Twilight and New Moon?

Question

Has anyone else thought that Edward is going to kill Jacob, either in Eclipse or one of the other books? My reasoning is as follows-
(page 370)-"What if Paris had been Juliet's friend?...what if she loved Paris. Not like Romeo...but enought that she wanted him to be happy, too?"
(page 552)-"...I remembered what happened to paris when Romeo came back. The stage directions were simple:They fight. Paris falls."- That Edward will kill Jacob, like Romeo killed Paris
(page 17)-"...And then, a few minutes after their wedding, he kills Juliet's cousin."~Edward-Duh. Right after their wedding (subsitute coming back? I'm not sure if they will get married or not, but Bella should marry him) he kills Juliet's cousin Paris.

Just wondering if anyone else had thought of the same thing...

Answer 1

I never thought of that, but now that makes me think.. I have suspected the whole ending like romeo and juliet because of the quotes.. and well the story, but ouch.. i dont partiularly love jacob so i wouldnt mind but reading all of the extra chapters and jacobs and Edwards point of view i think that there is going to be a battle.. and i believe in this next book she will be changed but you know stephanie she will probably put a twist in it... LOVE IT!!!

Happy Reading

Answer 2

I don't think so. Jacob, like what was said in New Moon, is incredibly strong given that he's new to becoming a werewolf compared to the others in the so-called pack. Edward isn't one to attack someone on impulse, especially if it means endangering his family and letting their secret out to the entire community of Forks. He'd be selfish enough to do that. Remember that in Romeo and Juliet, Romeo is the only one banished, not including his family. In Bella and Edward's story, if (and when) he does that, the entire Cullens would not only be banished, they would be prosecuted. Another thing to consider is the bit about Bella not wanting Jacob to be hurt--he's still her best friend, after all.

And what Bella said about Romeo and Juliet is just a comparison of sorts. Although she may have, in her dreams, seen things that will soon happen, it does not give her the power of clairvoyance. Oh, but we'll see. Maybe it is what Meyer planned for us... =)

Answer 3

definitely a possibility but there is still the rest of the "pack" to consider. i feel like the cullens will have to move away from forks in order to change bella. otherwise the wherewolves WILL be all over them and that wouldn't be good. but they do have the obligation of changing bella, as promised in italy.

i like jacob but there is NO way that bella would chose is friendship over edward. i hope the series doesn't end in a r+j way, that would be devastating.

Answer 4

NO.Edward will not kill Jacob...its all wrong for the book.And Edward doesnt seem to hate jacob enough to do it.And really,if you think about it...Edward i utterly in love with Bella.He knows that Jacob is her best friend.He would never do anything to hurt her or make her upset.

Answer 5

I yes they will kill jacob but i really just hope bella will marry edward becz if she wont then i might have to hit her in her eye

Answer 6

Jacob getting killed by Edward is just so sad for me because I really love Jacob! I know that's possible, but I really hope that doesn't happen because I would probably cry if he dies....
>_>

Answer 7

I hope not!
[How will Bella feel after her lover kills her best friend?.]

Answer 8

I can't answer your question, but my friends loveeeee those books. Ugh I just can't understand why.