Trade, please help, should i do it!!?

Question

Should I do this deal?
I give Jason Bay and Carlos Zambrano and

I get Manny Ramirez and Joe Nathan.

My current team is

C Jorge Posada
1b Albert Pujols
2b Jeff Kent
3b Chipper Jones
SS Derek Jeter
OF Juan Pierre
OF Jason Bay
OF Hideki Matsui
Util Mark Teixeira
Bench: Nick Swhisher, Edgar Renteria
SP Jake Peavy
SP Brandon Webb
SP C.C. Sabathia
SP Cole Hamels
SP Carlos Zambrano
SP Felix Hernandez
RP Chris Ray
RP Trevor Hoffman
RP Brett Myers
DL B.J. Ryan

Answer 1

You have plenty of quality starters so adding Nathan for Zambrano is a great deal. Finding a top end closer is hard to do, this guy is offering you one of the elite closers. Ramirez for Bay is again a deal in your favor. Love what Bay can do but he isnt playing on a team where he can put up numbers like Ramirez, once he heats up ramirez will be among the leaders in HR and RBI not to mention he is a .300 hitter. So pitching for pitching you get a better pitcher and hitting you get the better bat. Great deal and one worth completing!

Answer 2

It sounds like a good trade for you actually, you have one of the best starting rotation I have seen because all your SP's match thier innings with strikeouts, which is rare. Bay and Manny are similar players and having Nathan will help your RP while you got ryan on the DL. Brett is closing for a little bit but I think Gordon will regain his role. Good trade I would do it! You have some really good trade bait!

Answer 3

I'd do this in a heartbeat. Bay has no one around him and Nathan is one of the best in the league. For me closing is harder to find than a SP. Manny plays in a much more potent lineup. Good Luck

Answer 4

Do it. Nathan is the best, and Manny will get hot.

Answer 5

Is there like 4 teams in your league how the hell did you get so many superstars on this team?

Answer 6

nope lol. just nope