cutler nonetheless had Javon Walker and Brandom Marshall, plus stokley. nonetheless, if I had to go with a QB, it would could be Cutler, for the reason that Vince youthful establishes himself in this "I deserve some understand" altitude, whilst for sure he had a sixty six.7 QB score and it in basic terms jumped to seventy one.a million!! all of us understand pacman Jones saved those comebacks and a few good training and Vince youthful in my eyes are nonetheless overvalued!

Answer 10

Well Cutler is a pure QB....and between them, yeah, he's probably the best QB...but Vince Young is a weapon in the passing and running game and one of the best young leaders in the game. I'll take a Vince Young any day, sorry.