Fantasy Football RB Keeper Question (lots of options)...?

Question

I have to keep one, Shawn Alexander, Cedric Benson, Dominic Rhodes, Willie Parker, Thomas Jones, Tatum Bell, or Brandon Jacobs

Answer 1

Cedric Benson. He is young - has the entire team to himself with no competition. Thomas Jones and Shawn Alexander have had a lot of touches and are over the half way point in their careers - plus Alexander looked ordinary last season without Hutchinson blocking for him. Jacobs has potential but until he learns to run downhill he will not be a full-time RB. He runs to straight up which allow him to get hit hard and causes fumbles. Rhodes and Bell are RB's that will have competition and play on teams with less than stellar running O-lines. Parker is probably the next best pick - even though he has had a lot of touches and is smaller - he seems to be holding up...but he has a style and build familiar to DeShawn Foster - who after a stellar season has been unable to stay healthy as the focus RB.

Answer 2

First I would ask, how did you got that many good RBs on your team? The rest of your league must have been asleep all season.
Rhodes and Bell are at best sharing the workload, so I wouldn't keep them. Brandon Jacobs is the man now, but my guess is the Giants draft someone else to share the load with him. I like Parker and Jones more than Benson, just because of the QB situations on those teams. However, I still think that Alexander is in the best situation with his line and those players surrounding him. I think he was a little banged up most of last year and he should come back with better numbers than last year. Keep Alexander.

Answer 3

I'd have to keep Alexander. This is will be benson's first as a full time starter, Rhodes is now on a horrible team, Jones now has a horrible line, Bell is now an afterthought, Jacobs has now big play ability. The only question is Parker, and of the two Alexander is the better back and still has a few years left in the tank.

Answer 4

Alexander or Parker. I would take Alexander because the Seahawks have a better front line and qb.

2nd tier: jacobs is the real deal and could be a huge in 2007.

Stay away: Bell and Jones

Answer 5

Willie Parker. As long as he doesnt get the Madden Cover he will be very good for a long time. He is also one of the youngest guys on there. So Id have to say Willie Parker

Answer 6

I would keep Parker and Jones. Try to sucker someone into trading you for Alexander while he still has value. He may have one more good year in him but that should be it. He is approaching that magic "30" years old number where a running backs numbers start to decline.

Answer 7

First i might ask, how did you acquire that many good RBs on your group? something of your league would desire to have been asleep all season. Rhodes and Bell are at suitable sharing the workload, so i would not shop them. Brandon Jacobs is the guy now, yet my wager is the Giants draft somebody else to share the burden with him. i admire Parker and Jones extra advantageous than Benson, basically using QB circumstances on those communities. even though, I nevertheless think of that Alexander is in the suitable situation along with his line and those gamers surrounding him. i think of he became right into somewhat banged up maximum of final twelve months and he would desire to come again with extra advantageous numbers than final twelve months. shop Alexander.

Answer 8

i like willie parker. He can handle the workload and has proven to be a great commodity for the Steelers.

Answer 9

I would keep Alexander. He already is a proven star, and still has a few years left in his legs.