what are the theories to deside man of the series???

Question

I mean i still don't get it.... they showed that Mcgrath on top with 12 points Mahela in the second slot with 11 Murali...... Last????

even though murali took 23 wkt in 9 matches and Mcgrath who is on top with 22 wkt in 9 matches we all knw that he dont contribute with bat so what makes the selectors to give him 12 points as man of the series???

Answer 1

Dear I also dont Know.

Answer 2

in this example especially, relevance of wickets comes into consideration more heavily. for example, 5/ against holland is insignificant in comparison to 5/ against australia.

i didnt know man of the series was done so publically and formulaeically, though..?

i think the man of the series should generally go to the biggest contributor of the series of the team who wins (usually a batter.. unfortunately). for example, matthew hayden, should trends continue, should be man of the series. if south africa win, smith or kallis, and so forth.
unless there is some godly performance elsewhere - such as someone from the losing side amassing 150+ runs more than the stand-out player from the winning side, or something.

of course, its all incredibly subjective, but thats how i feel.. the suspense created by, and the integrity and esteem of the award (MotS) itself is sacrificed if people know the result before it has been awarded.

Answer 3

well man of the series has not yetr been decided pal
they lopok on all aspects not jus the highest wicket taker but his consistency n any different style in his play
wait n watch it'll definitely b an Aussie dey r real gud

Answer 4

Money makes everything go round

Answer 5

defeat or win depends on performance of players. sl win is example for taht
Congratulations to SL team lankans are playing brilliantly as one unit.All playes are

supporting and performaing for team cause not for sponsers or self records
same SL team was defeated by ind team 6-1 when team had no politician super player in playing XI under captaincy of dravid

some superstar senior players betryed team
captian and millions of fans by playing
back stage polticis
senior players let down team and major role in early exit of WC
politics
ppl blame ccaptain for team ind wC early exit ry easy to blame captain, What about other 10 players players%u2019s the lack of commtiment , lack of passion to win/perform, , poor body languge or groupism or petty politics played against captain and coach spending time in crease for sponsers cause, playing for self records, many players think they are leaders and not to led by skipper, superstar attitude ..
dravid played under sachin and ganguly captaincy and gave 100 % commited performance but trusted same from senior players and backfired by sachin, ganguly, dhoni bajji zahir and yuvrag…..
matching orders of team india
http://worldcup.indiatimes.com/quickiearticleshow/msid-1807342.cms
The real culprits by S Rajesh
http://contentgulf.cricinfo.com/india/content/current/story/288746.html

While India's players blame their recent poor form on e coach to a sense of insecurity to captain, the plain truth is this: When it really mattered, India's batsmen failed to deliver.

Captaincy myths

Names Matches Won Lost Drawn/Tied Won%
SC Ganguly 146 76 65 5 52.05%
R Dravid 65 33 28 4 50.77%
players who supported back stage poltics, now realised that it can cost their place in team
since many youngsters are knocking the door of team it will difficult get back if once out of team
Ganguly had advantage of leading team for maximu nos of matches and 5 yr lengthier period and 31 wins against weaker team dravid only captian for 16 months and difference in winning average is only 1.22%
Indian express poll 75% favoured dropping sachin and ganguly for odi series against BL
80% ppl approved bcci move to drop senior players TOI poll
65% voted in favouring the bcci decision to rest superstars while dravid's supports to retain him as captain increased even after ongoing dravid bashing articles..
80% of cricket associanton (survey in ndtv) supporte dravid.
,. IBN CNN survey 86% ppl voted for dravid.. Sachin may be living legend but he is no more bigger than team or game