Was the Sheriff who released Paris Hilton in contempt of court?

Question

This story is just beginning as there's lots of outrage over how and why she was released. The prosecutor has filed a motion that the Sheriff was in contempt of the court order which specifically did not allow her to have an ankle monitor.

So how should the court rule?

Answer 1

According to the most recent information, the judge and district attorney are steaming. See the following report:

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/n/a/2007/06/07/state/n142235D44.DTL

Reuters has reported that Asst. DA has filed a motion calling for charging the Sheriff's office with contempt.

Another source says:

The City Attorney in Los Angeles is challenging the Sheriff's decision to send Paris Hilton home on house arrest. The Judge has scheduled a hearing tomorrow. You can read the motion here. (pdf)

The City Attorney is also demanding that the Sheriff pick her up at her house tomorrow and transport her to court for the hearing.

There's more. He is asking the Judge to hold the Sheriff in contempt of court for putting Paris on home detention which the Judge precluded in his sentencing order. The court spokesman today said the Sheriff asked the judge to modify the sentence to home detention yesterday and the judge declined. But, the Judge was told of the sentence change before

Answer 2

The Sheriff clearly could not control his staff who were using cell phones to record Paris while behind bars. Paris did not like having her privacy invaded and the Sheriff could not ban cell phones from his staff. Therefore, the Sheriff defied the Judge's order and released Paris Hilton to home detention.

After all, Hilton made millions from her sex tape when she controlled everything from production to distribution BUT she did not like being at the mercy of the Sheriff's Deputies.

As judge, I would publicly reprimand the Sheriff and warn him that future one-sided releases would result in contempt of court and the Sheriff serving the same sentence as the accused.

Answer 3

The Sheriff is an officer of the court...he is not the judge.
Releasing her with the judge's permission is contempt of court, by defying the order of the judge.

The judge should return her to jail per his original sentence.

Answer 4

The sheriff should be held in contempt, better if he be charged administratively and criminally.

You are really lucky that you have that kind of justice system in the US. If Paris Hilton is a citizen of the Philippines and considering her status (rich and famous), she cannot be easily jailed. You americans really implement the law. I salute you.

Answer 5

If that is what the court order said, and that is what the Sheriff did, then yes he should be held In Contempt.

Answer 6

confident. She could study his lesson earlier it fairly is purely too previous due. final week, there's a commonplace Taiwan lady singer who inebriated using and kill a nurse who went to artwork at 5:00 am. The detention center already great wiped sparkling up for her. She have already got the decide to be stay on my own. She have been given caught some time earlier the choose deliver her to detention center yet i'm advantageous she did DUI many many circumstances which she have been given away and did no longer get caught. i don't understand why her mom and dad ask Lee Baca for decide to launch her. it fairly is time for her to awaken. could be they supply extensive donation marketing campaign fund to Lee Baca or unfastened Hilton's Presidental Room Coupon? Do you think of Lee Baca care approximately you and me if we pass to detention center? Do you think of he will pay attention to our criticism? regulation meant to be colour blind yet no longer as a result, in case you have green, the eyes are opened extensive. i presumed as a result, Lee Baca is worst than Paris Hilton. no longer something is worst than a corrupt cop. If the pinnacle of the dep. acts like that, I have no advantageous interior the equipment.

Answer 7

Put her back in jail, give her meds like other inmates receive if that is what she needs and let her serve her time. Martha Stewart served her time and it was ALOT longer than her. Let her stay there for 45 days! The document specifically says, no weekends, no house arrest, no ankle monitor. The judge is even upset. The judge makes the rules!!!!!!

I hope she goes back. I am upset about it because none of us would get the same treatment. She is not even in general population. I hope her binging buddie Richie also goes to jail.

Answer 8

I guess it is probably a deal between the jail and the DA if someone is released early. In this case it cannot be the jail alone that dtermines it, or the Sherriff.

Answer 9

Sounds like some thing is going on the judge is mad and wants her back in jail.