They say the spirit lives on, but if we never take our memories into another life?

Question

Does it not mean that this time around is the only time we live, as far as WE are concerned. And does that not mean that for us death is final? If this is not the right place to post this question would somebody please re-direct me.

Answer 1

Who are "they?". If they say we never take our memories into another life" where do they get their evidence? No one has ever come back to relate what another life is like or even if there is another life.

Why were memories created or evolved? If you believe (from experience) that every effect has its cause then the effect of memory too has a cause and a purpose in life. We just don't know what its cause and purpose is completely.

I know this is anathema in a philosophy section but there is no disgrace in saying honestly, "I do not know!" There is also no disgrace in having faith that there is some cause and purpose.

Seek on but provide some source and evidence for assertions.

Answer 2

Some beliefs concerning this do incorporate memory. However, it seems like you are focusing on reincarnation...

You are exactly right. Not only that, but remembering past lives would be irrelevant to our new ones anyway, unless, in the context of Buddhism, one becomes increasingly enlightened and can make use of something in a past life (though Buddhism focuses on the present, not the past).

You may as well say we are a new person in the next life, and the one after that, and the one after that...

I suppose this would show how there is no real self, as even this is changing. In each life, we have form, sensation, perception, mental formations, and consciousness, so that is something shared. However, these are rather abstract, meaningless ideas because they vary from person to person - from life to life. They are not things in themselves, so they do not change; their relationship to the individual always changes. This ever-changing "self" is therefore illusory, as it is impermanent in a number of ways.

So, you are correct in the understanding of reincarnation, and you can take it a step further.

Answer 3

Who says you don't take your memories with you? Of course you do. How else would you be reunited with your loved ones in Heaven? That's what I believe. It's the only thing that gives some solace when someone dies. Death is not the end. They're not gone. They're in another room, waiting for you...

The soul remembers love for eternity.

It would remember pain & torment too. What would be the point of Heaven & Hell if we didn't reflect on the lives we lived that put us there?

Answer 4

Iam not sure who says this, but I feel that when I go on to a better place I will be able to visit those loved ones of the past and have fond memories of what took place over my life's history.

Answer 5

I dont see how that would desire to paintings. Polygamy now could be extremely unorthodox, valuable, even though it doesnt *bodily* divide the relatives. If a guy with many different halves married somebody with yet another husband, the families could be split, they wouldnt comprehend who fathered her toddlers between the two adult men, and it may basically be pointless. incredibly valuable any sealings on Josephs section to a married lady substitute into to entitle her to everlasting reward, to no longer easily have all of them be his spouse. one subject isnt inevitably the different. i comprehend this. Heaven is heaven. no person would be in a compelled subject they do no longer desire to be a factor of. This via no potential might desire to be heaven.

Answer 6

Maybe we do, there have been cases of past life regression, or maybe there is a kind of combined race memory, until we cross we will never know, and we can only cross when the time is right.