Does this trade help my team?

Question

Id get Beltran, JJ Hardy, and Theriot...id give up Jimmy Rollins and Carl Crawford...my team:
C-Martinez
1b-Konerko
2b-Kinsler
3b-Hall
ss-Rollins
of-Crawford
of-Holliday
of-Granderson
util-Teahen
bn-Alex Gonzalaz
bn-Durham

should i do this trade???

Answer 1

No dont do it because jj hardy isnot going to keep up wat he is doing the whole year.

Answer 2

I am sorry to tell you this is a real bad deal. You are giving up too much speed in Rollins and Crawford. Hardy and Theriot are unknowns as to what they will do as the season rolls on and that leaves you with Beltran to do it all for you. Remember, Crawford and Rollins both have been hitting in the three slot this year and that means they will drive in runs as well. Don't make the trade

Answer 3

I will keep Crawford and Rollins. I mean you got a lot power on that team and besides for Rollins and CC not a lot of speed. I will rather have Team #1 since two got two unknown guys who just broke out. I think Hardy could be a top 5 ss but Rollins is a guaranteed one and he got good power and he will get you sb's and a alright average. Crawford is always a sb threat, hits for not great but ok power, and he gets a respectable average. While Hardy is hot right now but many hr's and he will cool down for at least some of the season, Beltran he is a sb threat, gets hrs, and a good average and a top pick, theriot he really only gets steals and hits for a good average. I mean its close but I give the slight edge to team number one. Also you will have to drop somebody so it will matter who that will be but still side 1 wins since they get guys who are CONSIENTLY good not two guys who are hot out of the gates and the first month and a half shoot forgot his name but look at the guy for the Tiger's a few years ago who started out hitting hr's like crazy he is now part of the minor leagues.

Answer 4

are you going to ask this exact same question again tomorrow too?

Answer 5

no way martinez and gonzalaz will do great