Do you think it is inappropriate for a husband to tell his wife to SHUT UP in front of their young children?

Answer 1

Abolutely, completely innappropriate.. Teaches the kids they don't have to respect Mom or anyone else.. and it's just a bad habit to get into... it's rude and insensitive to say that to another human being.

Answer 2

I find it totally inappropriate for a husband or a wife to disrespect the other in front of anyone let alone the children. Children in particular do not need to see that their parents are not in control of their verbal or physical skills. It scares them and it also puts the children in a position to try to control the parents. Please try to find a way to follow common decency so your children don't grow up thinking this kind of behavior is acceptable. They will treat their spouses the same and you will have behavioral problems with them in school if they think that abusive language is okay. Disrespect starts at home and then conveys to their everyday life. Put a stop to it.

Answer 3

Totally inappropriate either way. How would he feel if his wife said the same in front of the children. It shows a lack of respect to tell anyone to SHUT UP....Ugh!

Answer 4

I do not know why, but I feel strongly that "shut up" is a dis-respectful way of asking somebody to pretty much please be quiet.. The fact that a husband is saying this to his wife, wow.. No, it is not appropriate in my eyes. If my husband were ever to say that to me I would be baffled, and to say this in front of the children is wrong. If the wife is out of line, as in cursing and yelling like a banshee, there are still other ways. I have taught my child that this is one phrase we do not use and I hope that she always sticks to that. But, the amount of "adults" I hear saying shut up amazes me. Husbands and wives are really not suppose to speak to each other in such a manner. I know it happens but come on, why?

Answer 5

First of all, none of us can be sure that the wife did anything to be disrespecful. The husband could have been mad about something else, and took it out on her unfairly. If, assuming the worst, however, the wife did do something disrespectful, this is still not right. It never becomes right for any reason, because two wrongs will never make a right. That tit-for-tat nonsense is what destroys relationships.

I always tell my children, if you have something to say, talk in your indoor voice, don't yell or scream. I don't care what your sibling did to make you want to yell or scream, don't do it. I tell them to come and tell me when they have a problem, and to tell me in their indoor voice. That's what this reminds me of. If he had a problem, he could just say it. He could have said something like, "Please don't interrupt me, because what I have to say is important." (Assuming that was the problem the husband had.)

I'm sorry, but nobody can talk their way out of this one. There's never a valid excuse for teaching your children to act out like that when you become angry. He should say he's sorry to his wife in front of the children, so that the children know that it's not okay to talk to other people like that.

(I've absentmindedly said the D-word in front of my children, and I apologized to them for doing it, so that they would know it's not okay to repeat it.)

What happened won't be all bad though... Saying "I'm sorry" is an important example for children to learn, too.

Answer 6

I truly think it is inappropriate for ANYONE to tell ANYONE shut up. It is a gross form of disrespect.

However, to disrespect his wife in front of her children is horrible. It teaches their children how to be obnoxious little jerks who will grow up to be just like dad.

The best way to curb this behavior is to correct it when it happens..in front of the children. Tell the moron, "I do not appreciate you speaking to me like that, especially in front of the children. What do you want them to think about the way you are treating me? "

That should shut HIM up.

Answer 7

In general, no, not appropriate. Absolutely not.

However, if the wife is yelling / screaming / scaring the kids /cursing / using hate speech / making abusive threats etc in front of the kids, and the husband said "shut up" to kind of snap her out of it... then I could understand it and think that would be not the best way to handle it, but definately justified in that situation.

Answer 8

Shawdup!! purely kidding. My wager is that there is something incorrect with the funds. My intestine feeling is that he's the two hiding that he has spent extra funds on issues you don't be conscious of roughly, or he's hiding income a separate account so as that he can get it far off from you, or he's afraid that in case you be conscious of ways lots funds is actual there, you will prefer to spend it on something. Any of the circumstances are available. as some distance simply by fact the remark that he's purely a guy, i glance at marriage as being companions, i prefer a spouse to stroll beside me and not in front of me or at the back of me. It takes 2 to tango and having an substantial different who's your equivalent in existence is super. stable luck

Answer 9

Yes, it is. he does not respect you. that is not allowed in my house. children learn that from their parents, so whenever i hear a child say shut up I know that they learned it at home. Your husband sounds like a macho jerk. Young children means you probably have not been married too terribly long, he will only get worse, you might want to make alternate plans for you and your children.

Answer 10

I think it's inappropriate for a husband to EVER tell his wife to "shut up". That's ugly, in my opinion. He could be a lot nicer, and still get his point across!

Answer 11

Savage c
Yes , I do . They see how you both react and later in life can respond as yourself . The husband should have respect for his wife , not act like that in front of the children .