Who Do You Believe to be the Biggest Draft Bust?

Question

Culpepper. God does he suck!

Culpepper......God does he suck! BTW, I'm a Vikes fan, and I never ever liked the guy. Big guy, small hands, and even smaller brain. For the $$ they shelled out for him, he didn't do ****!

Answer 1

I would say Tim Couch, but he never should have been drafted that high. He was far too stupud to learn an NFL offense, and all he did at Kentucky was throw the ball at the guy with the blue helmet.

So instead I'll say Ryan Leaf. Did you know he is now the quarter back coach at West Texas A&M? Look it up.

Answer 2

Culpepper was not a bust at all he had productive seasons with the Vikings and now is recovering from knee injuries. Ron Dayne didnt live up to the hype but has had some mildly productive seasons. It is Ryan Leaf by far. He was compared to Payton Manning and the experts were mixed on who would be the #1 pick. Now he coaches golf at a college.

Answer 3

Being a New York Giants fan, i'd have to say Ron Dayne was the biggest bust ever.
Heisman Trophy winner, no less, and the guy couldnt get more than 2 yards each carry. Fat Bastid.

Ryan Leaf is a close 2nd, though.

By the way, Culpepper wasnt really a bust. The guy played many years in Minnesota and got them winning records. They just couldnt make it to the big game.
He sucks NOW, now that he's hurt and all. Watching him play in Miami, you could sense like he lost his nerve for the game.

Answer 4

Well if your a Vikings fan then you must be happy about the biggest draft bust the Packers drafting Tony Mandarich was the biggest bust ever. Tony was drafted before guys like Barry Sanders and Deion Sanders.

Answer 5

Are you serious Dante Culpepper is a great QB. But i guarantee you Marshawn Lynch is gonna be the biggest draft bust in NFL history.

Answer 6

Ryan Leaf is the poster boy. Also consider Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Audray Bruce and Ki-jana Carter as some recent busts.

Culpepper has been to a couple of Pro-Bowls and has had some good seasons.

Answer 7

Ryan Leaf by far...
Detriot Wrs minus Roy Williams (Charles Rodgers and Mike Williams)
and Robert Gallery HAHA...


But this years draft i think the biggest bust will be Brady Quinn. he might be good but hes never won a major game in his career... plus Notre Dame sucks haha

Answer 8

I go old school with this. When Green Bay Picked Tony Mandarich #2 overall to build their offensive line about 15 yrs ago. He never broke into the lineup and "retired" about 2 yrs later. I believe he did try a comeback but it failed miserably.

Note David Pollack of the Bengals should not be considered due to his neck injury -- Get well David.

Answer 9

Adrian Peterson is going to be the niggest draft bust this year
He is so hyped uo pas being the best rb but he isnt
Hes coming off an injury and hes going to be injured in the NFL. With his upright running hes going to take big hits and it will only be a matter of time till hes off the field

Answer 10

I might be a little early in saying this but I think its Eli manning. If you look at what the giants gave up for him, their first that year which was phillip rivers, there first the following year which became shawne merriman and their third from that year which is there kicker nate kaeding, and you see how much of a bust Manning is. Think about it the giants gave up Merriman and kaeding who were in the Pro Bowl this year and rivers who was in the top tier of the nfl in terms of stats for a below average quarterback and you see why