Should Movies like Hostle Part 2...?

Question

Texas chanesaw, and Saw be required to have a NC-17 rating?

I think so

Ok,.....NC-17 does not let people under 17 in at all, R lets them in with there parents. SO You want children to watch people get cut up and killed with the most violent means in the history of films? Can you say psycho killer in 20 years? Freaks.

Answer 1

Violent movies don't necessarily make people violent. It's just what we become.

I hardly believe that the story is true. Somewhere in this beautiful world those horrors do happen.

Answer 2

No. If they required an NC-17 rating, they wouldve been given one rather than an R or PG-13 rating. If people find the content of the films disturbing, they dont have to go see them.

Answer 3

Why? The 'R' rating tells you the movie has sex, gore, violence. An NR-17 would indicate vulgar sex, extensive gore & ultra-violence. Surely when you see a horror movie with rating of 'R' you know what to expect!? The 'R' tells you that so why would you need an 'NR17' to say it's worse than it really is?
Now all that being said, are you watching the 'unedited/uncut/director's versions of these on dvd? If so, then YES they WOULD be considered NR-17 if shown that exact way at theatres. However they weren't shown that way at theatres, which is indicated by the label of being 'unedited, uncut,director's cut'. That alone SHOULD tell you the movie is, well, ehr, 'uncut' etc... ;-)

Answer 4

Violent movies dont necessarily make people violent... I'm a living proof

Answer 5

Why? They already have an R rating which is more than enough. It's not like they are scary or anything. People who can't handle it don't have to watch.

Answer 6

no its just a thriller movie w/ a lot of torture scenes, unless they have a lot of nudity then it would be consider n-17