Do you think that if a man rapes a woman, he forfeits his right to life?

Question

If a man rapes a woman, do you think he deserves to be killed. I know that if some doucebag raped my mom or one of my sisters, I would slice him up real nice. What's your opinion on the issue?

By the way I'm not talking about capital punishment, I'm talking about the fury of the masses. Murderers on death row aren't even being killed in today's "ethical" society, so why should we expect any different for rapists.

Rapists, mainly the ones who get off on some bullshit technicality, need to be put in a room with me and my blade.

Answer 1

I am amazed that some people still have such ignorance about the crime of rape (FRAGINAL). No, rape is not driven by the desire to have sex. It is a crime of anger and the urge to have power over someone else. The death penalty is going a bit too far, but chemical castration and treatment for anger issues seems appropriate.

Answer 2

Ah, where oh where is civilization? Good people who express a primitive mindset here, you are short of 1) education, 2) education, and 3) er, a much-needed and large meaure of civilization. Let's leave lynching to the first half of the 20th century where, in my native state, Georgia, it was the Sunday afternoon pasttime of little white men with no courage, no sense of the world beyond the narrow one in which they lived, and wee-sized brains. Rape is what it should be, a crime, and slaughtering or maiming a rapist would be what it is, and what it should be, another crime. Hey, you might enjoy it at the moment but by your fourth or fifth year in prison you'd be wishing you hadn't been such a bloody fool.Think, think, think. It's not so painful a thing to do, you can still play with yourself in the shower or pick your nose when you think nobody's watching. Give it a try, this strange civilization thing, eh?

Answer 3

No...because while rape is terrible...most rape cases there is a genuine dispute between consent and rape.

The parties are touching and kissing and foolign around...the woman seems to agree to sex but either doesn't or changes her mind at some point...the guy may really believe she is ok but isn't and for some people hormones take over in such a way that it isn't fully understood.

And remember rape is the penetration after the no...so the slightest penetration once is rape...death for that?

For rapists that intend to rape...death...for unintentional rape...no.

Answer 4

There must be some exemplary punishment so that there is some decline in this horrifying crime.
Rape is worst crime than killing someone coz in rape the woman is killed in many ways(mentally and physically).
What about the raping of minor girls like 14-17 years old girls.
Its awful,horrible.
Not death but some harsh punishment like life imprisonment and choping off his ***** so that neither he nor anybody else have the guts to do so.

Answer 5

Our laws have become to lax on this despcable crime for sure. But even though I know its against the law for me to take care of it myself if given the chance without having to answer to the law for doing it well lets just say the world would be a safer place with one more rapist gone. The worst to me are the ones who molest children. And in some states they are getting off with probation! What is our country turning into? These people need special treatment. They need to be tourtured to almost death then let heal and then torture them again repeat as often as possible.

Answer 6

I am 45 years old and i am a victim of rape and not by a woman. maybe a little different perspective but . anyone who rapes an individual is deserving of a great loss. They used to kill people for raping women in this country and in my own opinion and experience they should.
But our society is so inundated with sexual stuff its no wonder that women and little girls are not being raped more often.
without any kind of deterrent or harsh penalties criminals will get off with only a hand slap only to be allowed to go on a rape rampage again.
so yes they should be killed.

Answer 7

No, because execution is a penalty too easily abused. It should be reserved for more serious crimes, and only when fairly certain proof of guilt can be obtained.

I think it's evidence of a certain kind of mental illness, when some citizens passionately demand more executions by the state. I think the act of violence, committed in their name, is more important to them then the mere question of guilt or innocence.

I think they would like to be murderers themselves, but don't dare, and demand therefore that the state provide them with blood vicariously.

Not in every case, I but I do believe some of the people you find making these bloodthirsty arguments are in that group.

Frankly I would say that real murderers, evil as they are, have at least the honesty to take the sin upon themselves.

Answer 8

Rape is a henious crime. It's worse than murder because the rape victim lives with the pain and debasement for life. The psychological and mental scar never heals and torments the victims through out their life. A similar life long sentence should be metted on therapist, say castration and life in prison with hard labor.

Answer 9

Rape is not a simple enough offence to allow one rule to cover all. There is mistake, insanity, etc to consider as well as someone who is just plain evil. It's dangerous to think that every rapist is the same

Answer 10

We have created this issue.

When we were animals there were many rapes. Aanimals are raped & have no justice.

It is this animal which makes a person go for rape.

We are a society & have choice whom to have sex with.

When someone doe it without concent is rape.

Animal should be treated as aminal.

He could ask decently for sex & not force. He should be punished.