American & French Revolution?

Question

im comparing and contrasing both wars and i was wondering what are some points i should include
examples???? sources???

Answer 1

The Yanks were trying to kick out the Brits - the French was purely internal, rather a civil war than a revolution.

Both were a reaction against the monarchy, but the French actually liked theirs.

American led to an isolationist policy, French led to aggressive empire building in the Napoleonic Wars.

Answer 2

On the surface, there were parallels. However, the American Revolution brought forth a relatively free economy and limited government, the French Revolution brought forth first anarchy, then dictatorship. The French Revolution failed because it compromised the principles upon which a free society is based, such as self-government, free markets, property rights, and limited civil government. The American Revolution, however, brought forth the world's freest society. Taking into consideration the fact that slavery in the U.S. was an issue that took away the very rights of humans the founding fathers wanted to protect. Additionally, the French Revolution has been considered the forerunner of the many, modern violent revolutions that have ended in totalitarianism. The American Revolution was a war indeed, but less violent in comparison. Even today, their are French peoples that are troubled by the revolution b/c of the ideology, events, and result. Cheers!

Answer 3

The American Revolution(despite europa's ignorant comments) were indeed a radical change, the change being that the PEOPLE were sovereign and could decide how, when, where and why to govern themselves. The American Revolutionaries did not kill their former leaders, they did not kowtow to a mob who wanted constant bloodshed as if they were back in the Roman Colisseum. What they did do was to establish the most radical society in the world to date, a country wherein the PEOPLE would have self-rule, rather than the autocratic rule of a secular or religious potentate and the further radical idea is that it worked, and they established the most stable, successful and longest tenured representative democracy the world has ever known.

The French Revolution quickly dissolved into anarchy, dictatorship, Empire, back to the Royalist kings, back to a Republic, back to a empire and back to a republic, not exactly a model for stability. Not to mention the fact that it inspired the thinking of Marx and the actions of Lenin and Stalin and Mao in the brutal repression and killing of anyone and everyone who were not fully supportive of them.

Simply put, the American Revolution was a radical change in the way nations were governed and the French Revolution was nothing more than political anarchy.

whale

Answer 4

I think the most important thing you should note here, and you can write the entire essay just on that, is that the American rebellion was not a revolution. It was maybe a quazi-revolution, but did not nearly inspire and result in enough change for it to be labelled by definition as a revolution (of course the Americans had given such a title to their rebellion to make it seem more dramatic, and to make people think that a lot had acutallly changed, which was not so...a revolution implies radical change!). The French Revolution can live up to its name, as society took a general reorganisation wuite a few times and later under Napoleon again, with new declarations and constitutions written to alter the class system, system of economy, government, foreign policy, military and so on. The American war was merely a rebellion, because England wanter to keep its colonies, and even though the new government was not a monarchy, soceity did not change that much and the rebellion did not have nearly as much effect on the world as the French Revolution had.

Answer 5

the yank Revolution replaced into fought to be sure that rights got here from God, no longer the state. The French Revolution replaced into fought to be sure that rights got here from guy and not God or the state. the yank Revolution replaced right into a Christian Revolution. The French Revolution replaced into an anti-Christian Revolution. One, the yank Revolution, replaced into fought to be sure rights preceived back from God and shrink the skill of the state over the guy. the different replaced into fought to do away with royalty and the effect of the Catholic Church interior the lives of the voters of France. the suited occasion of the reason at the back of the yank Revolution is contained interior the announcement of Independence wherein the promise is made that if the Colonists whipped the British the hot government to be formed could shelter existence created by God. the USA reneged on that promise in 1973 and grew to grow to be an earthly state. u . s . a . of america replaced into best as much as this place with the feminist flow that began interior the Sixties. As President Obama has mentioned, this united states of america is no longer a Christian united states of america. It ceased to be in 1973 whilst the preferrred court docket ruled, in effect, that God replaced into ineffective, that lady replaced into the author and had the constitutional desirable to kill what she had created.

Answer 6

Both countries where trying to get rid of the Monarchy & win more freedom.