Which of these players will make it to the H.O.F.?

Question

Eddie George
Keyshawn Johnson
Tiki Barber
Junoir Seau

And Priest Holmes

Charles S- Priest Holmes got a ring with the Baltimore Ravens.

Answer 1

Junior is the only lock, the others are maybes at best.

Answer 2

Seau for sure.

Barber, and Johnson have the right area of numbers and went to super bowls, but neither will be first ballet. A lot depends on who retires this year and next, if they don't make in 3 they probably won't. Barber has return yards, and passing stats that help him. Johnson change the way he played. When he first came into the league, he was a fast guy, a #1 rec. Last few years he changed into a position rec, that got the over the middle catches. and both retire while they could still play.

George might have rushing numbers are in the right area, but his game was only one dimensional, and he played in Tenn. With Bettis, Barber, Faulk, Martin all retiring he doesnt' stand much of a chance. A lot of his stats went down his last year or two in Dallas. So I don't think so.

Holmes numbers are only a couple of years are really good, but over his career that's only like 4 good years. Never played in a super bowl. No way.

Answer 3

Seau will make it!

George, Holmes and Johnson will not make it.

Holmes was only great for 4 years

George was a good back for a long time but it isn't called the "hall of good"

Johnson just wasn't productive enough for long enough (plus, his mouth and attitude are held against him.)

Tiki Barber MIGHT make it but I believe he was a couple of good years away. It didn't help his case that he left on his own. Some voters might see that as a slap in the face.

Answer 4

Eddie George, Keyshawn Johnson and Junior Seaus are all guaranteed but Tiki Barber hung it up way too early. Priest Holmes, i think will go in if he plays 2 more years.

Answer 5

Eddie George- Probably

Keyshawn Johnson- most likely

Tiki Barber- no

Junior SEAU- OF COURSE

Answer 6

Tiki Barber and Junior Seau

Answer 7

Tiki Barber hung it up about two years two early
Keyshawn Johnson will not make it - especially if Art Monk does not
Eddie George is on the brink- he was an MVP type for several years - no championships- oft-injured and didn't play forever
Junior Seau is a sure thing

Answer 8

-Seau is a first timer with honors. No question
-Keyshawn Johnson will get in but not first time and of the four, the only player with a superbowl win
-Eddie should be able to visit whenever he wants but without 11,000 rushing yards it will be hard for him to get in. Plus the way he went out. I think no.
-Tiki left to early and that will be held against him but in his playing days....he was really good. Wich makes him such a question mark. I think he is 50/50 and I will say I dont think so, but it wouldnt suprise me if he does, on the simple fact that once his brother Ronde gets in and he will, that there will be a push to enshrine Tiki as well.

Answer 9

I know that Seau will make it. I am almost sure Eddie George is going to make it. But Keyshawn has a shot but I don't think he will nor Tiki Barber because I don't think he had played long enough.

Answer 10

Eddie George and Junior Seau are maybes. Tiki Barber is definitley in. Keyshawn Johnson is not in.

Answer 11

seau for sure. the others would be hard pressed because in all reality their careers are average.

maybe keyshawn..but even that's pushing it. george doesn't have the numbers. and barber didn't start long enough to beconsiders..atleast on the first ballot. i mean if that's the case then one terrel davis would be a sure in (a 2000 yard rusher with more than one title) many of the experts say davis isn't a sure in...so i can't give it to barber either (even if he is a good guy)