How does A.E. Housman's "To An Athlete Dying Young" relate to Leo Tolstoy's "How Much Land Does a Man Need"?

Question

You have seen British writers questioning the benefits of nineteenth-century industrialization and modernization. Does this questioning change in a Russian setting? In what ways does Tolstoy share or extend the British writers' debate about progress?

Answer 1

Some Reflections:

Tolstoy's story generally echoes/extends Housman's main concerns and share in the debate at least if one were to read his story in terms of modernization and its avaricious undercurrents.
"To an Athlete" is a dramatic monologue poem written by A.E. Housman. It is so heartfelt and meaningful. In the first stanza he writes about the thrill, honor, and devotion of a young athlete. All of the town respects and appreciates his many athletic talents, he is truly the overall champion. As the poem moves on to the second and third stanza's the poem moves through the athletes years and as he becomes ill in his health.
The poem in whole is a "simile" of sporting events comparing life to a game. The runners in the race become sickly and the end of the race represents the end of life.
The poem is a commentary on industrial and economic wealth. Life is a game no matter. Honor and nobility notwithstanding. Often they lead to greed if not controlled and life is then seen as a race, a competition which ends in death eventually. This are the moral lessons one gets from Tolstoy. narrative.
In "How Much Land Does A Man Need?," Tolstoy's character, Pahom, works nonstop against the wealthy landowner who calls upon a steward to oversee her land. The steward forces Pahom to pay fines when his cattle stray upon the woman's property. Later on, when Pahom turns into the wealthy land owner that he before despised, he found himself acting the same way to people who's cattle strayed upon his own land and in turn, the people end up despising him. This story shows that the pursuit of wealth ultimately leads to misfortune and, in Pahom's case, death. This is exactly how Housman's champion athlete ends.
The story, "How Much Land Does a Man Need? and the poem may be read as social and political commentaries on European 19thC industrialization and modernization.
Tolstoy's, though set in Russia, is a parabolic story about Americans taking advantage of the Indians.
Although it is set in Russia, it is about the greed that
many people had at the time and the outcome of that greed.
The opening scene represents the Europeans coming over
to America. During that time, the mid-1800's, the Europeans
were rich and their relatives in America were poor. The
younger sister in the story represents the Americans and the
older sister represents the Europeans. The poor Americans,
like the younger sister in the story, did not mind having to
work hard all the time. They enjoyed their freedom and
security. Even though they were content, it wasn't
complete. In the story, Pahom agrees with his peasant wife
but wishes they had more land to work with.
"Our only trouble is that we haven’t land enough. If I had plenty of land, I shouldn’t fear the Devil himself!” (p 212). The devil here is greed itself. It is here that we see the greed begin to manifest, as it did in Americans over a hundred years ago. The story goes on and we see Pahom becoming agitated the he has to pay fines all the time because of his animals wandering. This represents the American people having to pay fines, such as taxes and tariffs, to the government in the mid-1800’s. Pahom lives in a commune and some of the people have begun to buy their own tracts of land. He sees this and decides that it would be a good idea if he did the same thing. He was worried that if he didn’t act soon, he would miss his chance. He wouldn’t have to pay any fines and could keep all the money he makes. The more people heard about it, the more they wanted it for themselves. Pahom finally gets his own land and is happy with it.
Inevitably, some problems arise with Pahom’s land. Other people’s animals were getting onto land and ruining his crops. At first he just put up with it. Eventually though he became a hypocrite. “So he had them up, gave them a lesson, and then another, and two or three of the peasants were fined.” (p 214) He began to impose fines on people the same way they were imposed on him earlier in the story. Needless to say, people were very angry with him. Some people began to leave the commune, eastern United States, and leave for new parts, the west. Pahom was content to stay until he heard from a stranger that the land was great where people were moving. This could be compared to news getting back to the east coast about all that was happening on the move west. So Pahom went to check things out, liked what he saw, and moved.
Here things went well, for awhile. Pahom was happy h
aving ten times as much land. He had land for everything he needed. But after awhile, it came to be to little. His greed was growing out of control. He was ready to buy more land but a passing stranger told him about a place he had just come from, more news from the west. Pahom was told about the best land ever and how cheap it was. Pahom travels to inquire about the land. When he arrives, he finds it just as he was told it was going to be. The people that live on the land, the Bashkirs, are a very simple and happy people. They do not speak the same language as Pahom, though. These people are the native Americans. As the European settlers moved west they came across the natives. Tolstoy describes: “They were all stout and merry, and all the summer long they never thought of doing any work. They were quite ignorant, and knew no Russian, but were very good-natured.” (p217)
When people first encountered the Indians, they thought them to be stupid and lazy, easy to take advantage of. With the help of a translator, Pahom makes his purposes know. The Chief, though, speaks Russian. Many native Americans knew how to speak English because they were constantly exposed to English speaking men. They made a deal that whatever deal Pahom could walk around would be his. His greed was out of control at this point. He was so sure about how much land he could cover that he thought he was stealing for them.
The night before he had a dream that the devil was sitting over his dead body laughing. He dismisses it and goes back to sleep. The next day he starts out to stake his claim. He is trying so hard to get as much as possible that he miss judges how far he has gone and begins to have problems walking. He is tired, hot, and hurt. He has to start running to make it back in time. Pahom begins to realize that he should not have been so greedy, as it is taking it’s toll on him. He barely makes it back on time, and alive. Right as he gets to the finish, he sees the Chief sitting and laughing, just like the devil in his dream. He collapses and dies right as he finishes. He is buried right there. “His servant picked up the spade and dug a grave long enough for Pahom to lie in, and buried him in it. Six feet from his head to his heels was all he need.” (p 222)
This story represents the greed present in Americans during the time of the settlement of western America. Americans were very greedy people. They were never content with what they had and, in more than one way, destroyed their own lives to try and get more for themselves.



Good luck

Answer 2

You are asking for a difficult essay about two very complex characters. That couldnt be done here, but if you had a specific question about a part of the essay, I could help. But to answer your question would take up several pages. Pax - C

Answer 3

smart wife