Randy Johnson vs. Pedro Martinez - Who is (read was/is) Better?

Question

Just looking for opinions.

Answer 1

you wont find a bigger Pedro Martinez fan, but Randy Johnson, in his prime, was better than Pedro Martinez. Consider this, in Johnson's best span of his career [1994-2002], he pitched 1935 innings with 2620 strikeouts, gathering 156 wins. In Petey's best 9 year span [1996-2004], he went 147-55 with 1841.2 innings and 2210 punchouts. Give Randy the nod, but Pedro's been more consistent.

Answer 2

Johnson has been an elite pitcher for the last decade Pedro was good for a handful. 286 wins to 206 the strikeouts aren't even close 6 300 k seasons to 1. Both have a win% over .650. Pedro played for some good red rox teams and met teams. Johnson played the first 12 years of his career on losing teams. Jonhsons k per 9 is the highest ever. Johnson by far the better pitcher I mean where is pedro now back of the rotaion guy at best and he is still realitively young compared to Johnson and Johnson is till mowing batters down.

Answer 3

Randy Johnson has won 9 strike out titles. Four in a row in both the AL and NL during a time in which Pedro Martinez and Roger Clemens were all in their prime. Had Randy played on half decent winning teams he would have won at least 5 more Cy Youngs.

Answer 4

Peak Pedro (1999-2000) beats anyone since the 19th century. Yeah, I mean that, no matter how much it aggrieves the Koufax groupies or the Feller fellows or the "lookit whut Carlton did with the really sucky Phillies" pholks or the Ryan ravers.

Otherwise, it's Johnson, though it's rather close and could make for an interesting discussion. But at peak? Martinez es los hombre.

Answer 5

Pedro Martinez. Because of his small size and was thought of never being anything but a reliever. Tommy Lasorda didn't think he was anything good and when he traded him for Delino De Shields (I still ache) Pedro proved the whole world what he's made of. I admire Pedro for his belief in himself and for what he became. Johnson is great but I've never been intimidated when he faces my team (Go Dodgers).

Answer 6

Greg Maddux He develop right into a great pitcher. He has the excellent combination of longetivity and high quality. He might have had the backside era+, yet he pitched one thousand innings extra suitable than eiyher of them. Greg Maddux has the utmost era+ 132 of 5000 IP member of the stay ball era. Maddux at top develop into arguably between the excellent ever. inspite of the years shortened via strike, he nevertheless controlled over 2 hundred IP and 10 CG in each and each. 8 innings to a initiate on standard that year proves that he develop into basically pulled out as a results of fact they needed a nearer. He develop into thoroughly dominant with era+'s over 260!!!. Then out of information Maddux develop into the neatest pitcher ever. He did no longer have a blazing facebook, yet he had appropriate administration and placed his pitches in simple terms the place the batter could no longer do a element with it. Randy himself stated that Maddux develop into extra suitable as a results of fact he did no longer choose a ninety 5-ninety 8 mph facebook to be dominant. Maddux is a without a doubt great pitcher. Pedro maybe might have been the excellent yet he develop into fragile and could no longer pitch as much as the two of them. Greg Maddux used his appropriate administration and brains to outsmart batters and detect the pitch in spots they might get out in, and he wasn't even a strikeout pitcher yet nevertheless racked up 3300! he's the suited place style for a glass. he's likewise an all time great participant as a results of fact he additionally can lay down a bunt okay and has 18 GG, maximum for any place. relaxing certainty: Pedro Martinez, Greg Maddux and Fergie Jenkins are the only pitchers with 3000+ ok's and decrease than one thousand walks.

Answer 7

Hard question both players helped their teams to win WS and both got great stuff. Now i think Martinez is/was better well not by much. i just think of Johnson stay in NY. that didnt help him and that's the tie breaker i think.