Rate my fantasy baseball team?

Question

Rate it on a scale from 1-10, give me feed back don't just give it a rating. 12 team leauge and it's a points leauge. Right now I have 47.5 points.

C-Joe Mauer
1B-Chris Duncan
2B-Freddy Shanchez
3B-Mike Lowell
SS-David Eckstein
OF-Jermaine Dye
OF-Gary Matthews Jr.
OF-Austin Kearns
UTIL-Frank Thomas
BN-Melvin Mora
BN-Chris Burke
BN-Ken Griffey Jr.
BN-Ryan Freel (Trade pennding with him for Ty Wiggington)
SP-Johan Sanatana
SP-Curt Schilling
RP-Dan Wheeler (trade pennding with him for Bob Wickman)
RP-Mike Gonzalez
P-Justin Verlander
P-Noah Lowry
P-Jamie Moyer
BN-Josh Johnson (DL)
DL-Chris Caprpenter (DL)

Answer 1

ILL BREAK DOWN FOR U GIV EACH PLAYER A MARK OUT OF 10-

Mauer-9(great catcher, shallow position)
Chris Duncan-3(solid first baseman but u can do much better)
Freddy sanchez-1(consider getting rid of him or picking a FA up)
mike lowell-5(on a tear)
david eckstein-4(won't giv u much power but will get u sb's and runs)
Jermain Dye-6(consistent outfielder who hits for good power numbers)
gary matthews jr.4(will get u alot of runs)
austin kearns-3(consider tradind him)
frank thomas-3(very old strike out a lot and is beginning to fall apart
melvin mora-6(solid 3b u should put him instead of lowell)
chris burke-1(drop him!!!)
ken griffey jr.-3(injured sooo much)
wigginton-6(versatile plays many positions

johan-10(cy young award winner)
carpenter-9(when he gets bak from dl he'll be a force)
schilling-8(starting off great with a good line up protecting him)
wickman-5
mike gonzalez-6
verlander-6(solid pitcher)
lowry-3(iffy)
moyer-4(probably pikd him up cuz of his last game)
johnson-6

overall i hat to break it to u but ur team isnt great.... u needa make alot of trades to improve ur hitting theres question marks at every single position consider giving away carpenter for some hitting since u have johan and curt. Ur team is gonna finish last if u keep it the way it is.

I giv u an overall rating of 2.5

Answer 2

I agree, the pitching is good, but could use another closer. Also, I'm a Cardinal fan and like to see that you picked up Duncan, he will be good this year, Eckstein though is a great player, but not too good for a fantasy team. When you get Wiggington, I would put him at the SS position. Overall I would give the team a 6-7.

Answer 3

it give you a 6. I dont see any star hitters that could carry your team. And I only see a few that can make contact on a regular basis (Mauer, eckstien, sanchez, and mattews). I see a few players that can give you home runs but will have a low hitting average. And i see only only one pure base stealer with freel. Your pitching is not to bad. You need another RP. another thing i ope this is not your line up right now. If it is why would you have lowell playing and not mora and kearns for griffey?

Answer 4

8

Answer 5

Rating:8
Pretty good team with awesome players, but I have to say that you could have better people.You should trade the following: Ryan Freel, Austin Kearns,and maybe Freddy Sanchez. Im not too cool on Noah Lowry, cause I think you could get great players with him.But overall,ya got a nice team.

Answer 6

Im sorry, but its not very good, 7 of ur offensive players are either on the waiver wire right now in one of my leagues, or were just a short time ago. Your pitching is so-so. A trade for wiggington and Wickman (fyi, hes on the DL) arnt going to save this team. Sorry but your team doesnt stand a chance.

Answer 7

Steals and saves are needed but will be hard to get in a 12 team league.

A little light in the power department.

Freel needs to pickit up or bench him if you already haven't.
Rating 5.75 / 6.50.

Answer 8

I would say 5 maybe 6.
Your starting pitching looks ok, I would take another look at your relief pitching, it could use some improvement.

Answer 9

9 But I would trade for a back-up catcher .

Answer 10

about a 7 .... very good pitching, but your position players dont seem to be so great. your catcher, 2b, and gary mathews are pretty good