I need help with these fantasy baseball trades!!!?

Question

I was just offered four trades from the same person because he really wants Alfonso Soriano. The four trades were Vernon Wells, Davis DeJesus, and Kelly Johnson, for Alfonso Soriano, and Chase Utley. The second was Vernon Wells, David DeJesus, and Arron Harang for Alfonso Soriano and Chase Utley. The third was Derek Jeter, Vernon Wells, and David DeJesus for Alfonso Soriano, and Hanley Ramirez. The last one was Vernon Wells, Derek Jeter, and Kelly Johnson for Hanley Ramirez, and Alfonso Soriano. And to help you out this is my team :

Batters
C Brian McCann
1B Nomar Garciaparra
2B Chase Utley
3B Chipper Jones
SS Hanley Ramírez
OF Michael Cuddyer
OF Ty Wigginton
OF Alfonso Soriano
Util Travis Hafner
BN Curtis Granderson
BN Xavier Nady
BN Rocco Baldelli
BN J.J. Hardy

Pithcers -
SP Ervin Santana
SP John Smoltz
SP Matt Cain
RP José Valverde
RP Jason Isringhausen
P Brian Fuentes
P Ryan Dempster
P Carlos Zambrano
BN Bronson Arroyo
DL B.J. Ryan

Answer 1

Okay, obviously he either doesnt really want Soriano that badly or he thinks you are a fool. Not one of these trades comes remotely close in terms of value. He thinks if he throws a lot of guys your way the trade looks more reasonable...who you going to cut among the rest of your guys to make the trade meet your roster limits (there is no such thing as a 4 for 2 or 3 for 2 deal, you have to cut others to meet the roster limit). Dont consider any of these deals, Wells is a very good player but he isnt at the level of Soriano or Utley (there is a reason both are top 10 players). Ramirez is a much better fantasy option than Jeter (on the field Jeter is by far the better player but fantasy wise the edge is clearly Ramirez's). DeJesus and Johnson are both playing exceptional ball at the moment but neither has a proven track record and could flounder at any moment . Tell him if he wants Soriano that badly he needs to give up Wells, harang and Johnson and you can include Nady and Wigginton to make the trade match numberswise or cut those two. Dont move Utley or Ramirez, you would give up way to much position value for either, if he wants Soriano that badly then tell him only Soriano is available.

Answer 2

You should definetely do the trade that includes Aaron Harang. You need pitching and Aaron Harang is 4-0. He has a good ERA, and he gets you strikeouts too. Vernon Wells is HOT right now. Though he will cool down, he will not cool down significantly. I can safely say that he will be in the same league as Soriano, if not better. So you are getting the upside there. Basically, this trade is Vernon Wells (who is better than Soriano) and David DeJesus and Aaron Harang (who add up to Utley). This is a must trade because looking at your team, you are probably closer to the bottom of your league than the top, and you must do something to change your team.

Answer 3

Don't do any of those trades. Soriano might be hurt/not doing well now but it's not even a month into a season so don't give up on his yet. There's a reason why the Cubs paid him 136$ million. Chase Utley is BY FAR the best 2b in baseball so don't bother trading him unless you're getting someone better in another position. The 2b position is so thin.

He's not offering as good as what he wants. Vernon Wells is pretty good but he's not a first rounder in most fantasy league.

Answer 4

Ask for (Haraang, Wells, Jeter) and give him Soriano and Cuddyer. No way in hell is Soriano and Utley worth those 3 players he offered u. Not to mention u had better sell Soriano high cuase he'l get hot. Dont be too bothered if in the end the trade doesnt work out with this guy, cuase u still hav Soriano and Utley!!!!!!! not to mention Cuddyer is gonna cool down somewhat.






Just for the record, u should trade one of ur closers for a 1b

Answer 5

You need to be looking for quality starters and not be messing around with Utley, Ramirez & Soriano! The only good player that you have been offered is Jeter, I've never been a Wells fan and consider him way overpaid. The other bats he is dangling are all on hot streaks, they have no history. Your pitching is definitely a sore spot...you need to be concentrating on that! Package Dempster & Fuentes for a #2 or #3 starter.

Answer 6

These trdes are hilarious. You give up two top 7 players
(by the way how did you get to draft to top 7 guys?!!?!?) and you get one stud and a stud for 2 months in Kelly Johnson and DeJesus? I hate all those trade offers for you. Looking at your team your weakness is definitely starting pitching and at closer. Soriano and Utley for Wells, Johnson and a stud pitcher. This is what you should demand. Your giving up 2 top 7 guys man!!!

Answer 7

Offer Soriano, Hardy and Valverde for Wells, Harang, and DeJesus

Answer 8

this isn't even close. No commerce. Navarro is a superior catcherbut Harden if extra efficient than Lilly and Fielder is extra efficient at his position than Navarro. i'm questioning once you've a 1B already and considering that of this you're even searching at this commerce? if so, you could make a extra efficient deal than this one. you'll stumble on a back-up on the FA list.

Answer 9

To put it simpley. #1 No. #2 No. #3 NO #4 No

Answer 10

they are all HORRIBLE TRADES!!! dont even think about any of them. the person proposing them is trying to take complete advantage of u!!!