which of these players would make the hall of fame and which ones wont?

Question

keyshawn
trent green
kurt warner
rod smith
isaac bruce
joe horn
terry glenn
tiki barber
drew bledsoe
priest holmes
brad johnson
jeff garcia

Answer 1

keyshawn-This is closer than you'd think bc of his stats and 1 ring. He shouldn't get in until Art Monk does.
trent green-No
kurt warner-perhaps...at least in the feel-good wing
rod smith-Tim Brown was better so until he gets in....
isaac bruce-again, many more better WR's have yet to get in
joe horn-no way
terry glenn-no
tiki barber-absolutely (2nd-3rd ballot at worst)
drew bledsoe-A difficult one, eventually might get in.
priest holmes-Terrell Davis is a comparable example and is more deserving.
brad johnson-no way (bucs scored more pts on defense in that SB)...see Trent Dilfer
jeff garcia-no

Answer 2

Keyshawn-no
Trent Green-no
Kurt Warner-no
Rod Smith-maybe
Isaac Bruce-maybe
Joe Horn-no
Terry Glenn-no
Tiki Barber-yes
Drew Bledsoe-yes
Priest Holmes-no
Brad Johnson-no
Jeff Garcia-no

Answer 3

I think it will be as followed:

keyshawn -> Yes
trent green - No
kurt warner - Yes
rod smith _ Yes
isaac bruce - Yes
joe horn - No
terry glenn - No
tiki barber - Yes
drew bledsoe - Yes
priest holmes - Yes
brad johnson - No
jeff garcia - No

Sorry for the short answer but I'm in a hurry and just wanted to answer the question.

Answer 4

keyshawn - no

trent green - no

kurt warner - no, he choked after a few good seasons

rod smith - possibly, but most likely not...I don't think simply because he's the best undrafted player ever means he deserves the HOF when his production isn't stellar compared to the rest of the WR pool

isaac bruce - most likely...top 10 WR all-time, a ring, and consistent producer

joe horn - no

terry glenn - no

tiki barber - he was a great Giant and will surely get his # retired by them. Because of playing for NY, he may get extra attention in the balloting, but he doesn't deserve to be in the HOF. Only 3 Pro Bowl years, and there are much better RB's, past and present.

drew bledsoe - probably not...he made a name for himself with a few 4000 yard seasons, but if you look at his numbers, they're not very good.

priest holmes - probably not...two good seasons, followed by an injury-plagued career.

brad johnson - probably not, but he does have a ring and a few records, so it's a possibility. If Romo gets injured (or pulled) and he can lead the Cowboys to an SB, then I'd say he's a shoe-in.

jeff garcia - no...just a couple of good seasons, that's it.

Answer 5

Good question. I will break it down by % of which gets in.

Tiki Barber 75% chance
Isaac Bruce 75%
Rod Smith 65%
Priest Holmes 60%
Kurt Warner 50%
Keyshawn Johnson 40%
Joe Horn 25%
Drew Bledsoe 25%
Terry Glenn 15%
Jeff Garcia 5%
Brad Johnson 0%

Answer 6

keyshawn - No
trent green - No
kurt warner - No
rod smith - Probably
isaac bruce - Possibly
joe horn - No
terry glenn - No
tiki barber - Possibly
drew bledsoe - No
priest holmes - Probably
brad johnson - No
jeff garcia - No

Rod Smith is probably the bet bet from this list.

Answer 7

I think Tiki has the best shot of the bunch. All the WR are not better than Art Monk and he has not made it in. Bruce has had the best career of the bunch but it will be difficult for him to get in. In football stats don't count as much as impact. If Bledsoe would have won the Superbowl as a starter he would probably get in eventually but since he didn't win, it will be tough. Warner not enough years. He was a shooting star. Holmes? He had an unbelievable 3-4 year run but that might not get him in. I would vote for him but it will be tough.

Answer 8

Only Bledsoe from this list has a chance to get in. Current players that are locks:
Peyton
Brady
Favre
Moss
Jason Taylor
Ray Lewis
Champ Bailey
Faulk (he may have just retired)

Answer 9

Of those players on the list:
Yes: Tiki Barber. I usually ***** and moan about players being overrated by the New York media. This isn't the case with Tiki. A terrific back both rushing and receiving.

Probably: Isaac Bruce. Terrific career, shame he didn't receive more attention as Moss and Owens got all the publicity. Like Marvin Harrison, he kept his mouth shut and performed greatly.

Maybe: Rod Smith. Had many great seasons, and a lot of good ones. Took a few years to develop, but was a good target in Denver. What could hurt him though is I don't think he was ever considered as a "Top 5" receiver in the league.

I think the rest will not make it because of not enough great seasons.

Answer 10

I'd say Isaac Bruce and Drew Bledsoe.

Rod Smith might for the combination of longevity and the fact that he was never drafted (he's a bargain even for the Hall!).

If Tiki makes it, it's only because he has media friends voting for him and he played in a big market. On-field, he had 3 great years, but most of his career he was known as a fumbler who couldn't get short yardage.

Warner and Holmes had a couple of fantastic seasons, but didn't play long enough.

The rest of them had good long careers to be proud of, but lack that defining season HoFers can so often hang their hat on.