English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

does the mind decide how we feel or do the feelings decide how we think? Is there a co-relation? and in case of conflict between the two, what holds more prominence, the feelings or thoughts? and why?

2007-05-01 09:44:54 · 7 answers · asked by x 2 in Arts & Humanities Philosophy

7 answers

Most people think they have one brain. In a very real sense, they are wrong. A close study of the brain reveals several brains, of different levels of development and sophistication.

At the core is what's sometimes referred to as the 'reptile brain'... and not for no reason. It is very similar in capability and function to the kind of brain that your typical lizard has. It is the primal seat of emotions and the engine that keeps your body working without thought. And it can generally operate almost independantly of the rest of your brain.

If you want to find sophisticated levels of thought and sensation, you'll have to go to the outermost, most recent regions of the brain. Memories lie in regions in between. And all of these parts operate SIMULTANEOUSLY. You don't think or feel or remember or sense or anything else... you do everything all at once. It is really a wonder that anyone can keep it all straight.

It's pretty obvious that they influence each other. What's more, it's also pretty obvious that they are all influenced by the environement - some people have trouble thinking in the presence of loud music, but with the right song they are much better at emoting. Nor is it too difficult to alter people's moods through chemicals or muscular motion (it's well known that smiling can help make you feel happy and feeling happy makes you more likely to smile).

As to who's in charge... I'm not sure anyone is unilaterally in charge. Some of the most rational people are occasionally overcome by emotion, and some of the most emotional occasionally accede to reason. The brain is plastic and flexible, though, and tends to do automatically do more of whatever it is that you're doing. So a emotive person certainly has more resistance to overcome.

If I had to pick just one, I'd go with the reptile. It's been in charge the longest and has the most subtle and pervasive influences. It is persistant, primitive, and stubborn. And it sometimes does things so thoroughly that people can't even concieve with the newer parts of their brains that anything might have actually been different.

So it goes.

2007-05-01 10:00:34 · answer #1 · answered by Doctor Why 7 · 2 0

I believe that our feelings are influenced by thoughts because it's our thoughts that get us to react to any situation rather what is said or done. Everything begins with a thought first including a scratch on the head. The mind is what tells us what someone means whenever they make a statement and we feel a certain feeling when they receive that statement. Feelings can take over us and tell us how to think when we're overcome with emotion. Of course, there is a correlation between the two which is what I explained above. In case of conflict between the two, I'll say Thoughts hold the prominence because people can turn on and off their feelings when they want to but you can't ever turn off your thoughts even when you sleep - only when you die. Thoughts are Prominent because they control you even when you don't know it.

2007-05-01 17:41:49 · answer #2 · answered by Dimples 6 · 1 0

i think feelings are influenced by thoughts. "nothing is right nor wrong, but thinking makes it so". it is also the case that small things are made by overanalysis to be bigger things, and really, overanalyzing separates the body from the mind.

we are naturally slaves to our passions, and so so it leads that our feelings and emotions dominate a good amount of our thoughts and down-time. thoughts phase in and out - we are sometimes consumed by brooding and sometimes idle, and often dwelling in between, but i am sure that our feelings, who dominate us, take the top spot.

this leads me into my next half-baked idea. imagination only really occurs in said down-time. i dont think when we are actively thinking/being constructive/being creative we are really being imaginative/imagining. im sure there is a small majority who disagree with me, but i tend to feel that dwelling in ones imagination is tantamount to wasting ones time - it is simply what fills in the doldrums left by serious thought. sure, its necessary, and every now and them im sure it helps us stumble into a great developement, but it is just idlity

2007-05-03 01:48:46 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

Imagination is born out of feelings. The imagination goes beyond our feelings until our feelings catch up to the imagination and even beyond but when we go beyond we retreat from fear and it is then we will let our imagination go again, until we are brave enough to express our feelings once again. It goes on and on, until we ultimately come into ourselves and our physical and emotional being unites, which leads us to peace and contentment in the moment in which we are living.

2007-05-01 09:51:53 · answer #4 · answered by applecheeks 4 · 1 0

a million) Do you reside interior the previous, contemporary, or destiny? (ex: you're able to be able to be certain a narrative approximately time commute, a individual caught interior the previous, etc) All, however i'm engaged on staying interior the present. 2) What if people had to soak up detrimental thoughts and offset their detrimental impact with constructive ideas/thoughts? isn't that what people do? 3) What "classes" you? Uh, my writing obsession and prefer to get right into a physically powerful college? Sheesh, idk, it somewhat is a heck of so lots greater suitable than that. 4) Is there an emotion which could offset elegance? Love (i think that's an suitable place to place in writing the be conscious "duh") 5) in case you have been born linked on your sibling on the face-and you have been separated..which might you prefer to be: the only without eyes (and subsequently incapable of seeing your self/what you're lacking), or the only with one eye? (that's no longer meant to %. on bodily deformed people..that is philosophical) the only with the attention, yet i could sense in charge approximately it. 6) Is having a selective reminiscence good or undesirable? undesirable. Definately. 7) What in case you in basic terms stopped being concerned approximately social expectancies? could you be happier? each so often I do and that i'm estatic. i do no longer attempt to ease my concerns by potential of attempting to slot in greater socially however. BQ: what sort of chocolate is your prominent: milk/dark/white/different White, yet i like all varieties. BQ2: have you ever prevented somebody who likes to borrow from you yet does not decide for to return products? in no way had that ensue BQ3: Is it worse to be lied to or stolen from? Stolen from, i think of. BQ4: is often anticipating the greater serious pessimistic or sensible in which you forearm your self for destiny issues? I dream too lots--I continually wish for the very, very superb and am commonly disspointed; commonly when I even have worse expectancies, issues prove greater suitable than ever. yet i do no longer enable undesirable expectancies drag me right down to far. I in basic terms enable them to take over slightly so as that i know that it is going to likely be greater suitable sometime quickly. it continually is. i don't know if this is clever. BQ5: What flavor toothpaste could you opt for for to be certain made? This BQ after that final one? certainly, i'm no longer surpised. Lavender--what does lavender even flavor like?

2016-12-28 06:46:27 · answer #5 · answered by palo 3 · 0 0

some feelings (like depression) are influenced by body chemistry.
our thoughts certainly have an impact on our feelings. thinking happy thoughts, translate to happy feelings. thinking sad thoughts may affect our feelings. our thoughts really affect our moods.

2007-05-01 10:03:51 · answer #6 · answered by ·will¹ªm ºn vacation! 5 · 1 0

i think feeling are influenced by thoughts. if you stop thinking of your granma's death (just an example), to woh dukh utna nahi rahega, kam hote jayega aur fir chale jayega, par ugar uske baare mein sochte rahe to woh badte jaata hai. agar aap soch lo ki jo hua woh acha hua, sabhi ke liye to aap itne dukhi nahi hote, par agar aap ye soche ki ye kya ho gaya kyu hua, jo hua woh bahut hi galat hua tab feelings bas badegi.
so as thoughts are controlled by mind, that will mean that feelings are decided by our mind. there is a corelation, we or i should say our mind decides our feelings without our realising that we are deciding our own emotions, so our thoughts change without us wanting them to. which of them would have the upper hand depends on person to person. a very practical person would rarely let feelings take over him/her in making decisions. it probably depends on the mental strenght of the person, more control a person has on his/her thoughts, more they can think without influence of their feelings.

2007-05-04 04:00:54 · answer #7 · answered by Kelrec 4 · 1 0

fedest.com, questions and answers