Fantasy baseball trade?

Question

12 team head to head..
Should I trade Miguel Cabrera and Hanley Ramirez for Jose Reyes and Justin Morneau..??

Answer 1

Fair trade from a numbers standpoint. Now you need to see if your roster has a good 3rd baseman to replace Cabrera and who is your 1st baseman now? The rest of your roster will dictate whether this is a good deal for you or not, if you are set at 1st and have garbage to backup your 3rd base slot then it is a bad deal. If you have a good 3rd baseman backup and your 1st base slot isnt very good then it is a good deal. 3rd base is a harder spot to fill with solid fantasy talent so from that standpoint Cabrera figures to be more valuable than Morneau but you need to look at what you have and then decide if the deal makes you better or worse overall. Ryes is slightly better than Ramirez (I said slightly...very close overall and I wouldnt be a bit surprised if Ramirez puts up nearly identical numbers to Reyes) so that part of the deal is pretty much a wash.

Answer 2

Your getting the better deal.
Most people don't really know how good Hanley did last year (unless you had, like i did). He really only he 20 less rbis than Jose, but is being drafted 2 rounds later.
Though Justin Morneau and Jose Reyes are two good first round picks that will both give you speed, power and rbis. (81 from Reyes ;) )
Though its a pretty fair deal.
Miguel Cabrera is great for average, some homers and good rbis.
Your gonna end up with a pretty good team either way.

Answer 3

this isn't even close. No commerce. Navarro is a strong catcherbut Harden if better functional than Lilly and Fielder is better functional at his position than Navarro. i'm wondering once you've a 1B already and it really is the reason you're even searching at this commerce? if so, you may make a better functional deal than this one. you'll detect a lower back-up on the FA record.

Answer 4

dont know what numbers ramirez is putting up but trade looks fair

Answer 5

Go for it, it sounds about even to me.