English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Is there some sort of compass we all have inside of us that guides us through life letting us know what we should and shouldnt do? A spiritual force? And I dont mean God or religion so all the bible bashers out there take it easy and sit this one out. Sometimes I get this feeling that m really suited to somethings and other times I'll get a feeling that im not suited to some other thing. Where does this come from? Thanks

2007-07-03 04:24:01 · 16 answers · asked by Eoin B 2 in Arts & Humanities Philosophy

16 answers

I have no good words to define it, but for lack of them, perhaps we could call it an "inner voice." Joseph Campbell said that he always told his students when they asked him questions about life, decisions, etc... to "Follow your Bliss. There's something inside you that knows when you're on the beam, and knows when you're off the beam. And if you get off the beam [to do something contrary to your real self] then you've lost your life."
I've applied this idea to my own life and have seen that it is true. I cannot describe what that something is; but IT IS.

2007-07-03 06:03:41 · answer #1 · answered by Cognitive Dissident ÜberGadfly 3 · 0 1

To get a good view of the scientific perspective of the kind of thing you're talking about, we need to consider your brain.

While some people like to compare the brain to a computer, there is at least one major way in which it is completely different. As most of us have probably noticed at one time or another, at any given moment a computer can only be carrying out ONE task. It might switch between many tasks quickly and SEEM to do many at once, but if you run across something big that chews up a lot of processing power, you will quickly discover that until your computer is done everything else is pretty much at a standstill.

This is NOT the way your brain works. Your brain has millions of neurons and they can ALL work more or less independantly. Though your conscious mind may only be thinking about one thing at a time (like a computer), all the other parts of your brain are humming along and doing their own things AT THE SAME TIME. Your senses still collect and process information, your memory is constantly bringing up correlations, and your body is still kept functioning - and many other things are going on - whether you pay attention or not.

This can create interesting situations. Because non-conscious parts of your brain are still 'thinking' in a way that is outside your awareness, you can actually know things that you don't KNOW that you know. Most of us are familiar with this in a variety of ways. Like when you stop thinking about a difficult problem and the answer just 'comes' to you - you WERE still thinking about it... just not consciously. Or when you get a 'feeling' about a person or a situation that turns out later to be true - you may have collected very subtle sensory and memory information to create that impression.

Just be careful not to give these other parts of your brain too much credit. Though they may often notice things you otherwise do not, they are not really any more accurate than your concious mind. And sometimes much LESS accurate. This is often the source of an irrational fear that psychologists call a phobia - your unconscious mind has associated a harmless thing with a bad or dangerous thing and makes you feel fear where there is no good reason.

It is the nature of the human mind to notice the unusual. So even if you perceive that these impressions are almost always correct, it may just be that you are noticing a statistical anomaly. One way to prove it to yourself is to write down EVERY impression you get, and check back later to see which ones are right and which ones are wrong. I have little doubt that you'll find your unconscious isn't much more accurate than your conscious is!

Hope that helps!

2007-07-03 05:40:40 · answer #2 · answered by Doctor Why 7 · 0 0

Why not?

It comes rom the "Guide".

If manufacture an item you would provide a guide for its operation and repair. You might even provide a tutorial.
Consider that the Universe is a manufactured item. The parts of the parts of the parts... are all manufactured to operate.

One of the parts is called Human. The Human is special in that they are physcal, mental, emotional, and can choose to do a variety of things. Somethings such as coming into physical or leaving physical existence at a specific time and place is beyond Human control.

So does it not stand to reason the Determiner of the when and where the raindrop falls and the when and where of the droplets etc. even to the placement of the molecules and atoms and the charges of their constituaent parts; that same Determiner that has chosen the when and where of your birth and death, and has loaned you the accesses to the vast resources to use; would supply you with Guidance?

Consider if you created an highly intelligent being with the ability to make choices, that Guidance would be fundamental for its continued development. The same must be true for Superiority of the Divine Guidance and the newcomers called Humans.

Sometimes it pays to unlearn what you have learned and allow the guidance to teach you how to learn. The resources of the Possesor of all things are vast enough to get a customized Guidance that is specific for you.

Besides is not the Guidance that guided you to ask yourself the question?

I hope that I have been helpful.

2007-07-04 10:00:57 · answer #3 · answered by LeBlanc 6 · 0 1

For lack of a better term life itself.

We are the sum of our life, the expression of our whole past unto the first generation. All of which has brought to bear the forces that shape and mold our minds, our will, and our perceptions. We can only choose among the choices that we perceive as presented to us. These choices are seldom of our own making alone. Thus it is that we interact with the universe to obey its bidding because we can do nothing else. It is the way we are made. And it leaves us with a certain amount of sadness.

We can but live in the moment, contending with what life presents to us. We deal with it as we move on to the next moment. We each have our share of blissful ignorance as we pursue our delusions. All that is certain is that it began and it will end. In the meantime we all share a bit of sadness.

In the tide of human affairs we cannot always see the reason, but it is there. Not a destiny as such, but a reason for it to occur. As the tides of the universe pass to and fro, we obey, blinded by its complexity. In the murk of it all, lies a reason for human affairs.

2007-07-03 05:33:55 · answer #4 · answered by Sophist 7 · 0 0

i gather that this is a question regarding morality. there are two dominant worldviews with respect to this human concept of right and wrong.these are the theistic and atheistic positions. since you begged off to hear the theistic arguments i'll just share with you what i know about the other view- the atheistic. there are a number of versions of this but i think the one that really is worth contemplating on, is the argument that morality is the product of evolving human consciousness with respect to his surroundings and experience. example, our ancestral prehistoric females learned that less violent males make for better partners and fathers to their young. more agressive males were marked as more likely to commit rape, dominate the females, and hinder the development of the young ones. hence, this selection process passed on less violent genes to their predecessors-us and thus giving us the "morality" to disdain violence, rape, and anything bloody. but the agressive gene hasnt been totally eliminated. that's why we still have some of the ills and mistakes of the primitive angry caveman. that's the force that drives a man in doing good or bad as far as these atheists are concerned.

2007-07-03 05:08:51 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

have you ever heard the song " the riddle" by five for fighting. the lyrics go

heres a riddle for you
find the answer
theres a reason for the world
you and I

that set of lyrics puzzled me. what did the songwriter mean? and then one day it struck me...that the "reason for the world."
was based on the relationships we have with other people. the reason for the world...to me is being able to have meaningful interactions with other people around us. To find people we love, to understand one another. Thats how an atheist can die in peace, knowing he has loved people and touched other people's lives. I know this explaination may be cryptic, but thats how i feel. and also...the quote from starwars "may the force be with you"...it means may you always have the connection with other people that are important to you. Again cryptic...but think about it.

2007-07-03 04:32:39 · answer #6 · answered by sophia Grace 4 · 0 0

we don't understand and surely, we gained't even risk an fairly knowledgeable wager. first of all, we don't understand if area is finite or infinite. despite if this is infinite, then someplace, something no longer surely prohibited by skill of the regulations of physics could desire to ensue. this is purely because of the fact an non-0 possibility accelerated by skill of infinity could desire to furnish a possibility of one. Then assuming that area is finite, that's probable the final public view between cosmologists, we nonetheless don't understand what the preconditions are for existence to start. And we additionally don't understand what the possibility is, given those preconditions, that existence will start up. the only real information we've on any of those questions is the final, and this is no longer encouraging. so a strategies as we are able to tell, all residing issues in the international have a elementary ancestor. That makes it seem as though existence in the international purely began as quickly as - which, in case you think of roughly it, is fairly unusual, except, of direction, existence is definitely very, very inconceivable.

2016-11-08 01:23:12 · answer #7 · answered by ? 4 · 0 0

There is not a guiding force other than a combo of genetics/instinct and your upbringing.

Nothing metaphysical. Obviously many people make huge huge mistakes almost all through their lives. So there can't be such a force.

Your feelings could be fear, apprehensions, anticipation, etc...

2007-07-03 04:29:56 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

You do not want to bring God into this but it is a desire to find out where did we come from and man ever since we first had the first thought was where do I fit into this world. Every one asks this question every day he is alive and one must find this out for ones self whether it is through God or thinking we came from a space ship or from an ape. Only you can find this out for your self but not by limiting things from entering your thought process. Ask and you will hear but more will come from each time you ask. Seek and you shall find. Close the door and you will go no where. Confucius said " a journey of a 1000 miles begins with the first step".

2007-07-03 04:41:09 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 2 2

Yes. Doesn't matter whether you call it God, the Universe, Divinity, your conscience, your heart, your inner voice or Santa, we all have that spiritual center that tells us right from wrong. Even atheists believe in their own individual power to choose between good and evil. Too many individuals chose not to listen to that powerful center, but that doesn't mean it's not there.

2007-07-03 04:33:49 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

fedest.com, questions and answers