is it offencive to look on a trans gender person in their original gender?

Question

i am not a homophobe and i am not trying to insult the people on this site. i just cannot accept that a man dressed as a woman is a woman. i dont mention it but i cannot treat that person as a woman, sorry if this insults it is not meant to, i just want to know if it is offencive or not

please....why am i a homophobe, i am a realist...men are men and women are women, i accept that a man may be born into a womans body but that still does not make that poerson a woman.

as a straight man i would never date a transexual, it does not mean i am a homophobe i just could not accept that person was a woman

Mr Shah, please dont answer any more of my questions!

lordwashu, very intense, i think you may well have hit the nail on the head

Answer 1

applause for lordwashu, I dont think your homophobic at all, you are just asking a question that interested you, and i cannot add anything more worthy of what lordwashu says, he says it all, good question, 1 star. x

Answer 2

To me you sound very homophobic, but never mind because TV's and TS's are not homosexuals. See the people on here with little knowledge lump everyone together. Homosexuals are men that go with men or women that go with women known as lesbians. But I am a transexual who had surgery, Doctors dont know the difference between me and a genetic woman. I also have a female birth certificate so how can you call me a man. If I so wanted I could have sex with you any day in the normal way, man to woman.

Answer 3

Offensive?

It's certainly impolite.

A 'man dressed as a woman' is not a woman, you're quite right. But if he is dressed as one, it's polite to address him as he chooses; most crossdressers prefer to be addressed as women while dressed as women,a nd men while dressed as men.

It *is* insulting, inappropriate and inaccurate to address a transsexual woman as a man, or vice versa.

If you are in doubt as to whether a given person is transsexual or a crossdresser, the simplest thing to do is to ask, politely and discreetly, how he or she wishes to be addressed.

And there's no need to protest that you're not a homophobe; you're not discussing homosexuality, so homophobia isn't involved.

Answer 4

Yeah, a little bit. I don't care at all if you don't want to date or sleep with transpeople- that's fine, you don't have to. But it is considered customarily kind, polite, and respectful to refer to someone as they wish to be referred. Trans people go through immense difficulties, and the least you can do is say "she" if that's what someone wants. It doesn't mean you have to change your viewpoints on their actual sex (though it would be nice)- just treat them with dignity, which includes using the pronouns and names they prefer.

Calling a transperson by their birth sex is akin to someone coming up to you and taking the worst attribute you have possible, and calling you it- fatty, idiot, uggo, whatever- it cuts to the core. Remember that.

Answer 5

Psychologist have proved that most of the time when a man dresses up as a woman or woman a man, then that means that is how they feel inside. The body is just a shell that contains our spirit. Besides, what would it hurt you to treat them how they feel?

Answer 6

It relies upon on the guy. maximum transmen i comprehend say that they have on no account felt lady, so as that they are merely as clueless approximately females because of the fact something of the dudes. That pronounced, in case you sense like a guy yet anybody thinks you're a woman, you style of get to bypass 'undercover', for you to talk, interior the worldwide of females- you will have interaction in all the female rituals, the bonding, and so on., and so on.. So maximum transmen have a definite wisdom of females that non-trans adult adult males do no longer.

Answer 7

A transsexual is asking a lot of you by demanding that you percieve them as their desired gender, when quite honestly modern medical science just isn't advanced enough to create "believable" results for transgender people. You seem like an intelligent, open-minded person, so please just try to understand their pain. Imagine being born in a female body, but still being you. Men trying to get with you, women looking right through you, the world upset and violent towards you for not wanting to wear fufu dresses and pink ribbons, the complete inability to be yourself or be seen as the gender you are. All those things, completely irreversible, for your entire existance. It sounds horrible, does it not? I cannot ask you to ever consider dating/marrying a transsexual, because I agree with you, gender reassignment really does come off as a desperate attempt to foster an illusion in most cases. But for the people who undergo it, they know how much they are asking of people to "believe it" with them, and how much society resents them for simply trying to be themselves, but they find the courage to do it not because they want to decieve you but because it is the ONLY way they can continue to live. Yes, it is a stretch, but please, if you can find it in your heart to try to accept these people as they present themselves, you will be granting them a little shred of happiness in a life which I guarentee you has had very little. Besides, an ignorant person accepts only black and white conceptions of the world, whereas a wise person is willing to believe in alternative possiblities and accept new things as they are presented in life.

Answer 8

You need to be more respectful.

Whether referring to them as their original gender is offensive or not, that depends on the person. Ask them what they would prefer to be called and try to show some respect for who they feel they truly are.

My friend is Transgender, female to male, but I've known her for a while and since I was introduced to her as "Arlene" I still refer to her as a girl and she has no problem with it.

Make sure to take their feelings into consideration.

Answer 9

It is insulting to treat a transperson as the person they were before. I'm not saying that you have to always use female pronouns and their new name and treat them just like you would any other person of their new sex. Just show some respect like you would to any other person and avoid using words that hurt them, like the pronouns of their old gender. It's possible to just not say names and use gender-neutral words. I've went days without using gendered pronouns, like he and her, and names. You don't have to show total acceptance, just basic respect.

Answer 10

would you like it if someone called you by the opposite gender than you know you are? i am not trying to be mean but think about it. i know that it is hurtful to be call a girl when you know you are a guy and vice versa. just take time to think about it. how would you feel to have people judge you by what was between your leg?