Should I reapair or replace my Subaru?

Question

I have a 99 Subaru Legacy Sedan with a 2.2 liter engine that has 108,000 miles on it. Recently some blue smoke began coming out the exhaust when starting cold. My mechanic said he found a used 2.2 with 71,000 miles on it and could get the engine and install it for $3200. I told him I didn't feel comfortable spending that much on a car with so many miles. The vehicle has had numerous other mechanical problems, though it looks clean. Does anyone have any comments on the quote for the used engine or have any ideas how to get some money out of the vehicle to put towards a newer commuter car? Trade-in ? Auto auction? Less expensive repair alternative? Thanks.

Answer 1

First of all 108,000 miles is not alot on the Subaru 2.2 engine. The car is worth fixing but get a second opinion. Has the car been maintained properly? Why the blue smoke. Second get a second opinion the 2.2 litre 4 cylinder are best engine Subaru has come out with. I have seen them with 275,000+ miles on them (original engine). What other problems does the car have. Again take it for a second opinion. I have a '93 with 133,000 miles on it(so far, so good). I would take it to a Subaru dealer for a full and proper diagnosis. Check the value at kbb.com

Answer 2

Subaru makes some pretty good engines.

I would first check your oil levels to see if you are actually burning oil because of bad rings or valve seals, and determine how quickly it is burning off.

For $3200, you should be able to get a completely rebuilt engine installed at that price. Most rebuilt engines run about $2000, and installation costs another $1000. So for that price don't settle for a used engine. Call some parts stores like Autozone and ask them how much a rebuilt engine for your vehicle would cost.

Personally I would just make sure the engine has oil. Check every week, and top it off if necessary, and keep driving the car. Save the money until your car breaks down and use the money saved to purchase a new(er) car.

Answer 3

before you make a decison check on how much it would be for a rebuilt of you own engine subaru 2.2 are generally good engines or maybe it doesnt need that just some work on the heads or valves but anyways get another mechanic or shop to take a look at it dont always go with the first auto shop

Answer 4

Ok, you have 2 options as I see it. First, deal with the blue smoke, it isnt harming anything really, just keep the oil topped off.

Second option, replace the car, my dad had a subaru of around the same year, they're expencive and not the most reliable! Get a camry or accord for the same price he's quoting you!

Answer 5

replace. get a porche cayenne. or a bmsw 325 1 2006 thats what i have