Should people in the Southern Hemisphere have different horoscopes to those in the North?

Question

I mean some of the constellations that make up the Zodiac are not even visible from the S Hemisphere.

Answer 1

I wouldn't even try to introduce scientific questions into a realm of "knowledge" that ignores everything scientific that we know about what the planets and constellations are.

If you want to do that, why not start off with, "Do people born in a certain month around the world really share certain traits that the others don't?" I think you know what you'd find.

Astrology is a pseudoscientific cultural hangover from the days when people (esp. Greeks & Romans) looked at the mysterious lights in the sky as deities with power over us. It's well past time to move on.

Answer 2

EVERYBODY should have different horoscopes. They are all off by a month because of drift in the way the planet rotates. That wonderful "science" (gag) that people put so much stock in is flawed. But it's gotta be right though; Hitler won WW II using it.

The sun is not in the sign the astrologers say it is. Here is an article; you can find your new sign and get rid of your spouse, find some one compatible and change your way of living.

http://www.geocities.com/astrologyzodiacs/realsolarzodiac.htm

Answer 3

No they don't.

http://www.greatcom.org/resources/handbook_of_todays_religions/02chap01/default.htm