pussycat dolls show?

Question

who knows that Melissa R should of won instead of asia who cant even talk correctly?

Answer 1

i was rooting for melissa R ever since the auditions!!! asia, who doesn't know how to speak, should go home and be with her daughter. she has her life started already and i think she is being very irresponsibly by even auditioning for this position!

mellisa R, on the other hand, doesnt have her life started yet. her parents are both doctors and constantly tell her that music wont work out for her. they disapprove of her auditioning for the position and they do not support her. she needed this way more than aisa did and was just as qualified for the position. in fact, i think she was more qualified! she knew how to speak correctly, she wasnt a drama queen (who only ate hamburgers and special ordered food), and she needs a stable position in the music industry.

i also think it was unfair that asia's final song was a fast, upbeat one. if melissa R sang that song i think she would have done it the exact same way that asia did. but she was stuck singing a slow (nice, but slow) song --- and she didnt win because asia gave "a better perfomance."


i was very disappointed and think that melissa R should have won. she was definitely the better choice.

Answer 2

Melissa R was good,but I think Chelsea was better.She had a great voice,and she could have worked more on her dancing.Chelsea has great star quality that I haven't seen for yrs.Maybe it's better that Chelsea didn't win,she deserves to do solo work and have the whole spotlight on her.

I don't think Asia is the best girl for the PussyCat Dolls,but I don't think Melissa R was either.I feel Melissa S was better than Melissa R,and she was on Making the band 3.So Melissa S has tons of experience in the recording studio.

Answer 3

To me, that was OBVIOUS.
Honestly, I think it was a liability issue. Melissa R was strugling with religion and sexuality... versus Asia who has a kid at 18... if you were a producer with an employee working sex songs in Las Vegas, would you pick the conservative religious with sexuality issues, or the kid from the corner who's had a kid??
She's definitely a place holder and in a way that's good for her because she may not have found anything else!

Answer 4

Chelsea should have won.

As far as the show goes, I feel ripped off because I thought they were genuinely looking for a new Doll. Turns out it was just a money-making engine, since they're doing it again and no one is actually leaving the group. That sucks. I won't watch it next time.

Answer 5

They each lacked somewhere. I think Melissa R should have won, she can dance just as good as Asia, but she has a stronger (and not a whiney) voice.

Answer 6

I HATED asia! she does look like a drag queen, not very pretty at all!!!!!!!! i liked chelsea though, she really worked for it, all melissa did was fight with asia. i think chelsea should have won.

Answer 7

Thats any such good question.... I certainly have been thinking that often! no person seems to be attentive to! in case you bypass to PCD's myspace, another remark is "the place's Asia!?!" It sounds like they are popping out with yet another season of 'The Seach For the subsequent Doll' too.... i think of Carmiete is leaving. they are one annoying team to maintain up with!

Answer 8

i watched it and your right !! asia cant even talk that well ya know

Answer 9

Yea I know, and in 20 years they wont even be remembered....

Answer 10

asia shouldnt have won, but idk about melissa either. i liked the other one with the voice