who is the best second baseman in baseball history?

Answer 1

Rodgers Hornsby is the greatest second basemen of all time. He Played for the St. Louis Cardinals in the 1920's and won the Triple Crown in 1925 and 1922 the only player to win 2 Triple Crown's. He had a 326 carrer batting average. Just a fantastic player

Answer 2

that's an extremely stressful question, pondering there are a minimum of 7 valid contenders(Napoleon Lajoie, Eddie Collins, Rogers Hornsby, Jackie Robinson, Joe Morgan, Roberto Alomar, Craig Biggio) for the precise spot. Hornsby replaced into the terrific hitter, yet a so-so fielder, a egocentric recommendations-set, and a impolite and obnoxious character. Collins replaced into the best participant, super at positioning, yet no potential, yet performed while no one had potential. Morgan replaced right into a stable fielder, and a grasp of astro-turf offense stable OBP, good potential, and super baserunning. He is likewise obnoxious. Robinson replaced into certainly a super fielder, very stable hitter, and super chief. He additionally had a short carrer, no longer allowed to start till age 28, and through age 35 diabetis slowed him down a lot, and performed in a era the place no one stole bases. I reluctantly provide the nod to Morgan, yet i might quite have Jackie Robinson be on my team because of the fact the 2d baseman.

Answer 3

How foolish can some people be? Craig Biggio? He wasn't even the best from our generation!!!

I'd have to say the best OVERALL second baseman to play the game whom you could accurately guage their performance without the consideration of the pre-WW2 era when baseball players were not only performing with inferior competition, but also the second basemen were not expected to pay much attention to defense are as follows:
Joe Morgan
Roberto Alomar
Jackie Robinson

For pre-WW2 era it's:
Rogers Hornsby
Eddie Collins
Nap Lajoie

Answer 4

Joe Morgan, Cincinnati Reds...the Reds were a good team, with a strong nucleus prior to Joe Morgan's arrival, but Morgan made the Reds a great team, on par with the greatest of all time, i.e., the 1927 Yankees, etc. In addition to being a solid defensive second baseman, Morgan hit for power and average, and was the great leader on a team of stars and future Hall of Famers.

Answer 5

"muwat" is right, about Rogers Hornsby being far and away the greatest all around 2nd baseman in the history of baseball.

His lifetime BA was .358 second all time only to Ty Cobb's .367. The difference is Hornsby was also a power hitter, the NL version of Babe Ruth in the 20's.

Rogers Hornsby's numbers are staggering. Among them, he holds the record for the highest batting average in the modern history of baseball(424) - the highest SLG% ever for a middle infielder(756) and the best OPS(1232) ever by a middle infielder.
http://www.mlb.com

Answer 6

So many
Willie Randolph on the Yanks
Peter Rose started on this position.
Joe Morgan onthe Astros and the Red.

This answer can go on for ever but that is a few that are greats.

Answer 7

I would go with joe morgan, but you could throw in ryne sandberg and maybe even craig biggio and there are some i have missed but thats a good start.

Answer 8

I'd go with Craig Biggio, he's almost to his 3,000 hit mark and a pretty good fielder as well. At the end of his career Chase Utley will be up there as well.

Answer 9

hands down jackie robinson

no question about it
but joe morgan, rogers hornsby, charlie gehringer, and craig biggio are good too.