I have a SOLUTION TO THE KASHMIR CONFLICT???

Question

I have a perfect Solution to the Kashmir Conflict:

According to the Pakistani government and citizenry, Pakistan has a rightful and just claim to Kashmir because the majority of the people in Kashmir are Muslims, right???

Well, the Pakistani government is forgetting that India has the world's second largest Muslim population (although they comprise only 12% of the Indian population - 83% being hindu). I think there are approximately 150 million Muslims who constitute India's Muslim minority.

My solution is this:
We can say to Pakistan that we will ONLY relinquish control of Kashmir to yourselves, IF YOU TAKE ALL INDIA'S MUSLIMS, ALONG WITH KASHMIR AND GRANT THEM CITIZENSHIP OF PAKISTAN!!!

I don't mean to sound heartless and I apologise if I have caused any offence. But the purpose of 1947 partition was so that India can become a Muslim free zone.

Do you agree with me??? Ain't I right??? Pakistan should open its borders to India's Muslims and only then get kashmir?

Plato, I disagree with you.

Firstly Muslims might be your brothers, but they are not mine.

Secondly, the fact that Hinduism is the majority religion, adheres to the idea that

hinduism=Indianism and Indianism=Hinduism.

Why is it fair for Muslims to champion Islam in Muslim states, for Christians to champion Chrsitianity in Christian states, but Hindus can't champion Hinduism in a Hindu state??? Why is it that Hindus are always expected to compromise their love and passion and pride for their religion in the interests of "secularism"??? In those countries where Hindus are a minority (like here in the UK) we don't demand that the majority compromise their love and affection for their religion for the sake of Hindus, so why do India's minorities expect us Hindus to comrpmise our Hinduness for them??? Especially those minorities that should have left in 1947???

Mr chandrasekharan k,

I have not dragged any "4th party" into the equation. This 4th party was, from the getgo, part of the problem and cause of the lashmir controversy. You are forgetting that we do not live in a vacuum. We live in a world of "cause and effect" and one where "every action has a reaction". God didn't just start civilisation in 2007. But the events and problems that are being experienced today, are a chain of events that started since islam intruded and trespassed into India in the 7th century. So called India's Muslims have always been the root cause for the kashmir controversy. They are not a new party to the event. In 1947 India agreed to lose large parts of our country (that had belonged to us for thousands and thousands of years) because the Muslims didn't want to live with us. Then, in the end they still didn't all end up leaving. So your argument is illogical.

Answer 1

Good for you, pal.

Answer 2

A few muslim activists wanted a separate state for muslims. That was the reason for 1947 partition. Partition wasn't commenced to establish a separate hindu state.

As far as Kashmir is concerned, it is a part of India and will remain a part of India no matter what happens. And about the muslims in India, they are Indians, they are our brothers. YOu cannot compare them to pakistanis. India is a country with pretty large range of cultures, languages, and religions. Hinduism is not the identity of an Indian. The identity is Indian-ness. Separateing the country based on religions will just split apart the country. The presence of India would gradually fade away.

Pakistan may call Indian muslims as their religious brothers, but when it comes to acceptance, just remember what's happenning with taaliban.

Edit 01:

You talk about Hinduism, and so called Hindu scripts have always preached brotherhood, harmony, peace.

Secondly, the term Hindu was used by the europeans to refer the people residing beyond the valleys of river Sindhu. These europeans had no idea what religion those people belonged to. The so called Hindu scriptures have no descritpion of the term Hindu. Hindusim is a cutlure, a way of living. It's not a religion

Just because few people around the world follow a stupid inhumanitarian path doesn't mean that we should follow the same. And if you think driving away Muslims would solve the nations problems, then please tell me how the hell are you gonna solve the problems related to ALFA's, ULFA's, BODO's, Naxalites, etc.? They are all hindu terrorist organizations in India.

If you really wanna help the nation, then please utilize your time in spreading patriotism, spread the feeling of Indian-ness, the sense of unity among Indians. Donot try to widen the rifts.

All the best...

:-)

Answer 3

I"m not sure it would work because any Muslims in India aren't going to back up and leave so they can move to Pakistan. That would be like All the Muslims here moving to Mexico. Why would you want to down Grad? Not to mention that the people that live in Kashmir would be pretty miffed.

Answer 4

Oh you again! You are definitely a sick person who has all his facts wrong. Your have Islam-o-phobia. First allow me to get your facts right. Pakistan was not created to make India Muslim free country. It was made to satisfy the leaders who refused to share power. For your information the partition has had worst effect on the Muslims. Their people, their intellectuals and their leader all got divided. The Muslims of both the countries were really orphaned. And people like you and the kind of organisations you support are not allowing those wounds to get cured. You forget that now a whole new generation has changed. And let us for a moment believe that the partition was a crime committed by the Muslims, I have never understood why majority of Muslims preferred to stay back in India, knowing fully well that here they will be a minority ? When there are so many Muslim countries why do Muslim Indians prefer to live in India? To one of your earlier question I have replied that it is high time, people like you and the organisation that you support, understand one basic fact- that the Muslim Indians are Indians by conviction and by choice. The gates of Pakistan were open for them but they chose to stay here because THIS IS THEIR COUNTRY AND THEY BELONG TO THIS COUNTRY. And no bigot can push them any where. You don't just sound heartless but you are heartless. Hatred is running in your blood. You are kind of people who create extremists. You need to be cured. Because you are a potential danger to Peace in India. Again get your facts right before entering in such serious forum of debates. If Hindus comprise of 83% then you mean to say that 2% that comprises of the rest of th Indian population includes Christians, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhist, Jews, etc. Because 15% according to you are Muslims. Now about Kashmir, when Kashmir was annexed into Indian Union, a time frame was set after which there was to be a plebisite in which the right of choise was to remain with Kashmiri people as to which country they would like to associat with. That referandum never took place. So let Kashmiri people decide their fate. And pray can you explain what is Hinduism? Then we can decide if Indianism=Hinduism.

Answer 5

i m sorry but you are not fully aware of the Kashmir problem.
during the time of Independence the region of Kashmir was a princely state. it was advised that the princely states should join either Pakistan or India.Pakistan attacked Kashmir in order to capture it . the king then joined India. but that is where the problem aroused from. Pakistan attacked the state of Kashmir and so they feel that it should be under their control. while the king decided to join India so according to India it is its part.
you think it is very easy for people to change places. shifting the Muslims to Pakistan is not a game. it might seem the easiest solution to you but you will not know the sufferings they will undergo. it is the toughest task in fact.

Answer 6

Exactly, what you expressed is correct. But, Pakistan will never say so. On the contrary Muslims are more safe in India and they never want to go to Pakistan. Kashmir will no more be a conflict because... Pakistanis now want to merge with Hindustan as they have experienced the safety and understanding nature of people is only in Hindustand and nowhere in this world.....

Answer 7

This is all vote politics, i.e., Hindu or muslims.

Their is no problem between two but other make it. Kasmir is not a problem if we consider your words even we can take controll of pakistan in few days but it will also be not the solution. The solution to this problem is that country first and religion latter.

Answer 8

As you know there is pullution around the issue which is trying to find solution in Kashmir. When Pakistan itself was given to muslims cutting India into 3 pieces(India, Pakistan
(West) & Pakistan (East) on the basis of religion (muslim majority areas!)... Pakistan was born out of hatred...against Hindus.. due to few persons like Jinna. But remember religion could not hold them together as a Nation and same Pakistan was divided into two parts Bangla Desh and Pak. in 1971. They killed their own brothers due to Power politics of Julfikar Ali Bhutto. In Kashmir after the freedom in 1947 the Muslims killed and chased out lakhs of Kashmiri Pandits and they are refugees in other part of India. While freedom fighting was on Hindus and Muslims also were together but with the freedom Muslims who opted to remain in India stayed back... out of whom .. few muslims are having their relatives in Pakistan and Bangladesh. As you know in secular India... Nation first and religion later. But for muslims religion first and Nation later! which is the main cause ...root cause of all evils. It is only those handful of muslims who are used as instruments by the terrorists of Pakistan for creating disturbances anywhere in India and our real patriotic muslim brothers of India are looked with suspicious eyes . However if the muslims of India take care of those muslims who do antinational activities in India there can be peace. As we know most muslims in India wants good and cordial relationship with each other. But they are tight lipped . Even in Kashmir many muslim brothern feel that Kashmir Pandits are the sons of the Soil of Kashmir which is integral part of India. So the solution can be there when humanity wins over religion and let us hope the talks now going on this direction at high level brings everlasting peace once for all as a solution once for all.

Answer 9

well....to some extent u r right. but what about those muslims in india who r very indian and very patriotic about india? there are quite a few such muslims in our country.and they wud love to stay back here and be called indians.

so we can't simply generalise and ask all muslims to go away. remember? india is secular...still!

anyway formation of pakistan was a mistake in the first place...

to please jinnah this blunder of seperating pakistan was done.
and an irrepairable damage happened to the country called india and it's people.

so may be it should rejoin india and live in harmony.

impossible dream..eh? :-)

Answer 10

That would never happen. Look at the conflicts moving folks caused when Pakistan wanted to be separate in the first place.

I think Kashmir maybe should become its own little country.

Answer 11

The Person propagating falsehood and enemity among the people, as his custom, tradition, culture and way of life is severely infected with the virus & bacteria of chronic hate, hatred and enemity against those who profess and practise a religion, accepted universally. His genes & DNAs are also infected so seriously. To protect his children (to be born) against such infections, he should join and remain in the company of sensible, true, learned, educated, justified, honest and healthy males for NIYOGA or else his evil, false and deceptive thoughts will spread more.

The present India consisted of thousands of small kingdoms, all ruled by locals. The Muslims settled down in India and made it their mother land. They united the small kingdoms and made it into Bharat Mata. They never interfered into the belief & faith of the locals. Locals also never considered them enemies, but welcomed.

India is a country of multi religion, region, language, custom, tradition, culture, costume, food habits, etc. All live together sharing each others joys and sorrows. 99+% people are very peace loving. 1% miscreants wanted to disturb the peace & tranquility of India but failed. Knowledge is spreading. Truths and falsehoods are being separated. Truths will always prevail and the falsehood will end. Muslims living in India have rejected the Pakistan and opted for India. Enemity against them will not help in Indian development. They always participate in the well being of their mother land.

Fanatic Hindus burnt and destroyed and are burning & destroying hundreds/thousands of churches in India and are continuing these nefarious acts openly & fearlessly in the daylight. The strongest Hindu organisations Bajrang Dal and Ruling Parties Shiv Sena and BJP publicly support it and claim it their success. The Australian preacher of Christianity and his son were burnt alive in their vehicle by a mob of fanatic Hindus, none got the punishment but rewarded. These fanatics challenge that except Hindus none should remain in India. Can they succeed? Are they thus serving the mother land? 99% Hindus condemn them and have sympathies with the victims.

To put a powerful brake upon spreading hatred & enemity among Indians, it is diagonised that such chronic infected cannot be cured and only preventive remedy can be useful. Such infected is prescribed to avail of the company of healthy and sincere gentlemen for NIYOGA to save future children from his such infection.