I am a huge Harry Potter fan and my suggestions and theories about "Deathly Hallows" are:
1. Harry´s scar is the last horcrux, because Harry always knows when Voldemort has strong feelings. There is a connection between both because Harry has a piece of Voldemort´s soul in him.
2. Harry survives, because he will be rescued somehow by the "very important fact he has his mother´s eyes" and by her love and her character always to see good things in everyone (perhaps in Voldemort´s character?) and, perhaps, also by Ginny´s love.
3. Dumbledore was definitely right with Snape being on the right side because, in my opinion, they made the Unbreakable Vow about that 16 years ago.
4. Except Voldemort, Hagrid and Lupin will perhaps have to die to rescue Harry...
Do you agree or not? What are your suggestions? I´ll be happy about every theory you are kindly to tell me! Thank you very much! It is so nice to know there are Harry Potter fans all over the world!
2007-05-24 08:27:11 · 11 answers · asked by Anonymous in Arts & Humanities ➔ Books & Authors
Horcruxes have to be destroyed. If Harry's scar was one, harry would have to be destroyed.
Why Harry is NOT a Horcrux.
First, we either know or have a pretty good idea of what the Horcruxes are.
1. DIARY - destroyed
2. RING - destroyed
3. Slytherin's LOCKET - unknown where & IF destroyed yet (I think it has)
4. Hufflepuff's CUP - unknown whereabouts
5. Nagini - wherever Voldie stashed her
6. Something of Ravenclaw's OR Gryffindor's - unknown What & Where
7. Voldy himself.
That leaves #6 as the big question. It has to be something of Rowena Ravenclaw’s or Godric Gryffindor’s. Harry could be Gryffindor’s heir or descendant, right? Wrong. Jo has confirmed that Harry is not the Gryffindor heir.
Let’s look at the rules of a Horcrux.
Rules of a Horcrux
1.Object must be collectible, as a trophy and chosen with some care
2. Object must have a powerful Magical history
3. Objects that, in themselves, have a certain grandeur
Well, Harry can fit two out of three. He fits more than Nagini. Okay. I give you that one, but we know from book six that it is very likely that Nagini was made a Horcrux almost out of desperation.
To get some more insight on Horcruxes, let’s see why Jo said the sorting hat (another popular Horcrux theory)is not a Horcrux.
"Horcruxes do not draw attention to themselves by singing songs in front of large audiences."
Even though Harry does not call attention to himself, he has a lot of attention on him. I doubt he would make a good Horcrux.
We know that Voldy places a lot of store in a witch or wizard’s blood lines. Harry is basically a half blood, and ol' Voldy wouldn't consider him good enough to hold a part of his soul.
Voldy has tried to kill Harry four times. 1st - SS through Quirrell 2nd - COS through the Basilsk 3rd - GOF at the Cemetery 4th - OOTP at the MOM
Does it make sense that Voldy would spend so much time and effort on trying to kill Harry if he held a piece of his soul? The answer is NO! There is more evidence to prove that Harry is not a Horcrux, than that he is one.
for book 7 theories and info on the books and movies visit my personal HP site
http://rpccstudent.tripod.com/
2007-05-24 09:12:10 · answer #1 · answered by kellyrv_bsa 5 · 2⤊ 1⤋
1. Scar = Horcrux
I don't think so, because Voldemort didn't have a chance to turn it into anything... he was planning to make a Horcrux AFTER he killed Harry, not out of Harry. The only reason he has the connection is because of the prophecy, and Voldemort's attack gave the connection, not Voldemort's soul... good theory though, I just don't agree :)
2. Mother's Eyes
Harry's mother's eyes played a part in influencing Slughorn to give Harry the memory about Tom Riddle learning about Horcruxes, and they may influence someone else too. Some people think that Snape might have been in love with Lily Potter, and he hates Harry so much because he sees Lily's eyes whenever he looks at Harry.
3. Dumbledore & Unbreakable Vow
I don't think Dumbledore would make an Unbreakable Vow with anybody, since the result of breaking it would be death. I think he trusts people for their heart and actions. Dumbledore told Harry that Snape regretted telling Voldemort about the Prophecy. I think that's where he developed trust in Snape, by seeing that Snape valued love, which is what Dumbledore also values.
4. Deaths!
Hagrid and Lupin are both good guesses on deaths... Lupin now has a love in the picture, with Tonks, and it's likely that his cover has been blown by fighting at Hogwarts... Since Greyback saw Lupin fighting, Lupin may be targeted for trying to spy on Greyback. Hagrid is very strong and pure of heart, so I can see how he could be a sacrificial character.
My biggest theory is that Snape has been against Voldemort all along as a personal vendetta, but didn't join the Order of the Phoenix right out of Hogwarts because he hated James and Sirius so much, and they were in the Order. I think he tried to kill Voldemort himself, maybe for revenge, if Voldemort killed Snape's mother. Snape gave the prophecy to Voldemort, hoping that Voldemort would die, but in the process, Snape's actions killed someone else's mother, Harry's mother. Snape feels awful for leading to Lily's death. He also develops his hatred for Harry because Snape wanted to be the one to kill Voldemort... Snape is very Slytherin: ambitious, cunning, doesn't want someone else to carry out his revenge. But now Snape knows that Harry is the only one who can kill Voldemort, and hates Harry for it.
Yay! Hope you liked that one :)
2007-05-24 15:38:52 · answer #2 · answered by HP Wombat 7 · 6⤊ 0⤋
I am not sure about all the details, I will have to finish reading the books again before the twenty-first of July, but.... I really think Harry is going to die. In one of the books, it was said about Harry and Voldemort that one could not die and the other live. He will die as a martyr. So many people rule out this possibility, just because he is the hero, the main character of the series. But remember, Dumbledore was killed! That, and Rowling is not a predictable writer. I have a feeling the last book will keep us all at the edge of our seats.
2007-05-24 15:36:43 · answer #3 · answered by MoJo 1 · 1⤊ 1⤋
I definitely agree about Harry being a horcrux... I think Dumbledore might have been a horcrux or that he needed to die and Snape had to do it so that Voldermort would trust him more .. and Draco kind of suprised me when Dumbledore was trying to get him on the "good" side I think we're gonna see Draco going back in forth with sides .. maybe he'll be like Snape ..
2007-05-24 19:38:25 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 1⤊ 0⤋
My one and only theory about book 7 is that Harry may choose to walk through the veil. His family is really all he has ever wanted and with both Sirius and Dumbledore gone and also depending on who dies in book 7, walking through the veil may be what he chooses to do. I do not believe that he will die at Voldemort's hands. At the end of book 1, Dumbledore said to Harry that "death is but the next great adventure." He could just be foreshadowing his own death, but I also think that Harry is not afraid of death and he could have been foreshadowing the next world for the both of them.
2007-05-24 15:41:27 · answer #5 · answered by SA 1 · 2⤊ 0⤋
not agree. harry has a connection w. voldie thru his scar but harry's not a horcrux.
yes harry has his parents love n love will be voldie's undoing.also v impt is hermione's love as his mum/sis. n ron as his bro.not ginny at all.he dun care 4 her like he does 4 hermione&ron. evid is throughout d book..
no. D was all wrong abt snape..snape bluffed D all d way.
way more than hagrid&lupin will die..i have some k'ledge of this..dan&emma have told some in i'views.
2007-05-25 10:11:21 · answer #6 · answered by Jane Fairfax 2 · 1⤊ 0⤋
harry is a horcrux - i gathered that back when i read hbp
ron will sacrifice himself to save hermione who will do something stupid!
the S locket found in the grimmauld place was a horcrux but mudungus has sold it off
snape is a good guy but will be killed after a showdown with voldermort
harry will die but will be brought back to life by ron and hermione?
james potter was not harrys father sirius was (messy hair)
neville will kill or at least aide in the killing of death eaters
mcgonngal will die
neville and luna will hook up or at least flirt with ron
viktor will make a reappearance
"lily potter was not a death eater" - what about james? was he?
how did albus know what happened at godric house place where james and lily died? - someone was there
regalus A black was aided by snape or james in getting the horcrux from the green jelly/liquid stuff
albus is someone we have met
lupin will kill or be killed by the other bloke werewolf (the one who mauled charlie)
several of the weasleys will die - ron one of the twins and percy. molly might sacrifice herself for her child
rufus scrimgeor will be found killed
voldermort will re-visit his plastic surgeon and tell him that he wants to get rid of the snake look. (ok thats my joke one)
well they are my theories
jo has said that albus is DEAD - he is not alive
but he will talk to harry/play a part in communicating with harry
something along these lines - he will talk via the portrait of albus
sirius may be dead but the little two way mirror communicator things will make a reappearance i think its because sirius is not dead merely gone
- could it be that the veil acts as link across time and that sirius is actually someone we all know and love as a character?
i just think there is something to albus
-he is not simply albus - he has 1 brother but we havent heard of him apart from once
albus in my opinion will be james, sirius, snape (would make big sense if you thought about it....) or percy weasley! - they share part of their name - is albus a weasley?!?!?!
2007-05-25 07:31:23 · answer #7 · answered by morderwarg 3 · 1⤊ 0⤋
hmm....i totally believe in no.3), find 1. hard to accept, think that no.4) is very possible, and hopes that it will end like in 2....
Although i don't want harry to die, i don't see any other way for the series to end properly..moreover, i'd rather see him die than to survive with either ron or hermione dead(God forbid!)I'm curious abt RAB, and am pretty sure like most others that it is R.Black..i definitely can't wait for July 21st to come...
2007-05-24 15:42:06 · answer #8 · answered by Lamya 6 · 1⤊ 0⤋
I am nor sure about any of the Harry Potter theories but the German referee in who officiated the football match between AC Milan and Liverpool was completely rubbish!
Hope this helps.
2007-05-24 15:36:09 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 1⤊ 5⤋
Dumbeldore is not dead as such so I reckon he will be back.
There is a clue to this in the last book.
2007-05-25 02:42:51 · answer #10 · answered by ? 4 · 0⤊ 1⤋