Who should be responsible for the family (bills, clothes, food, rent)?

Question

Question: in a relationship: husband, wife, and kids…..Say that the husband and wife do not share there income they have different savings account. And say that the man is making way more money then a woman should it be right for both of them to go half and half on everything?
And say that the woman buys the kids some clothes and the husband doesn’t think it is necessary and she asks him for half of what she spent (and remind you that she makes ok money but he gets more) and he says NO the kids didn’t need clothes so I wont give you anything…Is the Fair that things like this happen not only with clothes but with other things like food, ect.

Forgot to add one thing and what about if always think that nothing is necessary. Forgets to go shopping for food, because the woman does it and he doesn’t want to pay half up because she did it and he said well that was your choice to do it. And when the family goes out to eat he doesn’t eat because he doesn’t want to pay. So the woman who ate with both of their has to end up paying for everything while he sits down and watches. Basically he is a penny pincher.

Answer 1

yeah i mean, if the mother wants to buy the kids clothing that they don't need then she SHOULD pay for it with her own money. But, obviously their way of paying for things is disfunctional. Find a better way or it will lead to problems.

Answer 2

Its fair to split the bills you share and not split the bills you don't share.

Lets say he was your room mate and not your husband.

Your room mates income would not change what their half of the rent, cable bill, grocery bill was. Would it?

I recommend to budget a week amount the you both put in half. If you go over that amount then it your decision to spend your own money or wait until next week.








What about independence?

If you want more money why don't you find a better paying job?

Answer 3

First I'm not married but I read this in one of my personal finance books. Add up all family bills (household, kids clothes, school, etc). Add together your total income then get get each spouse's percentage of total income and time that times the bill and that is each spouse's responsibility of household bills. That would require a joint account for family bills and that's it. So each spouse would pay proportionally to what they bring in. So if you guys brought in the same amount you pay 50/50 but if one spouse makes more that spouse pays more portionally. However you two would have to agree to a budget before hand of how much you want to spend in each category.

Answer 4

Yes it is right for them to put half of their pay into a joint account since the home, the bills, the groceries etc benefit the entire family, not just one member. If the mother wants to overspend on the kid's clothes that would be her choice but that should be part of the joint account as well.
I made more than my ex when we put half of our pay into the joint account and the other half was put into seperate accounts. Worked out very well for us, especially at vacation time.

Answer 5

Ppfffttttt. he's a moron! and also you enable him to be a moron. How "little" you do economic-smart. seems to me, you're doing a heck of lots. better than I do. i'm an finished time mum, i do not usher in ANY money. My major different seems after all the charges. And if he ever dared to throw it in my face about what HE paid for.....nicely, suffice to say the **** might want to hit the fan. As for the understand issue, you ought to provide it to get it. He would not understand you in any respect from what i have examine on your positioned up. Why the heck ought to you recognize him? Or does he have some lofty concept about the guy being the large bushy Bread Winner and deserving of accolades every time he's taking a unload? Wow. Honey, tell him to close his pie hollow. His mind-set disgusts me.

Answer 6

The entire take home pay of the household should be pooled to pay bills, IMHO. After bills are paid, then you can decide how to spend your discretionary income. Splitting the bills IMHO, is childish, and unfair. It would be better to pool all the funds of the family (between husband and wife) and pay the bills first, then decide how to spend the rest.

Dividing funds, and paying bills based on how much a husband or wife gets paid is childish.

Answer 7

Both are responsible. Sorry, but doesn't sound like much of a marriage if you two aren't sharing everything. All money coming in should go into one account, all bills and everything else gets paid out of that one account. Works wonderfully.

Answer 8

Consider doing a budget. Determine how much it takes to support the household. Include gas, lunches, and an allotted amount each month for clothing and shoes. Then see how much is left of your combined incomes. Split that amount between you.

In other words, it all goes into one pot, and what's left is split 50/50.

Answer 9

I would say if he makes a significantly higher amount, and you share expenses, it should depend on his salary and not be 50/50. For example, if he made 100,000 a year and you only made 10,000, he should pay 90% and you should pay 10% of expenses. Or, if he makes 50,000 and you make 20,000, I would say that the percentage should be 25%/75% and the like. It sounds like a lot of issues here, but it seems very unfair.

Answer 10

Traditionaly it is the mans' place but more and more the woman has assumed the responsibility. Personaly I think you should share the responsibility and cost Different circumstances deem different ways of deciding.. Not everyone does things the same it is whatever works for you.