Since Peyton Manning won a superbowl, would you consider him better than Tom Brady overall?

Answer 1

No. Sorry to say this is the most overdone question in the world. Really everyone should wait to the end of their careers to pass judgement on who is better. At this point Brady is the better QB. It also depends what you use as a judgement of "better." There is no denying Manning has nasty numbers but when it comes down to it who has been more succesful? Brady! Brady has won 3 Superbowl whiel Manning has only won 1. I also think that Brady will get his 4th ring this year and that will just further the proof that Brady is better. Also, look at the weapons that Manning has compared to Brady. If you swicthed their teams Brady would still win but I do not think that Manning oculd survive without all the weapons he has. Brady is a big game QB and the better of the two, Manning is a close second.

Answer 2

Lets look at stats starting with the 2001 season.
(I do have a Brady bias, but I'll try and put that aside)

Games Started:
Brady: 95
Manning: 96
Winner: Tie (Brady didn't start until the second game of the 2001 season)

Pass Attempts / Completions / Percentage:
Brady: 3063 / 1895 / 61.9%
Manning: 3211 / 2117 / 65.9%
Winner: Manning (slight)

Passing Yards:
Brady: 21558
Manning: 25299
Winner: Manning

Touchdowns:
Brady: 147
Manning: 190
Winner: Manning

Interceptions:
Brady: 78
Manning: 81
Winner: Brady (slight)

Passer Ratings:
Brady: 88.4
Manning: 99.1
Winner: Manning

Player for player, Manning is the better player. Lets examine how they were able to help the team as a whole.

Team Records:
NE: 70-26 (72.9%)
IND: 66-30 (68.8%)
Winner: NE (Slight)

Playoff Appearances:
NE: 5
IND: 5
Winner: Tie

Playoff Records:
NE: 12-2 (85.7%)
IND: 7-4 (58.3%)
Winner: NE

Super Bowl Wins:
NE: 3
IND: 1
Winner: NE

In the Team Category, Brady stands out. In the same number of Playoff appearances, the Pats have had 12 wins which is an average of appearing in the AFC Championship each playoffs. They've also had more Super Bowl wins, at 3.

I won't argue that as a player Peyton Manning is the best QB in the league right now. Brady's strength is that he makes the best of his ability and the team results show that.

Answer 3

Tom Brady- 3 Super Bowls, Peyton Manning-1 Super Bowl. No.

Answer 4

Manning still played absolutely dreadful throughout the playoffs. When Manning can lead his team to a superbowl on a consistent basis like Tom Brady has, I'll consider him better. Tom Brady is a proven leader with 3 superbowl rings, out of only 5 years as a starting QB.

Answer 5

I think Manning has always been considered the more skilled QB but Brady is considered more of a winner. The Super Bowl win punched Manning's HOF ticket but Brady has him beaten 3 to 1 in Super Bowls. When all is said and done, barring major injury, Manning will go down in history as one of the greatest QB's of all time. And probably will hold most of the passing records. Brady will be considered one of the greats as well, but the only record he might have is Super Bowl wins. I expect he'll get a shot to win a couple more. So I guess to answer your question I think the consensus is that Peyton Manning is the more skilled player. So overall if I had the choice between the two I take Manning. Historically Manning will be remembered as the better of the two, but Brady will make it a great argument.

Answer 6

First off Brady has 3 superbowl rings and hasnt been in the league as long as Peyton... second off Peyton alone did not win the superbowl it was the WHOLE team. More impressive of Brady because he was picked number 180 in the draft in the 6th round.

Answer 7

Not even close. Peyton Manning has won 1 super bowl with a lot of talent on him on offense and defense. Also he wasn't exactly great in any of the playoff games. 3 pics against baltimore and it was his defense that won most of the games for them. Brady on the other hand already has 3 super bowls and is much younger than Manning and will more likely win more. Brady hasn't exactly been surrounded with as much talent as Manning has. He has been coming through in a cluth and may not have the numbers but knows how to get the victory and be reliable and that's what matters

Answer 8

Nope
Tom Brady won 3 rings

Answer 9

How accessible.. You ask this question precise after Peyton has the worst activity in his nfl occupation. no count number how tremendous a quarterback is, they're able to having a nasty activity like this and in the previous this season Tony romo(6 turnovers). That being suggested, I nevertheless imagine Peyton is the perfect quarterback contained in the league. you won't be able to say "tom brady is extra acceptable, look he led his team to three tremendous bowls." it really is real he did that, yet that's because he had the hot England Patriots as his team. If Brady had the Indianapolis colts the previous years, I honestly doubt he ought to have had as a lot success. Tom brady has the posh of arguably the perfect receiver contained in the nfl. He in basic terms randomly throws up a ball in Randy's position and Moss does his magic. it really is not any longer because Tom threw it with precision, notwithstanding it really is extra because of how sturdy Randy is. ok time to flow, savour my rant.

Answer 10

Not Till He wins 2 more superbowls in the next 3 years.