Should Holocaust denial be made illegal?

Question

Just because you support the rights of holocaust deniers does not means you support what they have to say.

If the government can make writting or speech illegal they can therefore reinterpret history as they see fit.

I say let these idiots say whatever they want and let the public be the judge.

I would rather know who these people are so I can challenge their views than to have them keep their thoughts entirely private (and unchallenged).

Answer 1

I don't believe it should be made illegal.

I do find it odd that research on the subject is illegal in Europe.

What are the Europeans afraid the people will find out?

Answer 2

Go open any US history text book and see all the lies, half-truths, and omissions.

Start with the Vietnam war!

I know the Holocaust happened. I have been to the concentration camps, the last one I went to was just outside of Waldsassen Germany in 2002. Many Americans were also put to death in these camps, most Army fliers. I have seen the ovens, autopsy tables, gas chambers and mounds of buried dead. They exist!

Ask a German. They won't deny it!

Answer 3

the concern is while governments do supply into allowing such as you pronounced particular rights to particular communities of people it creates friction between them and different communities of people which those different communities would possibly not accept as true with what the government has desperate wherein the government had created the conflict of pastimes through fact not all of us will lend a hand. It gets greater complicated once you throw into the ingredient faith through fact while a central authority makes a decision permit's say legalizing comparable intercourse marriage they have stepped on human beings's ideals that don't help comparable intercourse marriage through fact of their faith. of course there is a thank you to confirm the situation if the final public is set against the government's selection they are in a position to continuously choose representatives whom help their perspectives. yet permit's settle for it politicians can actual exchange into corrupted wherein they now not help the perspectives of people who voted them into place of work yet fairly comply with what the lobbyists choose of them. In such circumstances that's not uncommon for those communities of people whose pastimes are actually not being represented to protest, show, even rebel to establish that their voice to be heard by using the government and if that doesn't paintings it could desire to convey approximately a revolution wherein the government is overthrown. human beings snort on the tea party however the concern is people who belong to the tea party circulation are actually not happy approximately how issues are being ran interior the government and that they prepared demonstrations to voice their comments to the government. you be responsive to while america became into Colonial u.s. the Revolutionaries executed the comparable subject in the commencing up they tried demonstrations and non violent protests approximately taxation without representation interior the top the final public banned at the same time and overthrown the British government.

Answer 4

Sure only if they make honest speech for speaking out in support of good social values not a crime as hate speech as they are currently trying to do with HR 2015.

Answer 5

I don't really know of anyone who flat-out denies it happened...I know people who are merely questioning the numbers--was it only 6000 who died instead of 6 million, for example? (Either way it's not right.)

You should never blindly believe anything--it never hurts to ask questions. Asking about how the Holocaust really happened should NEVER be considered anti-Semitic. In fact, as a Christian I support the NATION of Israel (as opposed to the STATE). But I may have a few questions!

Answer 6

Zionist are the ones who are at fault for holocaust but i bet people are scratching their heads after reading this. there is a real reason they do not want you to research or question it at all. research and find out some unbelievable stuff i promise its worth it

Answer 7

Sure, throw out the first amendment while you're at it. No matter how much you hate what they say they still have a Right to say it. As you are exercising that same right by asking this question and sharing your opinion.

Answer 8

As stupid as it is that people deny the Hollocaust, you can't outlaw opinion. At least not in the United States. People will still think what they want to, regardless of whether or not the law says they can.

Answer 9

okay so i'm gonna prove a point okay watch. i'm not ANTI SEMITIC AT ALL..heck i feel for the people of Jewish faith (they aren't a peoples just a religion) but watch this.

why is it that every time someone questions people of Jewish faith and their state..its anti Semitic? (now i am not questioning the holocaust. that happened..any fool who thinks it didn't simply needs to do a search and see all the horrible pictures.)

now as i said..watch

watch all the people give me a thumbs down because...i said something about the people of Jewish state that they didn't like..even though i didn't say anything bad about them at all.

so those who are in denial about what the Nazis did to the people of Jewish faith-are just as mixed up as those who always cry anti semitism every time the word Jewish is mentioned.

Answer 10

I don't think it should be made illegal, but denying the Holocaust should be grounds for denying anyone a Teaching Certificate.