Am I all alone in thinking that David Chase is a freaking Genius?

Question

Think about it

I've been watching this series from the first episode and

It could end no other way

Either Tony Lives , Or Dies , or it's left up to us

Chase chose the latter

Answer 1

No you don't have to be singleminded to think the ending was great.

I've been watching since episode 1, and I like the fact that he had me in my seat thinking "okay only 45 minutes left" "okay only 30 minutes left"

Phil dies, We find out tony is 90% chance of getting indited, we figure out who the rat is, we figure out that paulie was good all along, you're never going to know if sil wakes up from the coma, so if tony gets arrested who will take over - paulie? or sil that comes out of a coma. We all thought tony was about to die in the restaraunt but we don't really know, I DONT THINK HES DEAD! I think that the ending was good!

Answer 2

I thought it was genius by whoever came up with it, but NOT TOO SURE IF IT WAS ACTUALLY CHASE'S IDEA. He is more dark and creative. Most who know him thought you would see a suicide. I thought it was interesting though because everyone wanted a "closure" type of thing, but really, the epi was titled "made in america" and it ended with a family dinner. It almost had a 7th heaven-ish kind of ending.

Answer 3

Davis chase is a butthead Tony could have woke up from a coma or a dream but the ending sucked unless your a very simple minded individual then it was probably good

Answer 4

I disagree. The ending was a copout. He should have decided if Tony lives or dies.

Answer 5

The cheese stands alone my friend!

Answer 6

Alone.

Answer 7

he got lazy... we deserve a good ending after gay mob bossess

Answer 8

You're alone!