Is this a fair trade?

Question

I give up:
Dallas Clark
Anthony Gonzalez
Reggie Bush
I get:
Antonio Gates
Chris Chambers
DeAngelo Williams

Heres my team. I'm in a 12 team keeper league
QB Drew Brees
WR Deion Branch
WR Roy Williams
WR Bernard Berrian
RB Frank Gore
RB Reggie Bush
TE Dallas Clark
K David Akers
DEF Seattle
BN Matt Leinart
BN Kevin Curtis
BN Julius Jones
BN Marty Booker
BN Anthony Gonzalez
BN Dallas DEF

Also, your opinions on this trade I accepted:
I get:
Bernard Berrian
Frank Gore
Dallas Clark
I give:
Santana Moss
Rudi Johnson
Desmond Clark

yea, im not going to be around a QB at all during preseason. im on vacation from the start of AUG to the start of SEPT. so im tryin to improve my team now

Answer 1

Great trade you already made, but do not go through with the other. Bush is too good and Clark and Gonzalez will pull their own weight. Yees gates is good bit can you see Deangelo williams being close to BUsh in productivity on a fantasy scale?

Answer 2

ok the first trade is good for 3 reasons
1.Gates is the BEST TE in fantasy football and is Philip Rivers #1 target while Clark is competing with Harrison,Wayne,and now Addai for receptions
2.Anthony Gonzalez is going to be the slot receiver for the Colts while Chambers is the best target that Trent Green has since McMichael is gone
3.now Bush is better than Williams but the other two players you will be getting will easily make up for the loss of Bush and since you already have Frank Gore you shouldnt have to worry about the backfield very much
as for the other trade its no good because
1.Santana Moss is easily better than Berrian because Berrian is just a straight line runner with speed while Moss can do more than just that and hes Jason Campbells new go to guy
2.Frank Gore is getting a new head coach but will still probably do better than Johnson bu the situation with the rest of the trade just wont make this work
3.Dallas Clark has Peyton Manning throwing to him while Desmond Clark has Rex Grossman throwing the ball do i need to say more?

Answer 3

Never trade Reggie Bush in a keeper league. It's pretty simple, you are trading an impact player for 3 average players. Gates is good at TE but Chambers and Williams aren't anything special. Basically this trade is Reggie Bush for Antonio Gates which obviously is not a good trade.

Your other trade wasn't smart either. Gore will get yards, but he has low ability to score TD's in the redzone. Johnson gets yards AND scores TD's.

Really it is not smart to trade half of your team before the season has even started. The PRESEASON hasn't even started.

Answer 4

your first trade was great on your part.

lets compare:
Dallas Clark vs. Antonio Gates
WINNER: Gates. Gates might be the first TE ever to get league mvp after he pulls in 15 TDs.

Anthony Gonzales vs. Chris Chambers
WINNER: Chambers. Gonzales is a rookie and will be the Colts' 3rd receiver behind Harrison and Wayne. He won't get the ball much.

Reggie Bush vs. DeAngelo Williams
WINNER: Williams. They both split carries but I think DeAngelo will get more touches. Reggie splits with Deuce McAllister. DeAngelo splits with DeShaun Foster. Deuce is better of the 4 backs an he'll get more carries than Bush. Williams has a better chance (if healthy) to get you more points this year.

2nd trade was pretty solid by the way.

Answer 5

The point of a trade isn't to be "fair", it's to provide the other team with something they can't refuse, and you benefit from. What you are proposing is to weaken yourself at running back, where you don't have adequate depth to begin with, in exchange for a better tight end. In fantasy football, running back is the most important position, and you want to go into the season starting either JJ or Deangelo? I think your trade partner would get the best of this deal!

Answer 6

I would keep Reggie Bush. He is only gonna get better and help New Orleans' offense. You need a TE and WR Champers and Gates are some good ones. It depends though. Getting Frank Gore was a good trade too.

Answer 7

honest commerce is achieved while international locations commerce with one yet another autonomously. loose commerce is comparable, however the lack of ability of fairness is many times attributed to 0.33 events like the WTO. contained in the tip, the weaker international places get exploited. not basic to entice the line between the two so unquestionably, yet an occasion of loose commerce that's not honest is Nike. Nike company runs production flowers in southeast Asian and latin American international places. the corporate place of work pushes the administration for such unreasonable income that the folk many times make approximately $a million.50 or much less an afternoon, that's adequate to stay to tell the story on food yet not the rest. international places can commerce autonomously on a similar time as nonetheless benefitting the smaller international places with the aid of installation rules that restrict their multinational firms from violating particular policies like pay standards. there's no choose for a 0.33 social gathering if the better government is to blame. regrettably, that's not the case. The WTO does not have the smaller international places superb pastimes in recommendations, the two. it rather is totally uncomfortable to think of purely how a lot of human beings stay damaging lives so as that we would desire to continuously purchase products at "stable" costs.

Answer 8

I think the trade that you are thinking about is a good one for you. I'm not sure I see the benefit of the 2nd trade the one you already accepted cause it seems like your giving up equal guys to getting equal ugys and not really upgrading a unit.

Answer 9

The trade you accepted was great for you.

The trade were you give up Bush, yeah don't do that one. The 2 for 2 is ok. You should make him offer someone way better then Williams for that deal.

Answer 10

Don't like either trade and I don't think your team will do much this year, I would have stayed away from reggie Bush for one more year