Lets end it guys is it Brady or Manning?

Question

for me its brady heres why

brady to me is smarter and less concerned with being the hero. we see vinatieri winning games because brady sets him up to do so by making smart choices and needing to throw thw winning td and thats why vanderjerk misses because manning needs the game winner instead of picking up that 10-15 extra yds for the fg. also brady leads a team with almost nothing around him into indy and almost upsets the high power colts offense. jim sorgi because the colts have a great offense has a career 99.3 rating is sorgi great or are the receivers. i think manning is good but put caldwell and gaffney out there and does he make the afc championship game

Answer 1

Okay this is really hard for me because I am a die hard fan of GANG GREEN, yes the J-E-T-S, but I have to say that Brady is a way better quarterback than Manning, Manning has the stats because of all of the weapons he has, and no doubt about it, mechanically he is the best quarterback, but playing in the clutch is what makes a qb great, the colts won last year DESPITE Manning, because he played terribly. It was their defense that came alive and won the games. Brady on the other hand is smarter, doesn't give the game away, he drives down the field, he is great in the clutch and his team won superbowls BECAUSE of him, not despite him.

Answer 2

This year will be the year to tell. Brady will have Stallworth, Moss, Welker, and Kelly Washington, probably one of the most dominate receiving corps in the history of the league, and Manning will still have Harrison and Wayne. Brady is in a different offense that focuses on controlling the pace of the game especially with the powerful running game of the Pats. Manning has to make plays because the defense doesn't provide that much support. The weather is also not an issue for the Colts because of the dome, while the Pats always seem to be playing in the worst conditions whether in New England, the Meadowlands, and Buffalo.

Answer 3

Well, Manning made Brandon Stokley catch 10 TD passes and more than 1000 yards. This means that he really makes his staff play better.

I remember Jim Harbaugh was an above average QB, and despite he had Marvin Harrison as the main target and a primed Marshall Faulk (way better than Edge, Rhodes and Addai), he didn't do anything.

The defense only played good against Baltimore, but when you overcome a 21-3 deficit and win 38-34 in the last minute, there is not much credit to give to the defense.

It would be really interesting to see Manning with the support of the Pats defense and Brady with a defense in the bottom 10, trying to figure out that complex offensive scheme and changing the plays on the line like Peyton does.

Answer 4

Manning all day every day. Brady is a system QB and has had an above average defense in the past. If Manning had the Pats defense for the last 5 seasons he'd have 5 Super Bowl trophies.

Answer 5

Brady.....Thumbs DOWN!! Brady is WAY over ratted sure he has 3 super bowl rings, but thanks to Vinaterri. Brady got the credit and just gobbled it up. Did he give the credit where it was due?? NO. Manning gave every player the credit to his super bowl win. Manning is better, smarter, better, plays better, throws better, and is not all hot headed like Brady. So Manning is the best. He broke Marinos 50 TD passes in one season that stood for 20 years. Elway, Montana, Brady or Favre never even came close. Tell me who's the best!!

Answer 6

It really depends on the team. Could Brady play for the Colts? Or Manning for the Pats? They play the way that it is best for the team.

Answer 7

Peyton had 868 more yards this season, 7 more touchdowns, 54.2 more yds. per game, and had a 13.1 point higher qb rating for the season. Peyton also only had 9 interceptions compared to Tom's 12. Completion percent for Manning is also 3.2% better. Tom also had 12 fumbles compared to Peyton's 2. Peyton owns every stat. Peyton is definitely the better qb. Argument over.

Answer 8

Yeah, I really liked the guy who asked who would you go with? Manning leading the Pats or Brady leading the Colts? That does it for me! 3 SBs to 1? I still would go with Manning on that........

Answer 9

Last year it was Manning.
Who knows ,this year may be Palmer!
It all runs in cycles.Its been Brady for a few years,and everybody is betting on them this year.The only thing is I hate the favorite
They almost always dont finish on top.As far as history, Brady is secure with three Super Bowls.HOF.

Answer 10

MANNING...by a long shot. Even though Brady is famous for saving his team during the last 2min or less in a game. All around, Manning is a better Q.B. He works hard, and sticks through with it...not afraid to get out/throw running out 'da pocket :)

Ohhh..but one day soon it will be my SAINTS!!!!!!