indian people created integers they invented numbers then why did leopold kronecker said god created integers?

Question

And also people say that newton invented calculus but bhaskara was before his time he has derived about limits and aryabhatta have derived many trigonometric ratios and mathematical stuffs why do they say that newton invented calculus as bhaskara had already invented calculus which was found in the book called lilavathi

Answer 1

Ben Franklin did not invent electricity either. It was there already...same for the numbers. They were discovered by man...not made by them.

Calculus is a coherent system. That construct was made by Newton, not the principal behind it.

Answer 2

Because if you are religious, then you quite often consider that God is the creator of everything, before he created the universe there was nothing. Actually nothing, not just a vacuum because even that is space and time which is something. It's impossible to imagine nothing, but I guess its a bit like when you're in a deep sleep. You don't remember being alseep, but you were. Then God created everything, physics, maths, people, animals. I personally don't believe in creationism, but many people do.

And as for Newton and Leibniz being credited with calculus, it was known a long time, even the ancient Greeks had some understanding of it. It was they who first used the notation we are familiar with and rigorously proved results using analysis. Mathematics went under a cultural revolution at this point and it was agreed that everything had to be perfectly, rigorously proven. Before this, mathematics was much more slap-dash.

Answer 3

This is becoz God resides in every human. God is in U, God is in me, God is everywhere. But the accurate answer is God created integers and many things like it. It is correct to say that Indian people discovered integers. We can even say that God in the form of Indian people created integers.
So applies for calculus too. Some people believe that God does everything for them. So they say that God has done that. If they are hurt also they say that God has hurt them and that hurt is good as God does everything good. Now u call such people mad, foolish or anything but whatever they say is true. God has created universe. Creator of everything in the Universe including the Earth, the Sun and even U is the one and only Almighty. He does everything good and wants every one to be good. The function of human is his daily routine work but the function of the highest minds of Earth is to just discover what God has created. Everything is there but the missing thingis that U don't discover them. Try to discover and U can be in the list if the Highest minds of Earth name list. Hope U get UR answer in my long answer and thanks for the 2 points.

Answer 4

wow. i think we've god to thank for the derivation of pi to boot. thumbs up for faith................................... @douchebag do not insult me or any of those human beings via preaching from a e book whos cultural important died with einstein. pi grew to become into first derived long earlier your e book grew to become into written, first noticably used interior the egyptian pyramids, and later derived to a astounding accuracy via archimedes, nonetheless earlier the time of your saviour. So please, do not recommend that pi is shown via some precis interpretation of hebrew numbers in a e book written via prophets who concept the international grew to become into flat. AND WHY might i ask are you throwing euler's id around like that's some variety of evidence... particular. it exists. all of us comprehend. it would not in any way mean that god created imaginary numbers?!? what's incorrect with you. AND wtf does 'the blunders virtually cancel eachother out' recommend?!?!? are you retarded? have you ever any concept of mathematical workings?

Answer 5

there is a difference between inventing and discovering.

newton didn't invent gravity... he discovered it.

Answer 6

its becausae God made the epople who DISCOVED them