Harry Potter fans, what do you think of this theory that Harry could go into the veil in the ministry of magic

Question

...and come out again in "Deathly Hallows"? Just like Gandalf in "The Lord Of The Rings" when he became "The White"? Could it be possible? What do you think?

Yeah, I know, dead is dead, but I thought Harry could be the only one in the whole wizarding world whom it could be possible for to come back, because he should be already dead, but survived somehow when Voldemort used the "Avada Kedavra" on him... The one who lived, once again...

Last time rescued through his mother´s love, this time rescued through deaths (the alchemistic theory: the sorcerer´s stone - when made - turning from black (Sirius BLACK´s death) to white (ALBUS=white Latin)Dumbledore´s death) to red (RUBEUS Hagrid´s death). They all sacrify for Harry...

Last time rescued through his mother´s love, this time rescued through deaths (the alchemistic theory: the sorcerer´s stone - when made - turning from black (Sirius BLACK´s death) to white (ALBUS=white Latin)Dumbledore´s death) to red (RUBEUS Hagrid´s death). They all sacrify for Harry...

Last time rescued through his mother´s love, this time rescued through deaths (the alchemistic theory: the sorcerer´s stone - when made - turning from black (Sirius BLACK´s death) to white (ALBUS=white Latin)Dumbledore´s death) to red (RUBEUS Hagrid´s death). They all sacrify for Harry...

Last time rescued through his mother´s love, this time rescued through deaths (the alchemistic theory: the sorcerer´s stone - when made - turning from black (Sirius BLACK´s death) to white (ALBUS=white Latin)Dumbledore´s death) to red (RUBEUS Hagrid´s death). They all sacrify for Harry...

Oh no, not so many times...
Sorry, it´s not my fault..
It just went...there.

Answer 1

I personally don't roll with this theory. Death is very real in Harry Potter, and is one of the only things that can't be reversed. It's the thing against which Voldemort fights hardest. The veil represents the mystery of death at its core. Since death in JK Rowling's writing is so absolute, I find it difficult to believe that someone would be able to experience the epitome of death and then be able to return.

Answer 2

Great theory, but Dumbledore himself said that Sirius could not come back from the other side of the veil, so Harry couldn't either. He would be dead, just like Sirius

Answer 3

i'm undecided what blond youngster in a image you're relating, and the veil replaced into element of the dep. of Mysteries. The veil replaced into the barrier between the living and the ineffective and demise, being a secret, replaced into the place Sirius gone by way of to as he chosen in his life to no longer walk the earth as a ghost like others chosen to do- which includes almost Headless Nick. this is a manner of finding at demise as finality from this life.

Answer 4

I've heard that theory before...the names mean so much and jkr has said that she really likes alchemy, so i bet it is somewhat true. at least, i bet hagrid will die to protect harry...

we don't know what is beyond the veil. harry needs to ask first lupin (because lupin somehow knew that he wasn't coming back), then dumbledore's portrait, and then mr weasly or someone else in the ministry about what lies beyond the veil.

or, he could not go back at all...and just leave it, but i doubt that. i think he will go to the department of mysteries again, but i don't think that he'll go through the veil...unless that's where the cover takes place.

remember, this all has to lead up to harry and voldemort's final battle, and this either has to be with alternate wands or without magic (priori incantatem). so if they can duel beyond the veil, then that's where they need to go. But if they dont need to, then they probably won't.

Answer 5

I don't think Harry will go in/come out but I do think Sirius will.

Unless the ending is this scene I imagined where him and Voldemort are in that room and they "kill" eachother and Harry falls into the veil, but some kind of way he is able to come back and he brings through all of Voldemort's victims. Wouldn't that be sweet?

Answer 6

Sirius is gone.
American Heritage Dictionary - Cite This Source hal·low (hāl'ō) Pronunciation Key
tr.v. hal·lowed, hal·low·ing, hal·lows

To make or set apart as holy.
To respect or honor greatly; revere.

respect greatly death...perhaps harry's death. She did say there wasn't going to be any way to write another. it'd play well into the theory that harry is a horcrux...

I dont want the DL to die, but I know he will...i can still hope though...

Answer 7

Yes, I thought about that. Maybee something like that will happen, but do you think he'll come back out? Death is . . . Dead. But does the veil really kill you? *sigh* To many theories. We'll just have to wait--not much longer!

Answer 8

no. it's a veil of death.if he fell thru it,means he dies..harry os not likely 2 go fall in it but he could talk 2 d ppl in it like sirius,dumbledore when he wants to.

Answer 9

I think Voldemort will fall through the veil ... pushed by either Neville or Draco Malfoy.

Answer 10

Possibility exists...But for voldemort to die he should also be sent into the veil also...n then harry can return n emerge as a hero (which he already is)