Do you think you have an open mind about politics that oppose your own?

Question

I think a lot of people totally shut down when they hear an opinion or political view that makes them uncomfortable. Most people have pre-conceived ideas going into an argument or debate, and are very stubborn about changing them because they feel they KNOW beyond a doubt that their stance is correct. I think it's always good to at least listen to other people, at least to show respect. Sometimes I have trouble with it, but I have to remember that I've learned a lot from people who are the polar opposite of me politically. I'm just wondering how many people out there really feel that they *listen* rather than just waiting for their turn to talk (or yell). Do you feel like you are open to the idea that a notion you feel strongly about might be incorrect?

john p. - why is it stupid that i asked a question about something my dog did (my "last question" was about something my dog did).. not really sure why that's stupid?

Answer 1

It has been proven to me enough times that I can in fact be incorrect about a strongly-held notion that I no longer try to deny it.

I am also able to argue different sides of a question fairly coherently (I loved the mock trial competitions in high school).

I listen to anyone who speaks politely, and I read and respond to all emails sent to me by those who disagree with any of my posts.

Answer 2

I think people use the term open minded incorrectly too many times. Open minded means you are willing to listen and research diff viewpoints and facts to get a complete picture of the issue, but it doesnt mean you can't then make an informed decision and stick to it. You are not closeminded if you refuse to accept another point of view if you took that point of view into consideration when finalizing your conclusions.

I think there are people here that know they are right no matter what just because this is how they were raised or because they resent something about the other side. Those people are probably closeminded and not open to new ideas. But I also think there are plenty of people that have looked at many sides, esp in terms of politics, and have concluded based on the facts and their values as to what they are going to believe. There are not a whole lot of mindshattering new thoughts being thrown out there on these message boards. I haven't really read any new facts or perspectives from those I both agree with and disagree with. I think a lot of people just like to debate and share their opinions. But if a person refuses to change their viewpoint or even say that maybe the other side might be right, then that doesnt make them closeminded. Why would you say the other side might be right if you have concluded based on the facts that you dont think their side is right?

Answer 3

Even the most closed-minded person would answer "yes" to this question.

Perhaps a good gauge would be a comparison of one's own views today to one's own views from five years ago. If the person's views have changed appreciably in that short time period, the person is probably open minded and a good person to have conversations with.

On the other hand, if the person's views have not changed; I'm not sure you can conclude anything. The person may feel that all of the evidence they have seen presented is still insufficient to sway them in the other direction. This is not necessarily closed-mindedness; for the person would still be actively weighing the evidence in this circumstance. Closed-minded people, on the other hand, would -not- weigh the evidence; and instead simply restate their own solidified opinion.

Tread through this water carefully.

Answer 4

The ones who talk sensibly cause me to look up the information to confirm or disprove. Some of the points brought up are nothing more than personal opinion that only time will prove or disprove. I do enjoy reading opinions even though they aren't always the same as mine. It sometimes softens my opinion but rarely changes it. It is interesting to see things from a different perspective.

I am a democrat but I realize that neither party should be in power for too long. Things become way too unbalanced.

Answer 5

I believe I have an open mind to others political views; with exception. When their political views paramounts as a wielding sword against the Constitution of the United States.

Currently the Republican Party has position itself to give in to the whims of Corporate America and her twin sister International Corporate interest; regardless of voices of the voters of America. The GOP, has been hijacked and ruin its image. I find it appalling when I hear those who still support the GOP; even after being betrayed and used like dirty whores: Born Again Christians; Middle Class Americans; Log Cabin Supporters; Military; Border Patrol Agents; Unions; those in of the Gulf Region; and those who truly believed in their values for the last 6.5 years,

Answer 6

I will listen and think about it. If it is reasonable and not harmful, I will change my thinking on that point or at least understand why the difference. However, if the opposing politics is, in my mind, harmful to the concept of liberal republicanism as espoused by the USA Constitution, then I draw the line. When I say liberal, I refer to the classic definition that refers to individual freedoms and responsibility, very limited central government, and is against tyranny of all forms, not the modern one that is, in essence, another name for Marxism.

Answer 7

I feel good if I can just understand their language. It seems like Liberals and Conservatives are coming at this nation from two completely different mindsets.

I simply do not believe our nation needs fixing. At least by anyone around here these days. Our Constitution works fine.

Answer 8

I generally do. I understand where they're coming from, and if they can marshal facts, logic and reason, I will consider their views.

However, it must be noted that there is no one truth in politics. Based on how people view the role and purpose and scope of government, answers will vary quite significantly. People must accept that they will often agree to disagree.

Answer 9

It's a sign of maturity and objectivity to listen and reason. It pays to be informed and read the pros and cons and objections on issues before taking a stand especially with all the mistrust that occurs.

Answer 10

I make it a special point to study the politics which I detest. I am well versed, for example, in the Marxist doctrines and philosophies. I have read Das Kapital and the Communist Manifesto many times.

One of the most significant precepts of Master Sun Tzu, ancient Chinese author of the military treatise, The Art of War, was "know thy enemy"

I will give Marx one thing, he was right about religion.